The Weekly Eastern DiScussion: just what do we know about Eastern music?
While artists from Japan have made inroads into western musical circles for many a year now – one only has to cast their mind back to last year to find Polysics touring with Kaiser Chiefs – few bands from other far eastern countries – China, Korea, Thailand, et cetera – have transferred domestic successes onto an international platform; or, rather, one beyond their immediate neighbours. Why is what DiS wants to know.
J-Pop (literally Japanese pop music) is a phenomenon in Japan, and has been since the days of Emperor Hirohito when American jazz crossed the Pacific. Its Korean cousin, K-Pop, is similarly huge (C(hinese)-Pop is growing, too): although restricted to the southern territory – popular music is still tough to find in North Korea – the movement has been building a considerable head of steam since the early 1990s. Considered experimental for the market they operated within, the group Seo Taiji and Boys (pictured) re-wrote the Korean pop rulebook in 1992, incorporating aspects of western contemporary music such as rap and techno and breaking into the charts in ballistic fashion. The band dominated the Korean market a la Take That in the UK, but their name never breached geographical boundaries.
Today, things are improving – with the internet providing music fans the world over access to the weirdest and most wonderful indigenous work around, the likes of Korean boyband TVXQ and former girlband singer turned solo artist Ayumi Lee are exposed to a global audience, should said audience want to search them out. Some musicians turn to acting to aid their exposure – Lee Jung-hyun, for example, balances a successful pop career in Korea, evolving from techno-influenced output to more Spanish-flavoured material, with a series of motion pictures. But still these acts, and myriad others, remain on the fringes of worldwide acceptance.
That why seems to boil down to one thing: the language barrier. But that may soon be a thing of the past, as Chinese continues to be spoken by more and more foreigners. Already a heavy influence on Japanese and Vietnamese in terms of style, the language is becoming essential for business transactions, as China grows as an international marketplace. In the music world, though, China is still seen as a pirate’s paradise – illegal copies of albums flood the market, and the result is that many releases are tested in Hong Kong and Taiwan before China.
Few Chinese acts have, as yet, explored foreign audiences beyond the realm of the internet. Rock outfit Joyside, from Beijing, even experienced difficulty taking their music on the road domestically: their attempts to win over audiences unmoved by rock ‘n’ roll are captured in the film Wasted Orient. Its American director, Kevin Fritz, said of the film: “The film Wasted Orient is what it is, pure and simple. It's honest. It is the true way of Chinese rock n' roll. It's not glamorous. It's filthy. It's filled with despair. It's very unwanted in that society and is shown in its citizens' apathetic response to it.”
Heavy metal is popular in China, yet many of the country’s big names are unknowns beyond their native land. Tang Dynasty, for example, have been at the forefront of the Chinese metal scene since 1992, yet to most DiS readers their name will be unfamiliar. Overload are a thrash band who were featured in Wire in 1995; again, their name will be new to most outside of China. Of them, Wire writer Steven Schwankert penned:
“The band plays like they're on fire - literally. Halfway through their first song, an amplifier at stage-right ignites and burns until technicians beat it out. Guitars and vocals cut out at various points as wires come loose, but the show goes on. At the end of the set, a 50-year-old man standing in front of the stage joined Overload's fans in a chorus of ‘one more!’”
Sounds brilliant. But it’s brilliantly obscure, still, and the above few are but a skimming of the surface, a cursory take on the multi-faceted musical market of the Far East. Which brings us to our DiScussion question, again: why?
Do Korean acts – and those popular in China (where punk-rock is fighting back following the closure of many bars several years ago), Singapore (which has a burgeoning urban scene), Thailand (which has an expanding indie-rock scene), et cetera – care about crossing over into western markets? Do consumers here want to hear music from so very far away, both culturally and geographically speaking? Is piracy in the Far East so bad that labels simply aren’t bothered about traditional formats anymore, preferring to put their artists onto televised talent shows? (Look at Morning Musume’s success through the TV show Asayan.)
What bands/acts in the Far East could benefit from exposure in the UK and the US? Are there great bands that Britain is missing out on, simply because of a few boundaries? Why have so few acts – even from Japan – made it into the west, and what do we actually know about the market of China and its surrounding countries?
DiScuss…
From the archive
maher shalal
hash baz
ZING!
I like Japanese Telecom
I don't think they're Japanese, though. Although they could be! I really don't know either way
www.myspace.com/theyours
Hong Kong's answer to Ride, and good they are too.
Cultural differences?
I've been trying to find out more about the independent scene in Hong Kong. It seems that the locals are just not interested.
