Sign In:
2377
Type: Album Release date: 16/09/2002
Your Rating:

Hey! Do you yearn for a time in musical history where it seemed that raspy-throated blokey singers in bands that churned out great slabs of white-boy blues-rock were the norm? Do you wish for a musical climate where disco, hip-hop, dance, all electronic and synth based music, and even some punk had never happened?

Do you favour deeply conservative, retrograde and over-wrought guitar music over each and every musical progression, mutation and step forward in the past thirty years? Do you have an innate distrust of all black music made since the late 70s - y’know, all that [c]rap (haha) music; P-funk, breakdance, gangsta rap, g-funk, R’n’B, 2-step, garage: it’s all a loada bollocks, innit?

Are your heroes exclusively white, heterosexual males? The ones that are standard-bearers for ‘classic’ rock: Faces! Ver Zep! Deep Purple! The Jam! Wellah! Waysis! Roses! OCS! Ashcroft! All propah musicians making propah music, real music! None o’that man-u-fac-chard pop shit. None o‘that girly chart rubbish.

Do you, even on the smallest level, even in the tiniest, tiniest amount, find yourself agreeing with any of the above? You do? Really? Are you completely fucking mad? Are you really deluded and tin-eared enough to actually believe that, for instance, Led Zeppelin were better than ABBA? That The Clash were better than Chic? That U2 were better than Public Enemy? That The Charlatans were better than Technotronic? Or that The Music are better than Destiny’s Child? You believe all that? Do you even have a scintilla of understanding at how wrong you are?

Are you a slick, greasy haired, lolloping, football-shirted, dim-eyed mouth breather - in short, do you look like Vernon Kay? Are you the kind of selfish, spoilt, ignorant fuckpig that sets fire to a toilet block at a music festival in a pique of sexual frustration and a delusional belief that you are somehow being anarchic? Do you mistake irony for humour? Do you piss yourselves laughing whilst watching ‘Bo Selecta!’? Do you laugh with and not at_ Ali G? And when you see Chris ‘Moylsey’ Moyles on the telly and look into his tiny, tiny, vacant-piggy eyes, do you sense a kinship? Perhaps you share his actual, open _hatred of intelligence and love for FHM/’Lock-Stock’/Loaded-Lad culture: a culture stuck in some fantasy 1970s daydream, a culture where emotionally stunted, aggressive boorishness is celebrated, a culture where casual racism, casual sexism, casual homophobia is flagged past as it’s only harmless fun and can’t really veil an actual poisonous prejudice, can it? A culture that offers nothing except an endless fucking barrage of witless, depressing banality, a culture that is content to wallow in it’s festering plague-pit of laddism, never daring to look out over the side of its pit towards distant, different horizons; never wanting to reach for something - anything - more, anything different, anything new. Merely happy with it’s familiar, comfortable, artless mediocrity. A cowardly, backward-looking culture?

Do you want a soundtrack to your pitifully ugly existence? Some lumpen, pub-rock perhaps? A band that would like you to believe that it strives for some sort of classicist ideal, but ends up, in reality, just being yet another formulaic, lazy re-hash of what’s gone before. A faded Xerox of a faded Xerox of a faded Xerox.

Songs! Not songs, anthems! Yes, anthems that say absolutely nothing whatsoever, yet say it loudly and repeatedly. Anthems that you and your equally dim, hunch-shouldered mates can stand in a circle in the pub with your bottles of lager and drunkenly bellow out in gruff, blokey voices that sound like the final, pained, dying brays of an ox sinking into a tar pit: “An through it AAAAAALLLLL she offers me proTEC-SHUN! Li’l love an’ AFFEC-SHUN! When m’right ur wrong”, “SOOOOOO Sally can WAAAAIT, she knows it’s too LAAAAATE w’shiz walkin’ on bye-yie”

Yeah? That kind of thing. Only not quite as good. Horrendous, shouted, empty chants written with the lyrical dexterity of someone who is still, apparently, trying to get to grips with ‘My First Book of ABC’?

Do you like whiney, tuneless caterwauling? How about spirit-exhausting, leaden 70s rock riffs? Would you like to buy an album featuring music so utterly tedious, so unforgivably turgid and so disgracefully inept that you have to wonder if it is, in fact, some sort of elaborate joke; a parody so precision crafted that it’s ended up sounding as boring and as dismal as that which it sought to satirise?

You would? In that case then, The Shining have just released an album in which you may be interested. Buy it. Go on. I’m telling you, buy it.

It’s all you fucking deserve, anyway. You scum.

The Shining - True Skies

Is this where I type "lol"??
An excellent article, although more detail of the record would've been nice. (What's this? ME? Giving Advice?) I reviewed this album for soundsxp.com and felt much the same, but didn't have the heart to be quite so bold. But then I never do.
The blokeishness thing is a interesting idea. It's a phase I've grown out of recently, but it is possible to still love the very best of Dadrock(The soulfull bassline in Town Called Malice? The fresh sheen of Liam's vocals in Supersonic? The whole of Maggie May) and also adore everything else worthy in Pop Music?

funny as fuck

spot on review. the best ive seen on this site.

all the reasons to rally against pub rock bollocks in one accessible album..... i'm tempted to buy it just to feed the hatred.

Re: funny as fuck

disagree about the clash though

Re: funny as fuck

nice review. beerfootballtits. the shining are one of the most depressing bands i have heard recently.

The Shining - True Skies

Hahahahaha

Nice review, spot on.

The Shining - True Skies

Fucking hell.

A Brilliantly savage review that explodes all the bullshit hype, and fucking funny too. I wish I'd written it!

The Shining - True Skies

"Are you really deluded and tin-eared enough to actually believe that, for instance, Led Zeppelin were better than ABBA?"

at this point, i wish to worship you. please send me an application form.

o
o
o
<><...
Gen

Re: The Shining - True Skies

that article is the anti-Joe Wisbey ... stop trying to pretend you're cool enough to agree with it

Re: The Shining - True Skies

Hmm. Spose it could be construed as anti-me, but I doubt whether Daue set out to slag off moi when he sat at his little keyboard. But I'm nothing like that at all.
And I never pretend to be cool.

Fistfucking popular taste

and quite right too. I can't believe other people think The Shining are anything more than a dreary abortion of pub rock band. They're shit. And anyone who disagrees otherwise is just a fly eating dogshit on the tarmac of music.

Re: The Shining - True Skies

If the cap fits, eat it. It made me laugh and I loved every word. But I know ABBA were dross and I do like U2 and I don't care. Beware the cultural bully in your midst! He makes you laugh, but he's can't be your inner judge.

Re: The Shining - True Skies

The reviewer is not only conveying his height of utter artistic snobbery (which is where art becomes something much less pleasant), but demonstrating that he is in fact the very opposite of the 'character' he is portraying.

Which makes him just as bad.

A 'character', which I may add, that does little more for his review than show a vague grasp of popular cultural references.


True Skies is not a great album, but for me at times it rocks. At others it's all a bit dodgy.

I don't fit his character description and i don't fit it.

And what was that about The Clash? probably just to provoke response from those who agreed with everything else.

The Shining - True Skies

Go back to your Destiny's Child worshipping Rolling Stone wannabe reviewing fairytale land.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon