Sign In:
28707
Type: Album Release date: 24/09/2007
Your Rating:

There are innumerable tedious and derivatives music scenes in England; yet surely none are more reactionary, inward looking, creatively bankrupt and generally vacuous than northern, particularly Manchester-based, indie. By which I don’t mean Hacienda stuff (or even The Smiths, who were good enough to transcend the tag), but the dreary, derivative drivel that followed (Primal Scream, Kasabian, blah blah blah).

On their MySpace Puressence have an endorsement from Mani; on the mp3 he drawls, “this band are from my hometown… this track is a belter!” Which kind of sums it all up really; a sort of dry, sad provincialism that clouds the fact that listening to Puressence is about as spiritually fulfilling as having a Carling spilt over you at 5th Avenue.

The extraordinarily titled Don't Forget To Remember (what am I supposed to not forget to remember? What? What?!) is, improbably, the band’s fourth album. You can literally hear the influences rolling themselves out of the speakers: those warbly The Verve-like vocals, layered over guitars the band would probably describe as ‘soaring’ (presumably with The Stone Roses or early Radiohead in mind), which instead sit drably on each track like a sludgy, lifeless, bepuddled carpet. ‘Drop Down to Earth’ sounds unnervingly like James, so formulaic it’s painful (quiet verse, ‘soaring’ chorus, pointless guitar riff; repeat). Weirdly, at times the band morph from Madchester indie-by-numbers to overtly melodramatic balladry; ‘Don’t Know Any Better’ sounds like something Michael Ball might sing, or a strange Andrew Lloyd Webber cast-off. As much as this seems like an attempt to sound more ‘nuanced’ or intelligent, the band just don’t have the know-how to make it sound anything other than dull. All the while the group have strangely downbeat lyrics (“life comes down hard / It won’t be long ‘til all this hell surrounds me”) that sit slightly at odds with the guitars, drenched as they are in ketchup-think dollops of reverb.

All of which made the experience of listening to this record strangely depressing, from the sludgy, desperately uninspired music, to the self-consciously ‘powerful’ vocals that, with all their posturing, express an approximation of nothing. Even so, as much as I’d like to see this as yet another death rattle from the bloated carrion of northern indie, I can’t help but feel there’s another dusty, swaggering zombie waiting to lurch from the grave. Though I suppose it’s to the band's credit that my predominant reaction to Don't Forget To Remember was muted indifference, rather than genuine abhorrence.

In conclusion: ho hum.

I have yet to listen to the album

but Puressence never sounded like all the bands you cited...

Re: Sam Lewis Pure essence review

Ridiculous! Sam Lewis - it is as plain as day that you have some kind of grudge against all things northern. It IS possible to give an objective review of any album and you would have done well to start there. Firstly ANYONE who cared to listen could not failed to be moved by James voice which is generally regarded , along with that of David Ford, as being criminally undervalued and overlooked. The music IS uplifting, heartfelt and melodic (even touching on Ramones territory on one track!) - far more so than much of the dirge that presumably Mr lewis will tout as the next big thing especially if its from 'the south.' A reviewer should be able to divorce any personal feelings from his or her appreciation of what they are asked to comment upon. The album is great. The music is great – try the chord changes at the end of ‘sold unseen’ or the opening to ‘moonbeam’ not to mention the almost operatic feel to ‘burns inside.’ The see them live – you never know you might even meet some decent northerners!I for one look forward to the day when Puressence manage to sort out distribution and publicity so they can take their rightful place up there with Radiohead circa The Bends but also stamp their own unique place in contemporary music. Finally if you want to read a decent and heartfelt review about this band from this particular web-site try John Robb.

Ian Kennedy Huddersfield

Put the dictionary down and listen!

I have been a Puressence fan for years and for the simple reason, they ARE good. Infact they are awesome. You should listen to their self titled debut album and see why you are so wrong. Who is Sam Lewis anyway? Noone and noone will listen to your spiteful rants about an awesome band that are the best band that you may have never heard of and I suspect that in a few years you will be eating your words.

You have no idea...

Sam Lewis clearly you are NOT the right person to be reviewing this album...your head is so deep inside your a**e you can't even recognise good music when you hear it.
Your most recent 'good' reviews are for bands that are so predictable and bigged up by everyone else (see Vampire Weekend)
Why do you even have to lump a band within a scene?

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon