Sign In:
51834
Type: Album Release date: 10/08/2009
Your Rating:

In the course of dutifully checking some dates pertaining to James Yorkston’s back catalogue, the man’s Wikipedia entry alerted me to his appearance on a compilation album released by V2 two years ago, entitled Acoustic 07. It features a Yorkston song alongside Paul Weller, Morcheeba, Aimee Mann and Rufus Wainwright, among many others whose reliance on ‘acoustic’ varies greatly. Although it blatantly exists to be purchased by the 12-CDs-a-year set, the fact that V2 saw fit to include our subject on said compilation isn’t in itself that surprising or unusual. Certainly, Yorkston had garnered a healthy following by 2007, being a regular presence at the UK’s smaller, boutique-ier festivals with his band The Athletes, while his records have largely been warmly listenable fare from his own rich Scottish burr on in. While the revitalizing of folk-rock’s commercial potential had benefitted many other artists to a greater extent than it did Yorkston, it didn’t do him any harm either.

There’s the rub: when Domino released his second single, ‘The Lang Toun’, in early 2002, they surely couldn’t have known that there’d be any extensive audience for a dude who composed ten-minute-long, harmonium-wheezy intersections of somber Britfolk and vaguely Krautrock-ish bubbling rhythm. Yet he’s established himself: Folk Songs is the fifth studio album for Domino, and couldn’t be more prosaically titled, featuring 11 traditional numbers – mostly from Britain, with one each from Ireland and Spain respectively. Does it represent a clarion call to trace back the noble genre’s knotted roots and highlight the Formica void at the heart of too much modern folk (cracks about mobile phone ad soundtracks might be pretty played out and straw mannish at this point, but they’re pretty accurate too)?

Yorkston hasn’t specifically answered this question, but he does claim to have had the idea to do this album as far back as 2000, before he’d released any material. His commitments to Domino saw the project become dormant, but it was reignited by his discovery of the music of Big Eyes Family Players, a Sheffield band influenced by avant-classical, slowcore and Eastern European folk among other styles. Correspondence with bandleader James Green slowly led to Folk Songs coming together, and the results are highly agreeable – if, to these ears at least, bearing the stamp of Yorkston far more than of the Family Players.

Cribbing his interpretations from a laundry list of Sixties and Seventies folk icons who got their versions down on wax - Anne Briggs, Shirley Collins, Nic Jones - the musicians generally make an effort to put their own compositional mark on songs. ‘Mary Connaught & James O’Donnell’ is an original track in terms of its arrangement, and is driven briskly along by a hectic drumbeat. ‘Pandeirada De Entrimo’ originates in Spain, and the violin-fuelled instrumental version here is perhaps the closest the album comes to reflecting Big Eyes’ pan-European refixes. You might know ‘Little Musgrave’ as ‘Matty Groves’, perhaps the well-known Fairport Convention version (I quite vividly recall my mum singing this to me when my siblings and I were much younger; presumably they weren’t broadcasting football or You Bet! at the precise time). It’s been attempted by an incalculable number of folkists since the 17th century; Yorkston’s vocal and the pattering guitar part lend a delicious gentleness to this weathered tale of unfaithfulness and man-to-man slaughter. Practically as well-known as a folk standard, ‘Sovay’ – the ballad of the lady who embarrasses her boyfriend by dressing as a highwayman and robbing him – shines brightest when all but the keening, tearful violin drops out.

The last 20 seconds or so of ‘Low Down In The Broom’, the closing track, finds the ensemble reaching a more raucous pace than they attempt for the preceding 48 minutes. If you’ve seen James Yorkston play with The Athletes (who remain his go-to backing band for future ventures, in case you were wondering) you may know they enjoy closing sets with a bit of a rambunctious jam. It all helps to remind us that this highly talented, consistently modest Scotsman isn’t easily put into a box for the selling; Folk Songs probably won’t soundtrack a woman exhorting you through your flatscreen to buy yoghurt in the foreseeable, but it will be received with a deserved warmth by an established cluster of fans.

This is a really lovely record

Definitely worth an 8. Not quite as good as his last but the rougher-round the edges sound of this band suits the material better than the folky wall of sound that he achieves with the atheletes.

Didn't like the review though. It feels like a discussion of where Yorkston fits into 'the market'. 2 long paragraphs of this nonsense. Yorkston is a folk artist, it's hardly surprising that he's going to release a folk album at some point in his career. I can't imagine the music in mobile phone adverts even crossed his mind for a second. He might play at 'boutique festivals' but he also plays off the beaten track of the indie touring circuits too; read his article in Loops.

Yorkston exists outside of the indie bubble that the reviewer is looking out from, where people give a shit about whether their favourite music appears in an advert or Skins or whether they heard a tune, y'know, like aaaages ago (off their mum in this case). In other words the kind of stuff that peppers the DiS message boards. Get some perspective.

Still, not as bad as this review:
http://drownedinsound.com/releases/2982/reviews/4239-
Surely copied from the NME or something?

It's actually first in a planned series of several

where I casually shoehorn my mum's taste in music 20 years ago into a review - think 'Losing My Edge' rewritten for a Hallmark card - I reckon this could fit into the market pretty successfully actually, exciting times

Funny, I did once ask Yorkston in the course of interview if he considered himself 'a folk artist' and he answered in the negative and proceeded to talk about Michael Hurley and Harold Budd for some time. I'm not sure if he was being slightly disingenuous, or trying to weasel out of the pigeonhole, but there you have it. Clearly folk is a reference point for him, but I think his career is more or less a procession of records that sound folky, but actually aren't (I mean, 'folky wall of sound' - what is this?)

That's why I don't write reviews

Listen to the bit between the verses on the title track of his last album, When the Haar Rolls In. All the instruments seem to form a cohesive whole the sum of which is greater than its parts. It reminds me of what Spector did, or Brian Wilson on Smile and Pet Sounds but with clarinets and accordians and stuff. He pulls the trick on loads of his songs and it's why I love the Athletes so much.

Interestingly the Quietus review mentions Yorkston describing himself not as a folk artist but in the singer-songwriter tradition. That's what musicians do, I remember Richard Ashcroft declaring with total sincerity that he considered the Verve to be a punk band. Whether or not he thinks he is a folk artist is irrelevant if that's what people think he is and he is certainly more of a 'folk' artist than any of the Banharts and Newsoms that soundtrack the phone adverts mentioned above. The same review quite rightly mentions that folk is a difficult term to define.

On reflection my comments above do feel somewhat twattish and I'm certainly not suggesting I could write a better review but I wish we could get away from 'where does this fit into the market?'-type discussions.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon