"What if you held the world in your arms?"
What if, indeed you held this blunt, rusted world in your arms. Your hands cupping its curve and your tears plopping into its many oceans.
"If I need to remember that the entire Earth is outside this room
So close the windows, keep the curtains shut forever"
Like a child, optimistically sad, waiting for the sunshine wearing a bright yellow t-shirt, when all there is to see is grey rain clouds. Idlewild bend into my ears like a startled cat jumping through a forgotten window. Nothing so stunning has come through that window in so long, I had forgoten it was open.
"I return but don’t remain, I’m impatient for a reason
To complain about winter, making me see through again"
They spread their beauty like the best jam, made from boiled up stars and silver moonlight, caught from a reflection using a green fishing net. My pulse begins to gain pace, as my eyes roll into the back of head. I want to eat all the words laid out infront of me. Have them sink into my stomach and turn my blue blood crimson.
Each song is sublime, lyrically and musically. Roddy spills his vocals like a clumsey, just woke up person spilling gasoline. My body taps and jars, i want to jump against walls and hide under my bed, both at the same time. (I mean that in good way)
"And happiness, did it happen
Sooner than the doubt it cost you
You learn from the mistakes that I taught you"
These words are what I want to say, even though i know nothing of what they mean. Words hummed under my breath for days, words aching to be heard, but Roddy does it so much better. I need to sidle up to the speaker, put my arms around it and press my head against the fine mesh. Just to get close to it. Just to get warm from its after glow. This is a perfectly imperfect (cos who likes perfection?) collection of songs that make the days seem warmer and the nights more magical.
"We stop in every passing place
To watch the world move faster than we do
Watch it pass with our eyes closed the way we usually choose to"
Idlewild - The Remote Part
i really want to interview roddy to talk about this album. think i can get a phone interview. a lot of it sounds very post 9/11 and everso slightly demanding social revolution or at least some subtle revolution.
sean
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
The lyrics are rambling and i find the effect is about what relationships can do when they go wrong, its a load of messed up thoughts coming out in an incoherant fashion but they still make perfect sense.
Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
.... just like every other plain drab review... but maybe Goliath never gets moved by records and can't relate to people who do...
Perhaps passion is indeed a temporary psychosis... then Vive la Psychosis!
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
If you want chord structures, go buy the tab sheets. If you want to hear how people feel about a record, then carry on reading.
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
This record has a similar effect on me, too.
And of course you'd call it psychosis, after all creativity is nothing but a pretty disease, but everyone wants to be sick with it! :)
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
critics. pah. i just hate the idea of them. why criticise? why judge? just enjoy, swim, drown, lose yourself, in the sound. that's what this site is about. if you want boring, chord structure dissections and degree-level grammar fuck off and read Q or Mojo or one of those proper muso magazines.
I want to know about stars, inspiring music, life changing records, records which make no sense, records which define, which invoke, which feel spiritual and dizzying. records which actually matter. entertain me, writers and musicians alike.
if you don't like it, fuck off.
sean
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
I take it all back
"Your hands cupping its curve and your tears plopping into its many oceans."
"Idlewild bend into my ears like a startled cat jumping through a forgotten window. " (What?)
"i want to jump against walls and hide under my bed, both at the same time. (I mean that in good way)"
And my own personal favorite:
"They spread their beauty like the best jam"
LOL!
Seriously though, if you're a critic, it's probably best to appear impartial, which might not best be achieved by making it seem like you want to fuck the lead singer. That aside, this is clearly genius.
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Like i always say, if you can do better, try it.
Only losers who couldn't do it sit and poke everyone else who're trying.
Why don't you put your real names/emails? Scared you might be wrong. This is the internet, there's 54million people in england alone, no-one will know who you are.
Doesnt mean we can't find you...
Re: I take it all back
And don't assume i'm a wanker just because i didn't like the review. I could easily sit and tell you to fuck off and make a better album if you wrote a bad review of something, because you're not trying to make good albums. Y'know?
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
That grammar and capilization looks SO very, very, very Joe Wisbey.
Me, paranoid, never...
Sean
p.s. i dont even like bright eyes, was just suggesting something. you can't really fuck people off during the loud bits, unless you wank in their faces or something, which maybe you do.
Re: I take it all back
Y'know...that's like saying whoever reviewed the papa roach album gave it a bad review because the singer turned down his sexual advances or something. and that's clearly not true.
Re: I take it all back
I just don't like the way you don't use your real name e-mail when clearly you can and would if you had any respect in slating other people, which is what you're doing... i mean, would you walk along the street and tell someone you hated what they're wearing or would you let the stranger walk on by?
Same differences.
Re: I take it all back
Am I allowed to have an opinion now?
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Re: I take it all back
Idlewild - The Remote Part
Good lyricists =
Stuart Murdoch - B&S
Morrissey - Smiths
Stephen Merrit - Magnetic Fields
Idlewild - The Remote Part
Worst review ever written ?
Re: Worst review ever written ?
Re: Worst review ever written ?
Re: Worst review ever written ?
oh, and idlewild suck
Re: Worst review ever written ?
face off, face on...
Re: Worst review ever written ?
Re: Worst review ever written ?
sorry ?
oh, and just quit your fucking ass as DiS head honcho cos you didn't know that 'Rocks' was actually a real Primal Scream song.
Idlewild - The Remote Part
Still, it doesn't tell me why the last single sounded like The Frank and Walters though does it? LOL
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
nothing personal by the way, i'm sure it all makes sense in your head but to the reading public it - well - doesn't.
Idlewild - The Remote Part
Idlewild - The Remote Part
That's not to say that I found Sara's review faultless. (In fact, I found its maze of rather clumsy, unintentionally humourous quasi-metaphors a little embarrassing to read.) Neither am I a fan of Idlewild. But at least the review was driven by a genuine passion for the subject it tackled. Personally, I'm glad she had the guts to approach the album in such a way, and it's a shame that so many would seek to deny her the confidence to attempt such a review again.
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
"Idlewild have returned with their 4th album! I don't have any kind of opinion so I'll just tell you what it sounds like and fuck off. Ummm, actually why don't you just go to a fucking listening booth in HMV you fucking cunts."
I wonder if they understood that. I doubt it. Go let your mum force feed your CDs down your fucking throat. It depresses me when I have to think about the idiots that I write for. You're not even worth educating. Stay ignorant. Flip me a fucking burger.
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
And my mum doesn't force me to listen to Brainiac.
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
but Raz, it's not as if you've been writing your reviews in pig latin up to now, is it ?
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
wanker!
Re: Idlewild - The Remote Part
Hopefully the writer won't be discouraged. Her decent: shite review ratio's still in her favour.
Idlewild - The Remote Part
there are three types of review
1) detailed analysis (you've read this in Q)
2) bland pap based on cliches and pre - determined judgements (you read THIS in NME)
3) An empassioned responce to the music written by a true music fan (you read this HERE)