Sign In:
Login with Facebook

sean

Comments



jimi

we calculated the list using the seeds of these comments http://drownedinsound.com/news/4135904 - not a lot of hip hop in there either.

my suggestion: start championing what should be in there, not moaning about what isn't in there.

eh?

that's a dumb post and i dont even know what the line of best fit is? we're big supporters of Bella Union and the likes of Beach House were in our long list. Having heard the Andrew Bird album i wouldn't put it past them filling our list next year.

Week that Was fans

you'll be pleased to know we also have the Lost 8 of '08 feature coming up!

yeah thanks mike (i don't get your Kills beef!)

I haven't stopped playing the Kills album since it came in and it was in a huge amount of both staff and readers top 8 album of the year lists, so nur-nur-nur, go back to listening to JoFo and talk about what you love, and ignore what you don't.

i was surprised

that very few people mentioned Flying Locus and they didn't really feature in our coverage

that's my fault

for being a shite sub-editor

grrr

stupid new html.

really?

blimey, i didn't spot that reported anywhere else

yeah

that was announced elsewhere last week but tis only in america

me also

yes

and also i think you can wear them to school too!

yeah

he put 7 but there's something broken with the release database and Tom is away graduating today

reason being

reviews are often the opinion of one person. we don't have some grubby party line but we do try to encourage our writers to think both subjectively and objectively.

weakest, wut?

this album is brilliant and has had such an incredible influence on my life/music taste. it's amazing that we get something like this and there's instantly some moaners moaning.

erm

I think Dodgy did it already :)

not had them do one for us yet

am sure they will in due course

sorry

my fault. forgot sheff is monday, manchester is tuesday and that my brain dont work BC (before caffeine).

get people voting

at least one of those is likely to be in the DiS end of year, proper.

nothing's been kicked out

that's just the top 15

"i want to hear what these people like, not what they don't."

is very much what i want DiS to be about.

the idea of the column

is kinda older bands who inspired a raft of newer bands i.e. if you like this brand new band check out these older acts that you might not be aware of. and then the alternating fortnight it's an older album and some of the things it has influenced. it's a two way street of hopefully people will discover some things which it's assumed they already know about in columns like this.

in other news

returning editor of DiS is not a fan... still haven't managed to listen to the album all the way through.

just sayin'...

we've changed the way comments work

now in order of when they're posted.

tis the thoughts of one man

he couldn't see everything... feel free to write your own reviews of your highlights.

was picked by rough trade

DiS' top 50 is still yet to be compiled, innit.

that's why

Raz contributed Thrash Hits thoughts to our predictive thinking article: http://drownedinsound.com/in_depth/4135730

some of the articles

appear here http://drownedinsound.com/search?q=dis+tips&commit=Go

there's never been any grand editorial line with these tips and despite their impact are very much down to the most involved in the site individuals at the time.

well

there's still more to come. this was just some very early on things people were excited about. surprised not to hear a mention of Big Pink too.

link plz

sadly not

i've read this phrase a few places lately, including here http://fearandwords.tumblr.com/

shush

there are plenty more parts of this coming up over the next few weeks

confusingly

this review fell back into our queue when we put some new features online, so anyone feeling like they're suffering from groundhog day you really aren't going crazy

cus

4 is not recommended, 5 is average, 6 is good but not for everyone, 7 is recommended for most tastes, 8 is pretty exceptional everyone should check it out, 9 is album of the year contender, 10 is perfection

really?

worked fine an hour ago

it's pretty hard

to give an individual insight without, yuhknow, talking as one person living through one set of events. if you want the skinny mass version of events there are about 2trillion news outlets and media formats to digest it in.

yeah

someone posted something which was exclusive to DiS

gawd knows

something's broken overnight. should be fixed in a little bit.

yeah

the concept of "we" is a ridiculous one.

not into this myself

it's like a noughties Goo Goo Dolls, feels very calculated...

yeah

DiS did promote their second ever gig at the Dublin Castle, with, if memory serves, Bloc Party as support (possibly in one of their pre-Bloc carnations)

you cared enough to click

read.
and type out a comment.
and probably come back to read my comment and reply to it. all of which could have been time spent being positive about something you do love.
dis isn't a ghetto, there's room for evaluation of all types of music which trickles into our world.

sorry

the press release didn't say that. shoot 'em!

that's subjective

i really enjoyed it

yeah... sorry.

i forgot to put this up on thursday and was outta the office most of friday

there is room for both

and for more