Sign In:
5592
Type: Album Release date: 19/01/2004
Your Rating:

Those well-schooled in the world of straight-up hardcore _à la _*Sick of it All *will be only too familiar with this raging HC style and it seems *Give Up The Ghost *are pulling no punches when it comes to where they’re channelling their rage. Do I actually need to write a review for this? No seriously, is there really any point?

OK, so it’s high octane hardcore-punk delivered with as much guts, venom and wide-eyed aggression as is humanely possible of a modern-day Boston band (*Converge *not included) but when you consider that G.U.T.G.’s core fanbase seems to be those fresh-faced pit-bothering kids looking for something new that’s loud, fast and pulverising to vent their anger, you do feel inclined to point them in the direction of other, greater bands (not to get too patronising about it).

Maybe if acts such as *Good Clean Fun *or *In My Eyes *toured Europe more and perhaps dyed their hair black, or maybe even hired Jacob Bannon to design their artwork they might be as cool and popular. I mean, they’re both equally able, and just as powerful.

Of course the 100mph browbeat of ‘Crime Scene’ _and _‘We Killed It’, which builds and bubbles into a face-punchingly tumultuous finale, do get the blood pumping but when the rest of the album is so unchallenging and so, well, monotonous you’re left desensitised to the non-stop torrent of rage being hurtled towards you. Perhaps if they’d experimented a little more with the swirling post-rock instrumentation of opener _‘(It’s Sometimes Like It Never Started)’ _and closer _‘(And It’s Sometimes Like It Will Never End)’ _then they may have made a difference. For now though, it’s hard to see where they go from here.

Give Up The Ghost - We're Down 'Til We're Undergro

it's better than this review would suggest - a lot more accessible than their earlier work as american nightmare. whether that makes it better or not is open to debate, but i personally think it's great. it can get a bit repetitive at times, but at its best it's as good as any hardcore album released in the last couple of years. one thing, though - release date 19th feb? i got this in september...

Re: Give Up The Ghost - We're Down 'Til We're Undergro

I think I can justify the review by the amount of incredible new hardcore bands around that are progressing the genre in so many ways! Check Daughters, Seven Feet Four, Circle, Jude The Obscure... Oh, and I didn't give it a release date. Someone else did.

Give Up The Ghost - We're Down 'Til We're Undergro

oh, sure, those bands are great (except seven feet four, who i have never heard...), and will no doubt go on to be awesome soon enough. it's just that i think this GUTG album is going to be really important - it's an accessible introduction to straight-up hardcore. i don't think people getting into hardcore for the first time would appreciate jude the obscure as their reference point...

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon