Just think of it: the very best scenes that were never made, from the very best movies that were never conceptualized. Those critical turning point moments, the headiest cocktails of regrets, uncertainties, thrills, throes of despair. Despite these concepts having never progressed past the mind of the unconscious dreamer; past the hands of the unartistic finance director refusing necessary billion-pound budget; muted by the statically fake acting, Guillemots conjure them from thin air - no pictures, limited dialogue but enough sound to create a whole world, worthy of a cinema screen.
You must understand - this album is not concerned with minimalism, understatement, earthiness or roots. Through the Windowpane maximizes and intensifies every moment, every muttered word and every touch of emotion. To criticize Guillemots for being overblown would be missing the central point of the record. The movie industry trades in the way that each critical emotion is taken to an extreme -
|
It's impossible to see anything but visions of every golden-age Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer climax - National Velvet heading over the race finish line, blonde-permed girls spinning umbrellas in the rain, ridiculous joy and technicolour fantasy.
|
'Blue Would Still Be Blue' fits the depths of despair scenario - a lone voice and keyboard arrangement still managing to be florid with philosophy; fear of death, fear of living - "I waste so much time / thinking about time / I should be out there claiming what's mine". 'We're Here' is the unabashed celebration of incredible optimism - endless string crescendos leading a dance of dizzy circles, Marilyn Monroe spinning her fluted white dress, staring into a cobalt blue sky. When Fyfe sings, "the world is our carpet now, the world is our dancefloor now", it's impossible to see anything but visions of every golden-age Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer climax - National Velvet heading over the race finish line, blonde-permed girls spinning umbrellas in the rain, ridiculous joy and technicolour fantasy.
Emotion is never black and white - this record has more depth than just joy versus despair. The most interesting scenarios are where sadness and regret compete with future hopes, where the uncertainty of what life brings next causes fear and excitement. 'Redwings' combines the sorrow of leaving a best friend - "just for the hell of it / just for the sake of it / How much I loved you" - and all of the sentimentality of Simon and Garfunkel's 'Bookend's Theme', with the elation of new adventures and journey in life - the tug of war between past and future orchestrated.
You must understand - life is what you make of it, you choose what you perceive. Should you want to, each doorway you pass through could be your entrance into new worlds. Through the Windowpane is a most fitting title for an album that takes songs into imaginary locations - worlds filled with all the surrealism of Alice's Wonderland, journeys as story-filled as Dorothy's red-brick road. It's no coincidence that the opening minutes of the album are stylistically akin to Dvorak's 'New World' symphony, cradling both warmth and aching contemplation. Good songs build rooms in time - you might like your gritty punk band to roll around in their own painful shit, but that's no more 'real' than Guillemots creating landscapes of magnified intensity and brilliance with music.
|
Guillemots' audience will not be decided by age or style but rather by whether they want to step through the windowpane; whether they want to involve themselves with an overblown, over-the-top world of orchestras and golden-age cinema story telling.
|
I continue to claw for a modern reference point to convey how far-reaching in sonics and story-telling this album is, but there are no contemporaries I can point to without doing a disservice to the band. Instead, I think of Elton John singing over Leonard Bernstein's West Side Story soundtrack; crystal-clear melodies and dramatic orchestral passages. The final track, 'Sao Paulo', is the most dramatic closing tracks you'll hear this year - the calls of a blues trumpeter in a nighttime street, dark rain in a unwelcoming city, horns sounding as alarms and behemothic rhythmic breakdowns.
Whether or not you will be swept away in the dreams and despairs of this album depends on your temperament - you could easily sit down, all stoic and profess that they are nothing more than a memorable singles band; you could deny all of the stormy depths that swarm beneath songs. Perhaps you just don't want to let music break your heart - I've sat weeping like a snotty-nosed Bridget Jones over these cinematic tales; I've thrown my arms up into the air and let my heartbeats race with possibility and hope. This is not convenient music to listen to, but neither is it difficult - Guillemots' audience will not be decided by age or style but rather by whether they want to step through the windowpane; whether they want to involve themselves with an overblown, over-the-top world of orchestras and golden-age cinema story telling.
very good review,
might have to pick this up after all the hype they are getting on here.
fantastic review
but the record just didnt do it for me. :(
You have a way with words!
Fantastic.
Might look at this, then again, might not.
I wish this reviewer
was my girlfriend.
Why?
Apparently she lives a joyless life...
http://www.theautomatic.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?id=1162&p=1
i agree
TOO MANY WORDS.
gosh, how many adjectives do you need?!*
*i'm joking big time, you're the best reviewer here**
**no it's you really colin
so...
is trains to brazil on the album?
YES
of course it is!
interesting.
My first take of the album was very different from this, it came across a little over produced and failed to really cling to the emotion of the ideas it represents.
With the exception of Made-Up Lovesong #43 and Blue Would Still Be Blue the album left me wanting.
