Sign In:
Login with Facebook

phreak

Comments



Maybe I should have said DiS lacks credibility in the review score department

Is that okay? You people should try to read between the lines. I was just pissed at the terrible score. Shoot me

Absolutely. Why do you ask?

Do you have a view of your own?

Without even reading the words this review is way off the mark

The album is great and will almost certainly get 8+ BNM on Pitchfork next week. Kind of illustrates how irrelevant DiS is at the moment

Got tickets to see them supporting both LC! and Good Shoes

and if they impress might even go see them in Derby. That EP of their's is a great listen!

This weak second half drivel needs putting to bed

Just go listen to 'This is my lot' would you and tell me it's not the album's number one jam! One song does not a second half make but the others, IMO, maintain the album's very high standards. This album is fucking cool.

Nice

Yeah this was a great gig and they didn't even play most of my faves - I was praying for an 'Instant Coffee Baby' encore. They really are a fab band.

Fan-tastic

AOTY for me.

Okay, it's a bad album and the review makes this clear

and I don't wish to sound like a twat, but what was all that talk about Dis focussing on the music it loves? What with the staff leaving and everything else.

Also, reviews of albums like this, done like this, just leave a bad taste and serve little purpose, IMO.

10 albums released last year better than Sgt Peppers?

Rubbish. I'd love to see your list of these albums. I agree with a lot of what you say, and it is all opinions of course, but, heck, 10 or more albums better than Pepper last year?! :-0

There were some great albums for sure and see your point about music moving forward. Albums today sure do sound more advanced in terms of production, sonic effect etc. and all of this is important, but I think what really makes a great album is intangible and hard to analyse. I'm struggling to explain my point but I think some albums just 'sound' special, like Pepper etc. From the past few years, of the albums I've heard, I think for example Bon Iver's album will be held up as a classic in years to come.

Anyway, mini-rant over. I'm off to listen to The Kinks Are The Village Green Preservation Society :-)

Like the sound of the songs

I've heard so will probably get this. Strings on The Airport Line are nice.

If so that would be immense

Pretty much my three favourite bands at the moment.

Also, that 'Between An Erupting Earth And An Exploding Sky' song title is too good!

I've not heard Wyatt's album

but I throughly care about a lot of the albums in this list (a lot moreso that than mercury list), esp FOTL, JoFo and TNP. Was tough call but Curses it is.

Having said that

this is a fucking good list, and great idea so well done DIS.

Los Camp and Frightened Rabbit

SHOULD BE SHORT-LISTED (IMO)! But I would have voted for Future Of The Left anyway, so nevermind.

yeah

one of the funnest live bands i've seen this year, looking forward to hearing the album.

so far

these new puritans - beat pyramid
los camp - hold on now, youngster
why? - alopecia
bon iver - for emma, forever ago
frightened rabbit - the midnight organ fight
no age - nouns

Saw them yesterday at Dot to Dot

Strong start and finish but lagged a bit in the middle. They didn't come across as being super pumped to be playing either. I was really looking forward to seeing them but they didn't quite do it for me...think i'll still check out the album though.

cool

sounds ace. can't remember if i've heard anything by this lot yet but i'll invest on the strength of this

Great record

can't stop playing it!

yeh

and they love fugazi

Still don't get

why everyone likes Neon Bibles, i think it's pretty rubbish. Also no Field Music upsets me.

Best list

I've seen so far - well done DIS!

I agree

Maccabees should be replaced with Good Shoes as the lists jangle-indie-pop representative. I really love their album.

Nice review though

.

Agreed

If this is not a 10, nothing is.

3 horse race

Between Maps, BFL and Fionn. I wouldn't be surprised if Mr Regan scooped it you know, just got a feeling.

Wow

Did her career really take off when Lily top-8’ed her?

If so, that's not only a very interesting insight into how the music industry works these days, but it must make Lily one of the most powerful people in British pop!

Great news

I loved down in albion and apparantly they actually tried during the recording of this one so I'm fairly optimistic.

Alex James (of Blur) said what he'd heard of it was ace, for what thats worth.

crap?

On top of the 2 you mentioned, there's Spoon, Fujiya & Miyagi, Pole, Gruff Rhys and quite a few others I'm quite partial to. Overall, think lineup is quite good.

Would go but its Field Day that weekend.

I don't think you read my sentence properly

unless you did of course.

Yes

They do generally seem like nice lads.

sweet lord jesus

p.s. i was backhandedly suggesting new rave is not all that

p.p.s. but i still love klaxons!

Maybe

but i bet you an nme new rave tour ticket their next album is the dogs

Give em a break

They're a breath of fresh air compared to the typical nme crap (enemy/twang/kasabian/kaisers/blah blah!!)

oh well

im a die hard libertines fan so am probably a bit biased, but c'mon, it's a choon, man!

It's a fantastic song

They've got no chance of matching its brilliance so whats the point...

I concur

art of fiction is a great little album. Plus he's great live and hangs out with cool people like emmy the great.

shit, the title of the previous post should read

isn't catastrophically terrible!

makes more sense then

I agree that the actual list is catastrophically terrible

but I prefer this list! Field Music is favourite album this year by a long way.

I might add the following:

Lucky Soul - The Great Unwanted
Good Shoes - Think Before You Speak
Gruff Rhys - Candylion
The Clientele - God Save The Clientele
The Bees - Octupus

All very nice pop albums.

It's amazing how bad this list is

compared to the canadian equivalent - http://www.polarismusicprize.ca/

To be fair to UK artists, the list could have been so much better.

Thank god

the enemy weren't nominated as touted, but i agree, where the f**k is P Wolf, or Field Music for that matter, or Good Shoes!!!

Overall, quite a crappy list. Fionn Regan has my vote though.

Cool album

and it even comes in one of those funky new cd cases. Plus the cover art is way cooler than the one shown above. Sort it out DIS!

Funny review

in a way

I was looking forward to this

because I heard they were described as the British Wolf Parade! I doubt that very much, but I reckon I'll still give this a shot on the strength of the singles and this review.

New editors is brilliant

as I'm sure this is. Last time I listened to the editors album there was plenty of substance and it's certainly a very emotionally charged album - tug on my heart strings a few times anyway.

The thing is...

when I saw them live they weren't as bad as I expected (better than the fuckin' twang anyway!). But let's be honest, its the most generic/average/brainless music imaginable and it's bands like this that give British music a bad name.

Mclusky

because their band is better than yours!

WHAT?

They were awesome at glastonbury - I was right at the front! They did play twice though so maybe we saw different shows. I watched the John Peel one.

Good album

but not as good as the first. Worth a tenner though

Field Music is the album of the year...

if not decade!!

Besides that I've enjoyed:

Deerhoof - Friend Opportunity
Patrick Wolf - The Magic Position
Electrelane - No Shouts No Calls
Arctic Monkeys - Favourite Worst Nightmare
Bloc Party - A Weekend In The City
The Clientele - God Save The Clientele
Gruff Rhys - Candylion