Focus: that’s the element that seems to be missing from The Black Keys’ latest long-player, their fourth album in all. The blues-rockin’ riffs, courtesy of Dan Auerbach, are present and correct, and Patrick Carney’s drums are rarely less than suitably bombastic, but Magic Potion suffers, rather, from alarming dips in concentration. For every romper-stomper of a four-minute fuzz-soaked foot-stamper, there’s a meandering exercise in mediocrity just around the metaphysical bend.
Opener ‘Just Got To Be’ sets an impressive tone: the listener can picture Auerbach leaning back, arching his spine, as he pummels heavy-duty riffs from his instrument of choice. His voice, soaked in soul and spirit (by which we mean liquor, obviously), is the perfect accompaniment to music like this: with raw instrumentation must come vocals from a boozy backwater only discovered by city folk sometime at the end of the last decade, at the very earliest, and Auerbach never disappoints on this particular front. But, well... there is always a ‘but’ where albums that don’t wholly grab their audience are concerned.
If Magic Potion was a six-track EP, featuring the aforementioned accompanied by ‘Your Touch’ and ‘Just A Little Heat’, to name but a pair of standouts, then we’d be in business: accolades would come the duo’s way easily, and DiS would be in no position to disagree with the acclaim such a brief, such a focused, collection would attract. But the slumps that pepper this eleven-tracker leave an unwelcome taste in the mouth, an irritating resonance in the ears. ‘You’re The One’ is such a song: although it represents the band’s softer side, compositionally, it also bores this listener’s opinion into a state of absolute indifference. Which is, perhaps, a feeling even worse than hating the song with utmost vehemence. It just limply swaggers by, filling its three-and-something minutes with characteristic repetition but zero energy.
Perhaps the record’s length doesn’t help – at 42 minutes, Magic Potion is probably ten minutes longer than its simplistic style warrants – but come the concluding pair of ‘Back Door’ and ‘Elevator’, it’s tough to muster much in the way of excitement for heard-it-before (across the last nine songs) six-string crunches and heavy-handed cymbal crashes. If variety is the spice of life, then this album’s heart must beat with a worrying weakness.
Great in parts though it is, Magic Potion isn’t quite the album to attract a raft of newcomers to The Black Keys’ archaic rock, a breed best played loud from dusty porches and creaking pick-up trucks. Loyal fans, though, will find much of their favoured brand in abundance here. Just focus on keepin’ your jaw from slackin’, you yokels*.
*DiS apologises for this horrific and inaccurate catchall.
Well said
I've enjoyed listening to this album but some songs still breeze by without making much of an impression (mainly the second half). Having said that, the production is great and there are some real gems on there. 'Just got to be' and 'your touch' easily compete with their best songs.
Haven't heard the album yet
good review, as ever from Diver. I am still very much looking forward to listening to Magic Potion; Thickfreakness and Rubber Factory were perfect examples of crunching back to basics blues rock, and i'm still hopeful that I can work through any imperfections that the album may have, previously slower songs on other albums I thought were often high points for me, The Lengths being a partcularly good example. Lets just hope the album doesn't restrict my excitement at going to see them at the end of the month in Brum. Probably not.
That said
42 minutes does sound a bit flabby for a Black Keys album. We'll see...
Glad I bought
Chulahoma. Which actually was a 6 track EP (+ some answer phone message from the wife of a dead bluesman but that ain't music) instead then.
Heard it now
And I can safely say that it is a fabulous album, without a duff track on it. Every 42 minutes is entirely justified, and even the slower tracks such as you're the one are wonderful.
The simplicity of the Black Keys is what makes their music so exciting and refreshing, and I can't wait to see them live.