Drowned in Sound

Search


Drowned in Sound Event sponsored tours and events.

The National - Boxer

The National: Boxer

4 votes
?
by Samuel Strang

“Stay up
super late tonight,
picking apples,
making pie,
put a little something
in our lemonade
and take it with us…”

What a dross opening verse to a record. Try to spout those sub-Springsteen lines without sounding a prat. Uttered by Matt Berninger’s reassuring croon, though, it seems so vital. Berninger seems the sort of majestic loser that you can associate with, a man ridden with gin-soaked, existential guilt. Under the dreary-eyed malaise of ‘Fake Empire’, The National return. Whilst the triumphant fist that previous LP Alligator rose may have lowered, Boxer documents the standard relationship gripes with absolute resignation and, though not quite as immediately arresting and rampant as its plaudit-acquiring predecessor, is an album of understated brilliance.

In the same renounced manner as their second album Sad Songs For Dirty Lovers, downtrodden and disenfranchised, Boxer documents the secluded aspect of city life, as ‘Mistaken For Strangers’ potently alludes to distant work acquaintances. The record is full of regret and perverted maliciousness. ‘Brainy’ casually scorns that “though I keep your fingerprints in a pink folder in the middle of my table, [...] think I better follow you around”, as if a disgruntled voyeur in denial of a recent cold shoulder, delivered by Berninger with the deadpan misery and embedded dry wit of Stephen Merritt or David Berman.

Boxer is far more subdued than any of The National’s previous efforts. Whilst they are forever indebted to the unassuming contribution from drummer Bryan Devendorf, who effortlessly alternates from rampant flurries to muted details, it is the subtle orchestral aspect to the record that stands out, with the same washed arrangements that Grizzly Bear and close cohorts Clogs manage to incorporate so casually.

Embroiled by dealing with commitment and dedication, whilst ‘Apartment Story’ and ‘Guest Room’ are call to arms for distant gentleman lovers to "just tie your women to your wrist, give her the room to tie up the other", enlightened by a newfound infatuation, the most imposing moments on the record are those that detail a relationship’s downfall. Despite something of a lull, 'Start A War' snipes with conviction at a partner’s reluctance to confront their problems. 'Slow Show' begs to start all over again, bemoaning that “you know that I dreamed about you, for 29 years before I met you” with the stone-faced realisation that the sly fumble with the neighbour was neither particularly sly, nor worth the relationship now threatened.

‘Gospel’ closes proceedings in a suitably understated manner. Whilst this aspect to the record can initially all seem rather lukewarm, the resigned tone of Boxer is one of its finest aspects, authentically affecting and reaffirming of its state.

“Stay up
super late tonight,
picking apples,
making pie,
put a little something
in our lemonade
and take it with us…”

...dulled brilliance.

  • The National 9 / 10

Yep

this record is ace.


They are fantastic

The NME reckons they sound like U2.

Wankers.


fuck off nme

clearly copy and paste journalism, louis pattison wrote about the national in the guardian 'they could be u2, in a parallel world where Bono sees his reflection in a puddle and says "you know what bono, you're a shit"'. so true. its a great example of style and substance combined, introspected yet with a cut of humour and yes, even the cheese works, giving you the kind of grin that says being silly is a release. breathtaking, beautiful and great to see that they can go off on something of an orchestral tangent and still produce something so relevant


The Guardian

are now eating their young:
http://music.guardian.co.uk/reviews/story/0,,2081968,00.html


wtf

"Unfortunately, both records they have released since joining Beggars Banquet have pursued a claustrophobic, minor-key U2-on-a-budget sound, with a lot of clatter and chime and little of their early magic."

seriously, have they actually paid any attention to either of these records?!


...

Intruiging...


sheer

brilliance


its a brilliant record

its good to see they didnt try and repeat Alligator... and they've tried something really a bit different (Driven by Drums, vast Piano)..

Whilst Fake Empire's opening lines are comparitively cheesy, Matt mentioned somewhere in an interview that he aims for "30% silly lyrics"... i guess it means that the album doesnt end up unbearably intense.

what a band.


It really is very good.

It only gets better with repeated listens.


Very good review Samuel

Captured the essence of their sound really well.

I personaly found it more immediate than "Alligator" though, and a bit more epic and grand sounding than previous records.

But hey, each to their own!


ok

i'm buyin' it.


I am too

as i'm so easily led by DiS these days! Plus I'm going to see these guys in little old stoke quite soon (1 of only a couple of UK shows I heard). Can't wait now.


funny

when i checked out the first track on the album, i was put off by his drone, so i didn't listen any further.
Yet, something was niggling at me.. i really wanted to like this band, so i went back and had another listen on their myspace, and it is truely awesome.
Its a grower for sure, but even after one listen you can really appreciate it.


Brilliant

Superb album from the best band in the world, along with The Wrens.


Obviously

not as good as Alligator. They're everyone's favourite new band though, so I won't stop them earning wages from this album.


This is a

strang review.


I Think..

..this album is fantastic.
The reworked '29 Years' (Slow Show) is one of the many highlights.
I fully reccomend this album for a nice change from commercialisation.


great work sam..

really wicked prose in this review.. made me go and pick up the record :)


Yeah, they're pretty good...

but like a lot of these '9/10 in indie rock circles' bands around these days, where are the truly memorable songs? Songs that will stand the test of time? Like Ghost Town, Fools Gold, Smells Like Teen Spirit, This Charming Man, Live Forever, Love Will Tear Us Apart, Guns Of Brixton, Common People, Blue Monday, etc...

It's all well and good giving these types of records rave reviews now, but in ten years time will this record really be comparable to London Calling or The Queen Is Dead - albums that have truly great songs that still resonate years later? I doubt it.

So, yeah, it's pretty good in an indie rock kind of way. But that's all it is. Let's not go over board.


...

It depends what you see as songs of lasting value. Personally I don't like the songs you listed all that much - sure, they may be more radio friendly, and therefore have received more airplay, thereby making them more 'memorable' (drilled into your head), but that doesn't make them great songs (in my humble opinion).

Still, horses for courses, and I think this is a great album by a comparatively under-appreciated band. Nice review too :)


...

I wouldn't assume just because a record receives a 9/10 review that it's a statement of the reviewer's belief that the record will "stand the test of time". It's more likely that he just thinks it's a great record that deserves substantial acclaim (which it does, in my opinion anyway).

Does it contain songs as memorable as the classics you mentioned? Probably not, no. But that's not to deny that the album is something of a quiet piece of brilliance with gorgeous melodies and wonderful instrumental playing.


...

Can't say I'm terribly arsed about Berninger the poet to be honest. Only played it twice but there's only a couple of tunes leaping out at me and not with the same immediacy as 'Secret Meeting', 'Karen' or '...Soho Riots' for example. Seemed patchy to me with some very overbearing drumming.


It needs a few listens to really get into it

but it's fantastic.


It really is quite wonderful

The piano loop at the end of Slow Show is the most beautiful thing you'll hear all year...


Yes!

I 100% agree with you.


so far

probably one of the best things released this year, and it's still growing on me.


It is a bit good.

Better than Alligator?


"Boxer"

Fantastic review.

I pretty much agree. It's still growing on me so i'm not going to say that that the album isn't 9/10 worthy. I'm really really enjoying this.

I have never actually listened to The National before *blushes* but there you go, a new band to obsess about!

Great so far.