I have been a fan since Captain & Hope but they are now by far the least listened to CD's in my idlewild collection. I really like the new CD & also loved Warnings/ Promises - El Capitan would be in my Idlewild top 5 - (although Roddy's solo CD wasn't that great apart from a couple of tracks). I would have lost interest them a long time ago if all I had heard since were Captain/ Hope carbon copies. There is nothing worse than being excited about a new CD by a favourite band & then discovering it offers nothing new compared to the previous one. Idlewilds strengh is that each album is different ot the last in my opinion.
Finished it remains, Everything (as it moves), No Emotion, If it takes you home are all fantastic. The only song I feel is a bit weak is 'In Competion' as I hate the distorted vocal.
I disagree
I have been a fan since Captain & Hope but they are now by far the least listened to CD's in my idlewild collection. I really like the new CD & also loved Warnings/ Promises - El Capitan would be in my Idlewild top 5 - (although Roddy's solo CD wasn't that great apart from a couple of tracks). I would have lost interest them a long time ago if all I had heard since were Captain/ Hope carbon copies. There is nothing worse than being excited about a new CD by a favourite band & then discovering it offers nothing new compared to the previous one. Idlewilds strengh is that each album is different ot the last in my opinion.
Finished it remains, Everything (as it moves), No Emotion, If it takes you home are all fantastic. The only song I feel is a bit weak is 'In Competion' as I hate the distorted vocal.