Sign In:
53093

Party Like It's 1992: Nirvana and Cobain Guitar Hero 'feud' starts to make even less sense

Today has seen somewhat surreal turn of events speed up rapidly since just the other day, where Kurt Cobain was revealed as a playable avatar in the Guitar Hero 5 computer game, in which he even sings Bon Jovi. If you make him.

Well, some people found this pretty distasteful, and sometime-writer on this very website and one-time friend of the band, Everett True, decided to point the finger firmly at the widow of Cobain, Courtney Love, and Nirvana drummer and Foo Fighters leader Dave Grohl.

Well, Love - who is well known for her Twitter ramblings - exchanged 'pleasantries' with True over the course of the next few hours or so, saying that she never gave permission. Then True posted this blog on The Guardian, giving his side of the argument. The details aren't necessarily that important, but what we got from it was that a) they disagreed and b) they both really, really, really, fucking hate the fucking Foo Fighters. Which is fair enough, really.

Courtney Love then threatened to sue the people behind the Guitar Hero game, Activision.

She wrote (verbatim):

"not in twenty JILLION years would i EVER have allowed this and this islethal."

"we get NO money for this, travesty, Frances gets NO money for the rape."

But what about Grohl, what has he to say? And won't someone remember the bass player?! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD THE BASS PLAYER! That's Krist Novoselic, by the way. As it happens, the surviving members of Nirvana have just released a statement regarding the issue at hand, with fewer curse words than Love, and a little more coherence (via Pitchfork).

They said:

"We want people to know that we are dismayed and very disappointed in the way a facsimile of Kurt is used in the Guitar Hero game. The name and likeness of Kurt Cobain are the sole property of his estate - we have no control whatsoever in that area.

"While we were aware of Kurt's image being used with two Nirvana songs, we didn't know players have the ability to unlock the character. This feature allows the character to be used with any kind of song the player wants. We urge Activision to do the right thing in "re-locking" Kurt's character so that this won't continue in the future.

"It's hard to watch an image of Kurt pantomiming other artists' music alongside cartoon characters. Kurt Cobain wrote songs that hold a lot of meaning to people all over the world. We feel he deserves better."

And now the game's developers have released a statement:

"Guitar Hero secured the necessary licensing rights from the Cobain estate in a written agreement signed by Courtney Love to use Kurt Cobain's likeness as a fully playable character in Guitar Hero 5."

This all leave's us more confused than ever before. The only thing we're currently certain of is that Kurt Cobain is indeed dead. Everything else is very much up in the air. Since the Nirvana members' statement True has apologised to Grohl.

How ridiculous is this then? What the bloody hell is going on? Is it really that distasteful? Have Activision done anything wrong?

worse though

is the fact that the green mohair cardi he's got on was the one he wore on the UNPLUGGED show and during the IN UTERO tour. it seemed really eerie. dunno why.

"The only thing we're currently certain of is that Kurt Cobain is indeed dead"

not true - we also know that Everett True knew him!!!!!!

^ ET may have mentioned it once or twice

This whole thing seems to stem from Courtney a) not knowing what's going and b) being broke. She wants to sort that out.

Activision must be rubbing their hands at all this free press, eh?

AND...

...that Daniel Johnston tee.

I thought people would be over guitar hero by now

1 was a novel distraction, 2 was pushing it, but its just a plastic button guitar.

If I turn out to be in a famous band,

before commiting suicide, I want it to be known now that they can put my likeness in Guitar Hero. I'll also issue a pre-emptory statement to my grieving widow and friends - everyone, it really doesn't matter.

guitar hero

was always a boring videogame. i genuinely never understood the appeal.

...

The appeal of Guitar Hero is the appeal of almost all games: You get to simulate an activity that would otherwise take years of training/negating of the laws of physics to perform in real life.

If you can't understand this, then you are legally dead. Sorry.

Additionally, this dispute is retarded. It's a fucking AVATAR of some guy. No doubt many people have had the idea to create a character with floppy blonde hair and a stripey jumper - you know, like how he looked in that one photo once.

Foo Fighters, Courtney Love, Everett True: All cretins.

P.S. That said, we really should pay Frances for the rape.

i'm starting to wish the word 'rape'

wasn't thrown around so casually. it feels wrong

This is bloody ridiculous

At the end of Guitar Hero World Tour, you're a supergroup with Sting, Billy Corgan and Ozzy Osbourne playing NYE on a skyscraper, and you kick out La Bamba. It's silly but how is that an insult? It's a computer game avatar...you can make the Undertaker mince around like a Diva, you can make Thierry Henry white if you want; I don't get what the issue is here.

we'll also ensure players can make you sing

the entire collected works of bananarama, celine dion and leo sayer

I laughed so much when I saw my gf playing the bit at the end on the 4th one

Honestly don't know why they're all kicking up a fuss. Especially as courtney knew what was being signed up for, but was just on too much crack to remember.

I think, maybe, the issue is to do with that Kurt can sing other songs...

...as an unlockable character. Though. Possibly.

ah bananarama

ive always had a vague idea for an all girl tribute band doing nirvana songs in the style of bananarama.
Their name?
Nirvanarama.
Im going to hell

Not that bothered really.

Fine article/news piece though - very well written. Nice one Luke:)
Some game I'm never gonna play has the image of some dead dude I REALLY liked 20 years ago on it and the arguement is about - what exactly? Cool points? Money? E True getting prissy with his ex-main squeezes widow? Their respective legal representatives not reading the small print>Whatever... If you like KC A LOT you may even have the little figurine doll or a pair of his replica trainers or whatever. You may even buy the re-issue Bleach CD/vinyl/download out in a month (I know I will). Personally I've eased my hatred towards Bon Jovi since despising them in the late 80s. Not so much that I'd buy a record, go see them live, google them, look up live versions of Wanted Dead Or Alive on youtube - but ya know.. lifes too short.

Oh...

this is painful....

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon