Drowned in Sound

Search


Drowned in Sound Event sponsored tours and events.

sound of silver

LCD Soundsystem: Sound Of Silver

11 votes
?
by Gareth Dobson
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 12/03/2007
  • Label: DFA Records

It’s a little disappointing really, given that the UK is apparently in the midst of a fifth summer of rave, that LCD Soundsystem’s James Murphy, one of only a handful of indie-dance’s genuine titans, finds himself as some sort of relic of three years’ past. Because, despite the fact that everyone’s ‘on’ one and the only relevant sound one is allowed to make with a guitar is that of a daft-punky club-toilet-door tone, LCD was probably old-nu-rave. Right?

A bummer. And it’s only because James Murphy is nearer to 50 than zero (and also isn’t Bono) that he’s not residing on the cover of various rock monthly and weeklies. We assume. Well it’s not due to Kasabian, Klaxons or anyone else having made a more cerebral, visceral or downright awesome record.

Given his persona as the grumpy techno fan-boy made good, probably the most vital thing that Sound of Silver can achieve is for Murphy to be recognised as a class songwriter and musician is his own right. Because, while opening track ‘Get Innocuous’ gently apes his own ‘Losing My Edge’ for the first minute and a half, the rest of the LP gradually moves onwards and upwards; either improving and tightening the previous template, or trying new things altogether.

Three songs in, it sounds like a better, refined, tighter LCD. By the end of the nine-track, 55-minute journey, you realise that this is LCD 2.0, not just a rebooted version 1.1. Because, whilst single ‘North American Scum’ is the same wise-ass persona with beats as portrayed on the likes of ‘Daft Punk Is Playing At My House’, come the elliptical, mesmerising ‘Someone Great’ – which sounds like a gossamer Human League in an ice palace – you realise that Murphy has not so much added extra strings to his bow as fashioned a whole new one. The best is ‘All My Friends’, which rattles hypnotically along on electric piano in David Byrne-like fashion, with Murphy musing over the oddities of life and success: “You spend the first five years trying to get with the plan, and the next five years trying to be with your friends again,” in an almost narrative monologue-style ballad. It’s a wonderful and quietly affecting track. Perhaps more so because no-one was entirely sure that he had it in him.

At eight-and-a-half minutes long, ‘Us V. Them’ is the album’s centre point, a funked-up stew of cowbells, fast-paced beats and lazy, chant-like vocals. Nicely bringing the album to a slinky near-conclusion, ‘Sound Of Silver’ is a restless, ambient soul effort. Ultimately closing the record is ‘New York, I Love You But You’re Bringing Me Down’. Inevitably, much will be made of the song that sounds like Lou Reed gone showtune: it’s a ballad! There’s no beats! The only necessary point to make is that it’s a song, and a pathos-laden, wry and thoughtfully well-written one at that.

Sound of Silver is a better record than anything you will hear from these shores this year, at least in terms of making you shake your booty, rediscovering the Human League, remembering that Talking Heads are still amazing (sorry, I know they were oh-so 2005, you frivolous taste-monkeys) and realising that New York is still the best city in the world. Period.

  • LCD Soundsystem 8 / 10

yep

great album especially in the middle with somone great. He may also be too intelegent for magazines, who would rather have an interview with a kasabian idiot saying (insert band name) are rubbish and oasis are great.


definitely the best album of the year

so much more focused and refined over his debut.. all my friends has to be one of my fave tunes ever already


Really really really

good


While I don't usually question ratings...

...as I know its objective...

How on earth does this only get an 8? If this deserves an 8 then the Klaxons and Jamie T reviews NEED to be altered to 7s as neither are better than this.

Bizarre.

This is album of the year for me so far with Bloc Party a close second.


arse on the whole

you twat


totilly

boss


Is it just me...

Or does the rating not match up with the review? It reads like more of a 9 than an 8.

I'll have to give it a listen anyway.


