It may be 27 years since Ian Curtis passed away, but his influence remains greater than ever in almost every genre of music today.
From industrial metal to post-rock, and even some of the more downbeat solo artists of this generation, the continuing inspiration of Joy Division echoes through like an ominous spectre.
Now, with Warner Brothers choosing to re-issue three of their albums (Unknown Pleasures, Closer and Still) along with three live concerts recorded at varying points of their short-lived career, fans both new and old get a (second) chance to hear just why they were so highly revered. And, to an extent, maybe even gain some kind of understanding as to the state of Curtis' troubled mind which culminated in his tragic suicide just days before the band were due to embark on their first American tour.
The main reason for these re-issues, of course, are to coincide with the cinema release of Anton Corbijn's Control biopic of Curtis. As cynical as that may seem, let it not take anything away from what is contained within these records.
If Unknown Pleasures was the catalyst that marked Joy Division's transition from shambling punk rockers to thoughtful new wave innovators, then Closer was effectively their crowning glory. Recorded in the early part of 1980 and initially released five months after the singer's tragic death, it stands now as a fragile suicide note spread intrinsically across nine songs.
Much harsher in sound and brutally delivered than its predecessor, Closer actually feels like an invitation to participate in a nervous breakdown in its opening couplet. "This is the way, step inside" repeats Curtis over and over during the disturbing Auschwitz negating 'Atrocity Exhibition', and from then on there really is no turning back.
Closer is a record that demands to be listened to in one sitting, uninterrupted, and it is perhaps not surprising that amongst all the posthumous rummaging through Joy Division's back catalogue, nothing was lifted from it as a single.
Each composition delves deeper and deeper into a world of despair only the writer could have been a witness to, and by the time 'Decades' brings the album to a close, amidst mournful cries of "hearts lost forever", the fragility of Ian Curtis' mind reads harrowingly, like an open book.
Nothing except perhaps the Manic Street Preachers’ The Holy Bible touches Closer either lyrically or musically, although it could be argued that greater reverence has been bestowed on both records over time as a result of what happened to the central creative forces of each.
If you don't own this record then you really should, and although the accompanying live concert recorded at London ULU in February 1980 doesn't enhance their reputation in stereophonic sound, there is an underlying element of poignancy linked between the pair, if only by way of the fact each signify quite painfully how Curtis was eventually building up to that fateful day on May 18.
Unknown Pleasures b/w 'Live at Manchester Factory', Closer b/w 'Live at London ULU' and Still b/w 'Live at High Wycombe Town Hall' are all released on Monday September 17.
best album
ever recorded - nuff said
Agreed
If this is not a 10, nothing is.
Nice review though
.
Most people
award Unknown with a 10 and this with a 9. I vehemently disagree, it's the other way round for me.
Good review.
damn fucking straight
that's exactly what the nme did this week. i just don't get it. unknown pleasures sounds like a band just learning to play their instruments and not really sure what they're doing in a studio. closer sounds many, many levels above that. to me it is a perfect record. it's up there with loveless and daydream nation and pet sounds etc. and it puts new order's entire output in the shade.
It's never really clicked with me
i'd go the other way
closer is an incredible, truly touching album
but i think just for havin day of the lords and new dawn fades on one album makes unknown pleasures my favourite album of all time.. and i aint even started on shadowplay, disorder, she's lost control, and i remember nothing..
two albums , too short a lifespan , imagine what album three might have sounded like...?
craigx
'an end has a start'
Yeah. In Editor's wildest,
wettest dreams.
Never say such silly things again.
wow
gonna have to buy still, It has a track live in High fucking Wycombe!
sort it out
should have been a ten all the way, agree with the holy bible reference though
masterpiece.
songwriting on this album still ahead of time. for me, still, bernard sumner is best guitarist ever!
nice review
and good enough to make me go and buy the album tomorro.w
i look forward to hearing it.
and here I go again...
lyrically it's dark but it's more the moanings of a well read teenager then anything especially profound. the lyrics have more to do with JG Ballard's writings (and the like) then any genius on Curtis's part, and like most lyrical content the ideas are never original but a reprocessing of the work of others.
what's amazing though is the contrast between the millitary precision and space of the bass/drums and the complete atonal freedom of the guitar and vocals they allow (and, to this end, Martin Hamnett takes all the credit from what I've read and heard).
what's depressing is this review totally ignores the music (we have half a sentence at the beggining of the 6th paragraph), and instead gets sucked into some sycophantic hero worship of the "tortured artist" at the centre of it.
the songs on here are amazing though and the best they produced, but not because of the words because of the music and the sound of his voice (he could be singing anything to be honest and this would still be the most perfect of albums).
also, this is an album you can happily lift stuff from and single out, 24 Hours for one is the joint best track of that whole goth era (along with Sisters of Mercy's Body Electric) and I happily play it whenever I DJ, and I'd say the album as a whole has 4 killer tracks on it which stand out way past the others.
more than JG Ballard in those lyrics...
...a lot more. A lot lot more. Nietzsche, Francis Bacon, the holocaust....
Stephen Morris is the most under-rated drummer of all time. The emotionless rythym to Atrocity Exhibition is every bit as powerful as Curtis' tortured musings.
that was kind of my points...
in that he's just recyling other peoples ideas and not "adding" anything of his own.
and the drumming is fantastic, BUT hamnett has to take a lot of the credit for insisting on that particular feel and sound.
if you look at the sisters of mercy who were doing a lot of similar stuff at the same time they were using a drum machine (!) and you get the feeling the idea is to recreate that feel but with real life drum sounds. the linn kit hadn't been invented yet after all and as soon as it was you have the whole of 80's pop ahead of you...
Hamnett/Hannett
Why do so many people persist in misspelling Martin Hannett's surname?