Drowned in Sound

Search



pretty odd

Panic At The Disco: Pretty. Odd.

29 votes
?
by Sean Adams
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 24/03/2008
  • Label: Decaydance

Whilst gazing at a news story about "a man who died whilst drinking a Starbucks", my ears are bleeding so much the bass has become muffled. It must be sad when all anyone can say about your life is a little remark about what you were drinking when you died. That all your existence amounted to was on level par with some name-brand stimulant that you had in your hand. He probably lived an ego-less life, with no desire to create and was quite happy that he left a mark on the page of this newspaper, which will be old news before his body has begun to turn to sediment. Dunno about you but I couldn't live like that, thinking my every breath, every utterance was as impotent as the chorus I can barely hear battling with this rattling tube.

Like all great mass deceivers and conjurers, Bowie had it right - be enthralling, by keeping ‘em guessing and to keep things interesting for yourself so that life and history making doesn’t become too much like hard work. Who’d wanna be The Rolling Stones, trapped in their wrinkly rock cell, where playing that riff again has become not unlike feigning a bowel movement? Who'd want to live a life, going through the motions like Johnny Borrell at a Television tribute night. Which brings us awkwardly to Panic at the Disco, one of the biggest and most important bands in the world right now, who last time around had magpied, strike-through'd and ctrl-C'd everything about the MySpace age, chopped it all up, sprinkled in a car-crashload of Fight Club references and threw on top a healthy dose of burlesque glamour.

But the past is the past: now they’re back, somewhat braver, smarter, older, as retro-futurist as any of your Duffy/Winehouse fare, stylistically pinching their dad’s roadtrip glove box, giving the world a modern take on The Band as much as The Beatles - or rather Weezer, Saves The Day and The Shins but then they dug deeper and p2p’d their influences mentioned on Wiki’.

The result is a peculiar cocktail of refined cartoon rock that’s more anime than The Beano, muddled with the fizz of the ‘60s, the knowing grace of Queen and Muse and despite the singles being liberally doused with a saccharine shine there are times where they let the production hang loose and dusty (‘I Have Friends in Holy Places’, for example) but just like its predecessor Pretty. Odd. never sounds anything but a highly refined modern beast.

‘That Green Gentleman (Things Have Changed)’ is one of the most incongruous moments of the record with a chorus destined to be booming from radio’s and tish-tishing from bloodied earphones long into the next decade, yet it’s a song that sounds like some jittering camp ‘70s rock track that you’d find The Darkness playing on the roof of the White House in the closing scenes of the Jack Black biopic. It’s the standout track on first few listens and is just plain weird. Yet what's weirder is how the mob chants which end of ‘Northern Downpour’ recall closing moments on Pennywise albums and then the next track sounds like those glossy moments when Broken Social Scene could be U2.

Although this is a record more likely to be caught knocking over a beaker of Ribena than snapped having ye olde in-out with an eager queue of super models; the nice, slightly safe, result seems to have confused the behelzebubs out of chrome domes ready to get their mitts into another lump of mascara’d emo cum college-rock toss fer the kidz. It’s not that, well, odd, it’s just that handclaps, horns and trumpets ain’t what people were expecting. Whilst in places Pretty. Odd. is more trying than triumphant (the cringey intro ‘We’re So Starving’) the end result is something hyper enough to keep the kids excited, challenging enough to keep the band and media interested but riddled with so many hooks that bigger things still beckon these brave boys. It may not be an album to die for, but it is a rare album of note, as much for its context as its content. But then stranger legacies have grown from pithier places. Bring on their rave revival album in 2022.

  • Panic At The Disco 8 / 10

I stopped reading after sentence #2

But I quite want to hear this.


bah

6/10 at most.


Terrible follow up.

Maybe they felt out P!-cked by THNKS FR TH MMRS?

Wnna be Oasis does not a good emo band make.


A very surprising album indeed

I pretty much hated their debut, but have fallen completely in love with this record.


...


this

album grows on you like a tumor


Anyone who hated them before

and likes them now, is very, very silly indeed.


That'll be

me then. There are two main reasons for this:

1. The guy's stopped singing like he's got a cork up his ass.
2. This is a really good pop album and the last one was trying too hard to be interesting.


...

1. Lies.
2. You will (all) eat your words, I bet.


Not heard the album

But that review is really shit.


thanks


It's taken me a fair few listens...

...but I agree with this review and don't really understand all the "bad review" comments. Fact is that PATD are always going to attract those kinds of comments because - let's face it - it's not cool to like them. Brave move then to give it an 8 and brave move to make an album like this is the first place. I was firmly closeted on liking the first album (I actually liked it a LOT) for similar reasons, but consider me outed. Yay, Panic.


By the way...

...what's with all the moon imagery?


^ this ^

There's loads of it, innit.


i'm still stuck on

whether it sounds a bit like Eve6


or

Counting Crows' album?


It is a wee bit...

...Counting Crows isn't it? Without the anguished whine. Was trying to put my finger on who the slight soundalike was and now the finger has been happily placed...


it's on virgin radio

this means it is bad music

biffy clyro never made it on.


So

I can appreciate the fact that they tried something different from the first album, and will definitely alienate a lot of their hardcore fans (which can only be a good thing!), but this album is really quite bad. It's a very bland basic ripoff of The Beatles.


"bad review comments"

I personally wouldn't agree with them but mayhap they're because it focuses a wee bit much on how modern it is and it mentions variously Myspace, The Beano, The Darkness, the White House, emo, kidz, rave revival, etc.

"it is a rare album of note, as much for its context as its content." I'd rather hear about the content.

Still like the review though.


Not a fan of this record

and although I won't be too much of a scathing prick about it, I'm not a fan of this review/reviewing style either


It's... Surprisingly Alright.

I've always hated Panic at the Disco (although a ashamedly big fan of "But It's Better If You Do"), but this is actually alright. Just don't quote me on that in a few months' time. : P


.

"Panic at the Disco, one of the biggest and most important bands in the world right now"

Haha


it's actually not that bad...

we sat and listened last night...

...and waited for them to break out the theramin :)

reckon they should have looked at releasing it late summer, the british spring weather doesn't quite match up to the beach boys-esque vibe we got...

x


waste of time

I REALLY don't think that this band deserve the effort that went into this review.


i just got the album

it's not great or earth shattering. but it's really charming


it's

definitely a fun album. I would agree with the comment in that there really isn't much 'odd', but on the whole they've really taken a left-at-the-traffic-lights approach to what could easily have been a fascimile of the debut album whilst still managing to write catchy pop songs. And for that i congratulate them


Samey

So maybe they copied off different bands this time, it doesnt really equal any more talent.