Maturity suits certain bands better than others. Fourteen years on from their fag-toting debut and somehow the prospect of a new Supergrass album is akin to that bit in You Are What You Eat where people are confronted with heaving mounds of congealed junk food to prove what shit-scoffing morons they really are.
Well it seemed like a good idea at the time, Gillian.
Actually the reality isn’t quite so gruelling: the Oxfordshire outfit’s sixth LP is a generally likeable affair with some worthwhile highlights, eschewing the introspection of Road To Rouen for a back-to-basics approach taking in the peppy funk of ‘Rough Knuckles’, the summery, overwrought pop of ‘Ghost Of A Friend’ and ‘Diamond Hoo Ha Man’’s White Stripes-referencing lark.
‘Butterfly’’s darker textures even recall Low-era Bowie and could slot comfortably on the swampy excellence of In It For The Money, while ‘Rebel In You’ has a nice solo in it ‘til you read that sentence back and realise this band used to be better than guitar solos.
But Diamond Hoo Ha sounds completely comfortable in its own skin, and that’s half the problem: while sparing themselves the indignity of trying to fit into another man’s skinny-fit jeans, the anodyne rock crunch of the record (it’s produced by Dig!!! Lazarus Dig!!! helmsman Nick Launay) means the band spends much of the time coming on like the world’s smiliest session bores.
It seems a shame to admit it about one of Britpop’s finest exponents, but rather like fellow soul survivors and noteworthy fans Oasis, they’re a pub-rock dullard’s dream with the punk edges sanded down, channelling the spirit of various suspect figures from rock’s back pages – The Who, Thin Lizzy, T Rex – into a retro package that’s more of a glammy stodge than a jammy dodge.
Briskly performed, smartly assembled and largely unmemorable, Diamond Hoo Ha is a lot like half-asleep sex; you’re vaguely aware this is supposed to be fun, but you keep drifting off, and you might have to ask the person sitting next to you if it actually took place come the morning.
Their worst album
Road To Rouen was quite charming but this is sooooooooooooooooo dull.
men at work
Just like their live shows in recent years, it sounds workmen-like. They did glam well on Life ob Other Planets, they did introspection well on Road to Rouen. They do both of these things very badly on this record.
I loved Road Rouen.
Was hoping they would stick to that sound myself.
Not sure I'll be bothering with this one.
did you just diss Thin Lizzy?
FUCKING DIE
/\
I meant to say that call the who, t-rex and thin lizzy 'suspect' is ridiculous. They just have a lot of idiot fans, thats all.
I'm an idiot fan of Thin Lizzy AND T-Rex
but thaz ok, I get yer message Alex. Sounds like supergrass have been sliding towards "Well chaps we've completely run outta ideas then" since ishouldcoco...and now here we are Hoo Ha. I guess that's how good the debut was ...that's it's taken this long.
Standard form for Alex Denney...
7/10!!!!!
http://drownedinsound.com/release/view/9686
I like how AD
is kinda ambivalent about it all...hehe
Supergrass were always dull.
Almost as dull as me. That dull.
Everyone should ignore them.
I must admit,
I've never heard a Supergrass song that I like.
this man^
has no soul.
diamond hoo haa's not great - one album out of six ain't bad though. i've grown up with these guys and have always defended them like my own
am with you on that
I have actually seen Supergrass Live about four times accidentally without meaning to. There i am at some festival minding my own business waiting for my mate to bring me back a beer and contemplating who i should see next, then they come on and play a set. And boy are they pedestrian. They should have split after In It For the Money.
ps - i have heard this album
and i cant remember any of it. They wish they were The incomparable Thin Lizzy and T Rex. They wish.
I like the Song about
Mary Shelley was it?
Thin Lizzy were fookin ace, no arguement.
Yes actually...
'In It For The Money' was a great record! But live, they have never done it for me.
The 'grass got their balls back
I've been a massive fan of Supergrass since they came out 14 years ago. Thy've done some great albums and have been great every time I've been to see them live.
Diamond Hoo Ha is a good, solid album. Okay, so they've never been flashy but this is a hugely listenable album and I'd definitely recommend it.