Your review is great incite though into how you saw the album, and will definately be making me listen again.
*insight, sorry, its been a long day.
I found it to be very mixed initially...
...and a good dozen plays since hasn't convinced me otherwise.
Some of it is cringeworthy.
But when it's good, it's 10/10 good.
Apart from the three singles...
...Annie and Sao, this album bores the tits off of me. The greatest disappointment of the year. So many times they could have soared to the heavens but instead they choose to focus on a sparse minimal sound with the vocals taking up all the room. When Guillemots are celebratory thats when the record is at its best but unfortunately there is a whole lot of weeping and wallowing going on.
^ yes.
You give these guys far more credit than they're worth. Carve away the "we're wacky, us, yet another wonky coda going nowhere" crap and there's a couple of good if overproduced singles and precious little else. It sometimes also me think of Coldplay going jazz, which is something no album should ever, ever make me think.
i really like this album
Giving it a first listen now
Sau Paulo is a stand out track.
scratch that
I really shouldn't make statements like that on the basis of the first 4 songs. The rest is a bit pretentious and boring. Tries too hard.
I think its
Stunning.
I totally concur
It is as splendid as the review make out. Wonderful, wonderful record.
great review !
boring band...
I'm undecided
I mean, the singles have been FANTASTIC, but there's something about them that puts me off, perhaps it's the slight "wackiness" about them.
Meh, I'll download some of it and hope I'm wrong.
for fuck's sake
will someone just buy an album for once!?!?
I'm glad I downloaded it
Would have been a waste of a tenner otherwise.
I always buy albums !
I won't buy this one.
Try to listen to some songs when I heard they were signed by Fantastic Plastic.
Wasn't convinced.
Still bought their second single because it was cheap.
Didn't like it.
So I won't try more.
Still it's indeed frustrating to see all this downloading of full albums...
Oh by the way
I think they're fucking amazing.
And I don't normally like bands like this. I prefer punky-electronica-new wavey stuff. To put it into a few words.
lyle...
the album is quite a surprise after the singles (to me)... final track sao paulo is something you should really listen to before making yr mind up about them...
NAH
Can't be arsed.
When you think about it, going to Amazon would take 3 minutes, which could be spent finding random bands on here.
I downoloaded this
and I think its the best album ive heard.
as debut albums go
i think it's amazing. it is very full-on and extravagant in places, but also has some really tender moments, and flows beautifully between the two. definitely an album to be listened to as a whole work rather than a handful of tracks.
Must try harder
Aside from the glorious Trains To Brazil and Made Up Love Song, which we've all heard before anyway, this album is so underwhelming. Really indulgent and completely unfocused. Disappointing
brilliant!!!
heard the album over and over again but never enough...the greatest ablum this year ive heard...
Looking forward to hearing this
I find them a bit pompous and indulgent live... But then they have some great songs so I'm really interested to hear which side the record falls on.
They do sound a bit like Prefab Sprout at times though...
Ace...
review. I love the album. Annie, let's not wait is a bit shit but the rest is excellent, I love it.
I'm going to give them the accolade of being 'the new Cure'. They remind me of them in so many ways. Guillemots for the win!
Polarizing effect
Must be something to these guys. People seem to either love them or hate them, usually the sign of a band that's worth listening to a bit more carefully than I did the first time.
I'm pretty sure
it was a yellow-brick road...
great review though.
hang on a...
i love the guillemots... but i am shocked and/or confused that the amazing Who Left The Lights Off Baby isn't on the album... i'd pretty much assumed it'd be their next single.
also there's another song they do live which is always one of the stand-outs, don't know its name, which is also missing... boo
other song
ok, so it's called Sea Out, apparently.
it's a good'un, very 'rousing'...
leaving off Who Left... is just plain weird though, easily the most likely to be a 'crossover hit', if they're at all interested in gaining wider attention
Great writing in the review
and i totally agree with the score.
its an alum full of fast and slow songs, all of which are very very good.
sao paolo is simply fantastic, and i cant help but smile throughout the whole of were here when im listening to it.
its a great uplifting, creative album,
and i dont think it is overproduce (i dont think its underproduce either though)
I
Bought this album today and it nearly blew me away, 'cause it's so overwrought and incredibly emotional. Just...a few of the slow ones don't hold on (Blue Would Still Be Blue), but yeah, I likes.
Blue Would Still Be Blue
is definitely better live - when he sings it solo without a mic and manages to silence EVERYONE it is a sight to behold. Very, very moving.
Are the review quotes at the side
put there by the writer of the review?
uncomparable?
rachel says she's looking for contempary comparisons with guilllemots. i could only think of ARCADE FIRE, and that was top ten 2005 or top 3. but then the guillemots cover even more ground than the canadians...
I now conclude
That this is one of the best albums recorded in the last 5 years. It's a work of genius.