Drowned in Sound

Search


Drowned in Sound Event sponsored tours and events.

do make say think you album

Do Make Say Think: You, You're A History In Rust

3 votes
?
by Mike Diver

It’s rare, really, that post-rock stands up to repeated listens, however allegedly wonderful the act in question is. So far this year shelves have been graced by the epic Enjoy Eternal Bliss by Kentish quintet Yndi Halda, but although it received a nine outta ten on these here pages, its longevity is questionable: there are only so many times a single song can have you welling up before your emotions build a barrier to block said affect. The same, sadly perhaps, should also be said of Explosions In The Sky, whose recent All Of A Sudden I Miss Everyone didn’t really build upon the band’s existing foundations, however lovely (and it was) the record was realised.

Do Make Say Think, a Toronto-spawned five-piece initially formed to soundtrack a play, have never been ones to touch their audience with immediacy and fail to let loose their grip – their material, available since 1998, has always been slow to sink in, and it doesn’t claw as sharply as that of many a peer. They do not rely on easy tricks. It’s an organic process, the digestion of the latest DMST record, and You, You’re A History In Rust is no different in this respect to, say, its immediate predecessor Winter Hymn Country Hymn Secret Hymn, released what feels like way back in 2003. It’s a record of many subtleties, each of which is entwined by a dozen more; it’s a record that cracks and groans with each inhalation, as if strapped tight into an old rocking chair. It sounds as its title suggests – rusted by the rigours of a history that continues to roll by, uncontrollable and incessant.

Percussively, this collection finds drummer David Mitchell at his very best – opener ‘Bound To Be That Way’ sets a fantastic tone with its rippling work around the kit, beats balanced between absolute bombast and delicate tickles. But this is expected – the members of DMST are renowned masters of their chosen trades, which is why the band remains so revered, with each album incredibly anticipated, this far into their career. What’s not on the cards in an obvious sense is vocals: ‘A With Living’, the bearer of that verse-chorus-verse promise made by Constellation a while ago, will blindside the odd aficionado.

Surprises, though, aren’t really DMST’s forte – they’re able, effortlessly so it seems, to convey true emotion through their music without the need for lyrics, and while it’s neat to hear the band use them, the few words scattered across You, You’re A History In Rust really don’t set it head and shoulders above anything the band’s achieved previously. This is a step onwards, granted, but when a group’s so ahead of the game anyway, the distance covered from point A to B doesn’t really matter. This is a wonderful, intoxicatingly special album that deserves to be cherished, and played and played; its only failing, really, is that it’s unlikely to stir the souls of those never previously touched by these Canadians’ own history.

Oh well, the ignorant majority can keep rewinding their old cassette of Young Team and watch Planet Earth ‘til their hearts are sore from all the chafing.

  • Do Make Say Think 9 / 10

Good review

I love the now Explosions album, but this tops it for me - totally lovely, and track 3 makes me dance around like a loon - something most "post-rock" lacks.

By the way, isn't "post-rock" an utterly ghastly term? Love the music, hate the tag...


lovely album

i think you hit the nail on the head as far as longevity goes, theres something different in what DMST (and gy!be, silver mt zion and others that bring in uncommon instrumentation) do that not only rewards repeated listens but requires them.


great album.

so many good post-rock releases lately, i love the new eits.


another good review

though i've only had it a short while, think this might be my favourite do make say think album. can't wait to see them tour it. anyone know if the vocals are guests or touring members?


They're

done by Akron/Family.


Great album

I've been lucky enough to have this album for almost 3 months and even after repeated listens, it still sounds fresh. With their last two brilliant releases, DMST have really set themselves apart from the rest of the post-rock crowd.


Yaye for this review

and yaye for DMST - an amazing band. I think we need to stop calling them "post rock"... they're clearly making music that can't be pigeonholed... which really is great!

Did anyone else buy the vinyl and was disappointed that the cover artwork is different? I think that CD cover photo is really beautiful.


Well if

"it's only failing, really, is that it's unlikely to stir the souls of those never previously touched by these canadians' own history". Then let's point out where to touch them!??
'Goodbye Enemy Airship/The Landlord is Dead', would be a good starter! Or just go and see them live! Since I saw them at the spitz, 2003, I've never looked back in thinking these boys are the nuts!


You are right

'You, You're a History in Rust' is a great record. I think it's maybe a slight step back from the more experimental bent DMST showed on 'Winter Hymn...' but that's no bad thing, necessarily.

But, let's face it: the best record ever in this sort of instrumental rock genre ("post rock" is a misnomer) is still 'The Burden of Hope' by Grails.


I like this review too

mr diver's doing well again. :D

i will give this another listen later, "post rock" always takes ages for me to get into.


..

what more is there to say, great review, timeless album


It is a great album,

but it got almost totally overlooked in the end of year lists.