- Artists:
- Cancer Bats »
- Label:
- Hassle Records »
From the meandering title of this record it’s apparent just how unfocussed and divergent it aims are. On opener 'One of These Days's Liam Cormier howls “One of these days I’ll sleep this away”, a line indicative of the ‘mortal coil’ philosophy extending throughout the lyrics. The suggestion that the band are somehow vindicated by suffering acts as a central cliché. Unfortunately Cancer Bats fail to illustrate how they’ve found themselves in such a predicament. Is it just insomnia plain and simple? Is it something more? More I wanna be hated than sedated, the band strive for universal appeal with unqualified rage and banal sonic ventures.
Ironically, salvation, if any, comes with the track ‘Doomed To Fail’ and a spiralling guitar entering increasingly insane riffs, which in isolation could be deemed far too vibrant for a band who almost blindly pursue the hardcore mentality.
Despite adopting a don’t-give-a-fuck persona, the band are dry when self-deprecating. Rarely do they vent their spleen at others. Change comes on ‘Black Metal Bicycle’ whereby a relationship is ended for the pleasure of the audience. Surprisingly, ‘it’s not you it’s me’ is the response. But what’s this? “If you kill for me I’ll die for you… I’m scared to death of dying alone.” Well you should stop pushing them away shouldn’t you?
It’s not that the lack of continuity directly detracts from the final product. However, there’s a clear distinction between brutalism and crude. This is angry music for angry people.
“I’m sick of the tired and weak.” But aren't the lyrics by someone tired and weak? Tired of expression, tired of communication... before the track is out such an explicit criticism becomes inverted back upon the singer.
The problem is that Bears, Mayors, Scraps, And Bones does not create the platform for catharsis. It is so self-referential and exclusive to the band that a listener cannot appreciate nor relate to the strife. Through only referring to the individual, and without any explanation, the lyrics assume that the listener is just as oppressed and perturbed by life.
Sonically the record is super masculine. It drips of man sweat. Music for marines; the moment in Fahrenheit 9/11 when the soldiers reveal the soundtrack for combat. A world underwritten by fear, testosterone and the capacity to kill. The production extols conservatism, everything is clean, meticulously done. For the tracks reliant upon a constant aesthetic the heavy as hell riffs become but incidental. Only on the more flamboyant excursions, ‘Doomed To Fail’ being a key example, does the recording capture the feral nature of the music. As with the music, there’s little commonality. Leaving that which distinguishes them from their peers being their myopic search for ‘tour de force’ sounds at the detriment of a unique and stylised aesthetic.
Fortunately ‘Radiation’ shares a moment of clairvoyance, “I’m not as negative as all this sounds / I just feel like humanity has let me down”. I concur.
- Slottsfjell 2012: the DiS review
- In Photos: Leeds Festival 2012 - Day 2 @ Bramham Park, Leeds
- In Photos: Bring Me The Horizon @ Norwich Waterfront
- Cancer Bats - Bears, Mayors, Scraps and Bones
- Friday Feeling: Cover-core with Cancer Bats
- In Photos: Sonisphere 2009
- The Great Escape 2008: the DiS review
- T In The Park Diary Part 1: Saturday 12 July
I don't want to sound unprofessional....
...but if you're going to tear an album to shreds, then surely it's A) a good idea to get the song titles right (the opening track is 'Sleep this Away', not 'One Of these Days'), and b) ascribe the lyrics to the right song ("If you kill for me I’ll die for you" is from 'Scared to Death, not 'Black Metal Bicycle").
If you clearly don't give enough of a shit when reviewing an album to get stuff like that right, why on Earth would anyone take your opinion seriously?
Could you not have given Samuel Pepys, Sorry, I mean Breen
something slightly more pretentious to wrap his cluttered dictionary around?
It takes times to construct sentences as psuedo-intellectual as these, how can we be sure he's actually had time to listen to the record?
Oh wait. As others have already pointed out, we clearly can't.
The review reads very much like 'my first metal album - phew!'
...and can be condensed to 'lots of lyrics about death and stuff, and boy were those guitars heavy - I normally review classical music don't you know'
Hmmm
I disagree. I think this is a rather good album, actually, and quite like the old 'confessional' style Liam adopts. But to each his own, mon ami.
responces
@HughDoVoodoo
'One of these days' came up as the album opener. I don't have a copy of the track listings.
The paragraph with the incorrect lyric attribution is due to the fact I didn't make it clear that I was talking about the following song. Poor quality, sorry. At least you were keen enough to spot it.
@badgertastic
I agree, it does read like that. I was quite conscious about that, but then I'm going to blame the rudimentary nature of the record.
@keveddy
I don't get why people keep describing them as confessional. I've just had a search around to see how far off the mark I am with this record; the BBC have gone with 'confessional' as well. However, I always thought confession was about telling someone about something you have done and find it hard to make explicit. The lyrics don't say anything that could be confessional, perhaps they're a little taboo in their aggression. However it's hard to argue that there are any taboos left for hardcore lyrics.
@themighty
I chose to review the record. I've seen Cancer Bats a few times in concert (and gave them some good reviews as well) and thought I'd like to review a record of theirs.
I don't mind the criticism, but come on, I've clearly listened to the record.



Drowned in Manchester #15 – May 2013
armchair dancefloor 39: Mount Kimbie interview, Bobby Browser, Powell, Move D, Leon Vynehall...
DiS meets John Lydon - Part 1: The Man
DiS Does Singles 20.05.13: Paramore, Laura Marling, The Replacements
DiS joins the Music Alliance Pact + May 2013's global MAP compilation
Drowned in Bristol #12
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article