Drowned in Sound

Search



guillemots red

Guillemots: Red

25 votes
?
by Billy Hamilton
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 24/03/2008
  • Label: Polydor

Do-gooding celebrities have never been my bag. Flicking through the daily rags to find a bosom of botoxed socialites slumming it with the needy frequently reintroduces me to a more coagulated form of my morning oats. The same can be said of that smug-pussed sect of the musical aristocracy who spoon-feed us shite about needing to make a difference to the world before skulking off to their countryside manors founded on sweatshop-produced merchandising and carbon-emitting live shows. (Bono, Sting, Jagger, McCartney: I'm looking at you.)

Thinking about it, this inherent scepticism of celebrity self-righteousness has probably been a feeding factor in my dismissal of Guillemots since they released 2006’s debut long-player Through The Windowpane (review). Sure, it was a record engulfed in crisp, string-laden indie-isms, but its tone was always too smirksome; too holier-than-thou in its pandering to the masses to merit attention. For me, this London-based quartet were a group who promised to soothe the music-buying public's ailments but delivered little more than earnest ballads whilst, at the same time, lining their pockets with our hard-earned coinage. Or, in short, a glorified Keane.

But full length offering numero deux is an altogether more adventurous proposition than the thimble-thumbing schmindie wincing of its predecessor. Red could be pop, it could be R&B, it could be disco. Christ, it could even be dub. Whatever way you wish to categorise this, it certainly ain't The Guillemots that I – nor anyone else who chastised the group as insubstantial meh-merchants – remember. But what I do know is this: Red is good. In fact, it’s very, very good.

Yet, taken as a whole, the facets of this genre-shuffling affair feel like the cringing culmination of your family’s record collection: yer da’s ostentatious pomp-rock is here, as is the old dear’s lipstick-caked ‘70s soul nuggets; your little sister’s glossy chart buggery also rears its naïve, hair-straightened head until wee bro' scythes it down with a trigger-shot of Timbalandic beats. And to top it off, mind that gin-guzzling, cheek-plucking embarrassment of an aunt? Well there’s a splattering of her Stock, Aitken & Waterman collection in here too.

Fucked up, huh? Well, after touching base with this multi-directional beast for the first time it certainly seems so, as a shower of futuristic sonics warp into straight-laced strum and drum before upping-sticks and launching onwards through a rhythmically skewed middle-eastern tangent. But, two, three, four spins later and Red’s mutilated exterior begins to heal as a patchwork of lush, fluid melodies that wiggles its way past resistant nerve-ends and into giddy, nauseated stomachs.

The gargantuan rumble of magnificent opener ‘Kriss Kross’ sets its precedent with a hooligan-like swarm of strings and brutal guitar that finds a willing accomplice in the pit of frontman Fyfe Dangerfield’s throat stretched bellows. This stinging intro eventually gives way to sleazy, lascivious loin-burning in the form of ‘Big Dog’ – a metallic synth shuffler that gyrates hips with such virile sexuality it makes JT’s SexyBack seem like a laughable lunchtime fumble in the playground – before lounging out into ‘Falling Out Of Reach’’s summery acoustica.

And it’s the sum of these first three offerings that epitomises this lavishly produced record’s entirety. Undoubtedly inspired by the new-breed of indispensable, utterly infectious British Pop, tracks like ‘Get Over It’ (video) and ‘Last Kiss’ pout and pose their way into the razor-cutting dance-floor mechanics of Sugababes and Girls Aloud. But there’s more to it than splicing together a wealth of modernistic melodies - shades of Terry Callier and Gwen McCrae colour the slinky disco-kitsch of ‘Cockateels’; the wistful guise of Tracy Chapman seeps into ‘Words’’ sobbing down-tempo lament; and flashes of Sandinista-era Clash dart through ‘Don’t Look Me Down’’s muffled tundra of bass and drum.

All in all, Red’s a grandiose statement of intent, crammed with aspirational symphonies that run the gambit of popular culture over the past 40 years without ever succumbing to grating pastiche. And although the echoing layers of ‘Standing On The Last Star’ may stray just a little too far into Le Bon-like territory for comfort, the sheer density, scale and magnitude of this ambitious offering ensures the thirsty desires of pop-connoisseurs are quenched with plentiful slurps of lip-licking melody.

Guillemots may never convince the cynics who’ve discarded them as yet another bunch of scruffy, talent-starved miscreants, but for those ready to bury the hatchet, Red will prove to you just how much good these indie boys cum pop experimentalists can do.

  • Guillemots 8 / 10

That is one terrible cover

It looks like a Chris Rea record from 1987!


Yes, that is a truly awful cover.

What were they thinking?


I'm Really Looking Forward to This!

I hope this review is more accurate than that in the NME, which was apparently 4/10.


As we've established since the NME awards...

The NME is well stoopid, innit.


LOL!

Very true.


funny

really, because this review reads to me like a review of the first album.

some journalists need to get over their class prejudices.


WTF


..

i'm not really sure what to make of this review.

suffice to say that i think that the nme review of the record was deeply unfair. i think its really depressing that certain publications or media entities/personalities seem to 'blackout' particular bands - guillemots must be the only mercury music prize band to not have played 'later -with jools holland' for example.


Class prejudices?

Elaborate...


You do realise

that the working classes don't exist anymore.


hrmm

i thought 'through the windowpane' was okkk. if anything it showed lots of "potential". granted i haven't heard this new one yet, but kriss kross sounds like a really really bad version of animal collective.


I can't wait for this to drop.

I loved their last full-length and it's preceding releases.

Great band and great live too.


odd enough

Get Over It sounds like some 80s synth pop band, therefore I like it

Apart from that, Guillemots are well crap


i should like them but dont

they have great production, are good arrangers and have a lot of ambition. but to be quite frank, they just dont have any tunes. some of the ballads on the first album were just staggeringly dull, and the songs i've heard from this album (which ideally should be the most instantly enjoyable) are the same; remove the bombast from get over it and it would be a belle & sebastian c-side. kriss kross really has no worthy hook at all apart from the intro/post-chorus bit.

i also really dislike fyfe dangerfield's voice, though that's just purely personal taste really


None so deaf.....

"Here lie gorgeous tunes that are lithe enough to cope with the little bursts of sonic madness that flit around like overproduced Eighties butterflies - brilliantly indulgent, wonderfully imaginative." [Observer]

Metacritic rating of TTWP 81/100
User rating 8.6/10

Of course, they are all 'staggeringly' wrong, and the Mercury Prize nomination just a wayward conclusion.


I couldn't get into 'Through the Windowpane'

and as much as I want to really like this band, and appreciate their vision and experimentation, I just always feel a bit let down by them. I think they're far too inconsistent, but they do have a few songs I really love. However, I feel like I will just let this release pass me by. The cover is awful too!


A glorified Keane?...

Ouch!


Can't get too excited about them

...every time I saw the album looking all cheap and buyable the thought that it's purchase would represent another unstoppable step towards a Prefab Sprout reunion stopped me stone dead.

*shudder*


Hmmm

'Get Over It' stinks like the after-party of an egg and cheese eating contest. If this is an indication of their current sound I should avoid.

Shame, I liked some of the first album.


Get over it

is a modern day pop gem indeed. It's attracting a lot of hate for being upbeat and joyful pop music. Oh what a crime for an indie band to commit. Someone call the Nick Cave Police.


Listen without prejudice

The number of opinions people have put on here without even hearing the album is ridiculous.

I've had the album for two weeks now and it's a grower, give it time.

If you don't like it cos it's not your type of music, then keep your opinions to yourself.