Easily a 9

every track a winner and the 3 at the centre of the album(someone great,us v them,all my firends)are fuckin outstanding.More accesible than the 1st album and all the better for it.


makes me

want to go and buy items of percussion i can neither use nor afford. ace.


More like a 7

Yes it's good but it's full of re-hashed ideas from the last album and early singles. Us v. Them sounds EXACTLY like Yeah without the squelchy bits at the end and an added David Byrne chorus.

My problem with Murphy is that he is such a talented musician so why does he have to take the 'today I'm going to write a Talking Heads/Eno/New Order/Human League (delete as appropriate) song'? All My Friends sounds like the Strokes, albeit when they were good. The ones where he uses his own voice still sound like he has a cold. I've heard him talk and he doesn't talk like that.


good review gareth

but then thats because i agreed with you.

pitchfork did a good one too for once, which is nice.

i've not been this addicted to a record for years. I'm worried I'm going to wear it out, so I'm going to listen to 45:33 for a bit instead...


by the way remittanceman

i know we're all entitled to an opinion, but i'd just like to say that yours is wrong

:-)


us vs them

sounds exactly like yeah? I don't know about that... I would say this album is LESS accessible than the debut - which had three minute pop blasts like Movement, Tribulations, Disco Infiltrator as well as daft punk - i think this a far more advanced record for the more discerning listener - and all the better for it


However

It doesn't make sense that this gets 8/10 whilst Klaxons got 9/10 - this a far superior album, you can keep going back to it and love it more each time - whereas klaxons completely lacks longevity for me


At least a 9 for me.

One of the best so far this year.


i think the reviewer

might have accidentally clicked '8' instead of '9'
although he really should have clicked 10 instead


its got to be a 10

at first, it was an 8.. but its completely flawless.

Get Innocuous = Perfect (dispite ripping off losing my edge)

Time To Get Away = perfect track 2

NA Scum = enough said

Someone Great = song of the year contender

All My Friends = perfect vibe

Us Vs. Them = amazing
and the rest of the album just pulls it off so well...

--
Note: what other albums have DiS give a 10 this year? I know the new Field Music album got one!


9, probably a 10

I really wasn't that impressed when I first heard it, but it's got under my skin big time (Weekend in the City did exactly the same thing).

It's definitely one of THE albums of the year.


come on, surely..

this album is a 10, it's so much better than his previous effort and more importantly, EVERYTHING IS RELEVANT on the album.

even pitchfork gave it a nine.


reading this..

I bought this album.

it's feckin ace. Buy!


wish i'd wrtote that

earball sos's "someone great". try not imagining own dad's/granddaddy's passing. (even if he was a prick, or you never met but you only wish you were close), the sense of love and reverence jm had for his protagonist connects & resonates. profound, polished, tin pan alley quality lyrics. wry chorus / outro: "...were safe, for the moment", wish i'd wrote it. last song wished for same was arctic monkeys bigger boys and stolen sweethearts, it's that good.


I wish..

.. I'd given it a 9 now. Ah well. The eight's there for posterity. Anyway, what the hell is the worth of music criticism anyway?
x


I know I'm chiming in late...

because after NA scum I figured "eh, more cleverassedness from LCD. Not my thing."

Then I scraped Someone Great and All My Friends off a blog.

I never thought I could feel this way about music again. These aren't just songs--they're landmarks.


chime

fna


Gareth, now you're wishing..

....you gave it a 10. DiS album of the year, good choice, ace album, ace band


this is yuppie dance music

I just don't get it.

extremely boring, extremely derivative, not even as good as their first album.

the lyrics on this record are excruciatingly bad. cringe-inducing for sure. and the beats and grooves are flaccid.

most overrated album of all time?
everyone seems blinded by the hype....

how in the world is this shit better than klaxons?
everyone's blinded by the hype backlash on that one. at least they can write a fucking song without causing me to vomit.


i don't get it either

overhyped. there is a plethora of better releases this year.

it's time you all looked under the radar a bit. and new york the best city in the world? come on now...that's pushing it.


overrated

overratedoverratedoverratedoverratedoverratedoverratedoverrated.