Try and make it in the region of around 14-18 tracks long. You don't really have to stick to just using your No.1 band, you can decide on whoever you want to use. Try not to exceed the 80 minute mark, if you are using a band that has mostly long tracks then you don't need to stick to the 14-18 track guideline.

This is mine, for Muse.

1. New Born
2. Stokholm Syndrome
3. Unintended
4. Dead Star
5. Citizen Erased
6. Map Of The Problematique
7. Bliss
8. Hysteria
9. Assassin
10.Sunburn
11.Plug In Baby
12.Showbiz
13.Butterflies & Hurricanes
14.City Of Delusion
15.Space Dementia
16.Muscle Museum
17.Time Is Running Out

It appears that in general I prefer more of the singles from the first 3 albums, (Absolution especially) but prefer the album tracks from Black Holes & Revelations. I might actually make this into a compilation, I've done one for Muse before but it was before they released BH&R.

I love making lists. :)