Drowned in Sound

Search



Belle and Sebastian Push

Belle And Sebastian: Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

no votes
?
by Dom Gourlay

If any artists from the past decade epitomise the true spirit of independence then it surely has to be Belle And Sebastian. Formed by two students on a government training scheme, releasing their own self-produced demos as albums before anyone had heard of them and using the internet to rig the Brit Awards best newcomer poll in 1998. And even after that little episode they still refused to cash in on their moment of televised fame and milk it for all it was worth.

'Push Barman To Open Old Wounds' is a compilation of all of the band's singles for Jeepster Records between 1997 and 2001, and perhaps the most astonishing thing here is that despite releasing five albums over the same period of time, only one track from any of these EPs ('The State I Am In') appeared on any of their long players.

Talk about giving the fans value for money, but anyway, on with the review...

If the first single 'Dog On Wheels' was a bit of a let down in comparison to the two albums that preceeded it, then it's follow up 'Lazy Line Painter Jane' was probably the first indication that Belle And Sebastian would soon be moving out of bedsitland and into the psyche of the nation's youth courtesy of it's heavy playlisting at the time via daytime Radio 1 and ITV's much-missed 'The Chart Show'. A gorgeous five minute hammond dictated waltz that revolves around semi-sinful word interplay between Stuart Murdoch and Monica Queen, culminating in the evocative moment where both end up cooing "You will have a boy tonight, or maybe you will have a girl tonight?..."

'This Is Just A Modern Rock Song' meanwhile was feted as the "big" single, coming out just after the Brits' triumph, so in true B&S style, they released a seven minute version of the song as part of a four track EP, thus making it ineligible for the charts! Still, here in all it's glory, it marks the end of Belle And Sebastian mk1 as founder member Stuart David was to leave soon after to concentrate on his Looper project full time, although the signs had been there from the spoken word interlude of 'A Century Of Elvis' earlier on that the head of David was pointing in a different direction to the rest of his colleagues.

Belle And Sebastian mk2 could be heralded as being the start of their brief foray into making concise pop tunes, as the delightful 'Legal Man' and its accompanying b-side 'Judy Is A Dickslap' take the blueprint of seventies MOR bands like the New Seekers and turn it into something both plausible and entirely credible.

Soon after this, Isobel Campbell was also to depart permanently to concentrate full time on The Gentle Waves - again not a surprising move when listening to the likes of 'Le Pastie De La Bourgeoisie' off the '3..6..9 Seconds Of Light' EP - and after two more singles, 'Jonathan David' and 'I'm Waking Up To Us', the former featuring the poignant 'Loneliness Of The Middle Distance Runner', the band finally inked a distribution deal with Rough Trade (OK, still an indie but with a considerably bigger budget) and the second chapter of their story was at an end.

Most bands would probably rape their own mothers and sell the story just to write anything as good as most of the 'b' sides on any of these seven EPs. If you don't already own all of these singles then this compilation is a must-have addition to your CD collection. As a document of the way Belle And Sebastian have grown up in public to the sturdy staple of indie pop they now represent on a global scale, 'Push Barman...' is an essential collection of work that simply cements their status as one of the most inspirational musical collectives to have embraced punk's D.I.Y ethic since the late 1970s.

  • Belle And Sebastian 9 / 10

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

'Loneliness Of The Middle Distance Runner' was on Jonathan David :)

and is my favourite B&S song hands down.

Having failed (so far) in my bid to get all the singles and EP's, i seriously cannot wait for this collection.

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

As luck would have it, I managed to be in on B & S from around "3 6 9 Seconds of Light" so have all of the early stuff.

That's still not going to stop me from buying this though. Maybe only the Smiths and Suede (and possibly not even these two) have been so consistently excellent over the course of their b-sides.

Anyone who get into B & S later on and is wondering whether it's worth buying a compilation of early singles and B-sides, the answer is emphatically yes!!!

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

If anyone hasn't read this article, they should.

It funny.

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

It's only 3 6 9 seconds of light that my B+S collection lacks, and so I'll be picking this compilation up.

Have to agree with theguywithnousername, if you've only got into B+S with the last LP, then you must hear these songs.

Al

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

"If any artists from the past decade epitomise the true spirit of independence then it surely has to be Belle And Sebastian."

Fugazi are corporate whores!

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

I'm really looking forward to this as I am one of those who has only got into Belle and Seb recently. But I love them dearly. Yippee!

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

I have most of these EPs (some on 12") but Legal Man was the reason I went off Belle & Sebastian. The stuff before it was great (some of us 'love' Dog on wheels) and the new stuff is great (I got back into them recently after festivals), it's just theres a few tracks that made me think they'd lost the plot for a bit.

I've never even heard Wash Your Hands Child, You Smell Quite Unpleasant...

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

I may be alone in this but I think "Fold..." is unfairly maligned. Granted, it and "The Boy with the Arab Strap" are probably the worst B & S albums and the album wasn't really enough of a progression but it did have a few really strong songs. "I Fought in a War" would certainly be near the top of my list of fave B & S songs.

Didn't mind "Legal Man" either, not so keen on "Dog on Wheels" though...

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old

I'll get it eventually - but as with all back catalogue it'll be in a sale for 5.99

Dog... was the first B&S thing I bought so that might be why I quite like that & the other EPs.

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old

I do really like the rest of the songs on Dog... (and indeed the other EPs).

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

I've never really understood why "Fold..." gets slagged off constantly. Ok it's maybe a bit of a mixed bag but it's certainly got some of my fave songs on it...Model, Too Much Love, Women's Realm, Family Tree.....

Mind you I've also never got people who claim they're fans then slag off Isobel's songs. It was the whole collective approach and different vocalists and stuff that was/is part of their charm and one of the reasons I fell in love with the band when I heard Arab Strap. I definitively felt they've lost something since she left.

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

I get what you're saying, soulboy, but I think you can be a fan without liking Isobel's stuff. I too like the collaborative approach in the band ("Waiting for the Moon to Rise" is very under-rated!!!) and I think she sounds good on Famly Tree and did a good job directing the Legal Man vid but her songs always tended to be among my least favourite B & S songs.

I guess I've never been so keen on the 'twee' side of the band and I think some of her songs tended to showcase that more (although obviously you can't in any way solely blame her for this as "Nice Day For A Sulk" and "I Love My Car" are my least favourite B & S songs and I think these were both Stuarts'?)

In terms of B & S losing something since she left, I think it's true in one sense but, obviously she wasn't too happy and I think the band seem a lot more comfortable since she went so there were obviously some tensions (presumably due to the Fleetwood Mac-style inter-band relationship break-up!!!) so, whilst it is a shame she went, I can understand why it happened.

Sorry, I don't want you to feel I'm arguing unnecessarily and I'm probably nitpicking a bit but I kinda took issue with your use of the word 'claim' as I think it's normal, healthy that different fans will like different member's songs, and one of the main advantages of the collaborative approach.

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

I agree with soulboy, Isobel's songs were much maligned with no justification.
Lazy Line Painter Jane's got to be B&S at their best.
Monica Queen's album was rank tho'

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

Maybe the use of the word 'claim' was a bit strong and was certainly not aimed at you 'the guy etc.' It was aimed at some people on the boards on B&S sites long long ago.....mind you thinking about it they wouldn't have been looking at the sites if they weren't fans anyway so my argument is blown out of the water...haha.

I suppose I quite like the twee side of them myself but can be forever satisfied by Isobel's solo stuff. I personally didn't like Monica Queen's voice at all.....sounded like (hmmm what was the name of that MOR female Scottish singer from the early 80's who's 'best of' was recently advertised on telly?'

Mind you it was pointed out to me on Saturday (on my way to see Electrelane) that I have a weirdly eclectic taste with a fondness for twee ie B&S and doom laden intrumentals al la Godspeed and Electrelane oh and 70's soul....maybe I'm just weird? or maybe just have fantastic and diverse musical taste....hahaha

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

Don't worry, Soulboy, I didn't think the use of the claim was aimed at me; I just threw myself in regardless. I get annoyed by whinging from fans myself so I definitely see where you're coming from.

I think Monica Queen's voice works on Lazy Line (prob 'cos the MOR was a contrast to Stuart's more indie-ish sound. I presume you mean the woman who sang the one that went "my baby takes the morning train, he works from 9 to 5 and then etc.". I can't think of her name but think she won a TV talent show.

PS Nothing wrong with a weird music taste - most people stick too much to what they know anyway. I've spent the morning alternating between Kylie Minogue and Hefner!

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

My Baby Takes The Morning Train was by Sheena Easton. It's a hilariously cheesey song in Monica Queen territory but I think the whole Lazy Line thing works a treat.

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

Barbara bloody Dixon.....that was her! Just came to me

Re: Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

Oh, didn't read your second message. Who am i talking about then?

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

Sounded more like Maria McKee on LLPJ to me.

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Woun

I suppose with the amount of songs that B&S have done people are always going to have favourites and less favourites and dislikes... the third track on 'Fold' is terrible...in my humble opinion. Another example is I think the new Electrelane album is great but there's a horrible noodling type ambient thing in the middle which is frankly rubbish but that doesn't mean to say I still don't think it's a great album (and thank God they didn't play it live).

I just think that people saying they dislike all Isobel's songs (which you didn't 'theguy') is a bit weird with her having been so integral to the group.

Who was/is Monica Queen anyway? Was she in another Scottish group or was she treading the Sheena/Barbara MOR path

Belle And Sebastian - Push Barman To Open Old Wounds

Monica Queen is a Scottish singer/songwriter who was in a group called Thrum before she went solo. She has recorded one album 10 Sorrowfull Memories which sounds like Dido on smack. Not the most pleasurable thing to listen to. She did appear with B&S on stage last year at the Glasgow gig in the Botanics and gave a brilliant rendition of Lazy Line Painter Jane, the highlight of a brilliant day.




© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - DiScover: MySpace Trail #2