The people who are involved in the independent scene are people who have gone abroad for school/university and so have grown up in a different way compared to the locals. The locals would rather go shopping or to the karaoke.
With the lack of support back home, I guess most of the bands have to rely on full time jobs, and so touring abroad is difficult.
.
This is a subject quite close to my heart, but alas, I'm currently pressed for the time to give the considered response I'd like to.
I think one of the major factors is our tendency, as Westerners, to 'Other'-ise music made by anyone who isn't Western. If we're talking about the mainstream, the simple fact is that people aren't interested in songs sung entirely in a different language, and, dare I say it, made by Asian looking people. In much the same way as a metal band made up entirely of females is doomed to be referred to eternally as a 'girl metal band', regardless of what they sound like, a mainstream, run of the mill Japanese rock band like Asian Kung Fu Generation or Mr Children simply wouldn't make the cut in Western charts because there are similar Western bands (Foo Fighters, Feeder) who are doing exactly the same thing - people simply wouldn't be interested in a Japanese rock band unless it confirmed their internal 'Other'-ing of East Asians and provided something different to what we already have. A Japanese rock band will always be described as just that - a 'Japanese rock band', and as such there's the implication that such a thing should somehow be different to what we've already got.
A cursory glance over the Japanese acts that tend to get known in the West will confirm this: by and large, any descriptions of them will be preceded by 'crazy' or 'mental', as though this is what we should come to expect from the Japanese. Were The Mad Capsule Markets Western, they'd be described as 'innovative' - as it is, they're labelled as 'crazy Japanese manga mental' or by some other meaningless epithet, serving only to confirm deeply rooted cultural expectations that the Japanese are somehow 'different' to us. The vast majority of Japanese bands that have achieved any kind of fame in the West are similarly 'weird', 'crazy', 'kitsch', or 'cute', and provide something for the Western listener that supposedly couldn't have come from their own culture, often involving cute girls shouting in high-pitched voices etc.
Perhaps I'm going too far - but in summary, I think it's definitely indicative of insitutionalised racism and cultural expectations of East Asians as somehow 'different' to ourselves that there's an extra barrier that non-Western bands have to leap before finding themselves in a position where fame could be even become an option. This isn't to say that Mono, Envy, Boris and the like are particularly 'crazy' when compared to their Western counterparts, but the fact remains that none of those bands are ever going to make it big, either.
As for an act that not nearly enough has been said about: World's End Girlfriend. Latest album 'Hurtbreak Wonderland' is a masterpiece of epic proportions.
^
Good post
stuff from pakistan
well actually most of them play your average alt-rock fair, but there's one stunner:
pretty much a mix of classical indian music with some prog rock tendencies.
Daft names
But if English isn't your first language, I guess that can be expected.
I'm a little surprised there's no mention of indie faves 'Melt Banana'. Especially as there's a new album out (today as a matter of fact).
In the nineties you had the kitch 'Pizzacto five' and the Jesus-Jones like 'Boom Boom Satelites'.
In the nu-metal years 'The Mad Capsule Markets' managed to knock out a couple of albums before that bandwagon stopped rolling.
This lot have the most wonderful name : http://www.myspace.com/thesigit
That's 'The Super Insurgent Group of Intemperance Talent'. Metal from Indonesia.
.
While I don't want to start sounding all defensive, Mad Capsule Markets released their first album in 1989, and are about as non-bandwagon a band as you could possibly hope to find!
Olivia Lukin
Olivia Lufkin from Japan is great. She has the potential to crossover because she sings in English but has a distinct Japanese style. She doesn't fit in the typical Japanese stereotype of being a bit bonkers.
Cold Fairyland from Shanghai are causing a big stir in the live scene. The are like Arcade Fire but use traditional Chinese instruments.
I've lived in HK for many years and there is no way the local population would ever embrace an alternative act. Everyone likes cheesy love ballads. Air Supply are cool in this part of the world. They would be be a bigger live draw than U2.
Good point.
However, from a personal point-of-view, I can't help but disagree. I would never listen to a Japanese rock band that sounded like Feeder as they are absolute dogshit.
I'd also be unlikely to bother listening to a tabla guru from Wigan whose aim was to play exactly like Zakir Hussein. It's simply uninteresting to me.
Re-interpretation and cross-pollination are always going to be more exciting than appropriation, simply because there's a dialogue involved.
Maybe I have an ethnocentric perspective on this, or maybe I just like to hear new sounds.

DiScover: redcarsgofaster
Spotifriday #23 - This Week on DiS as a playlist
DiScover: Grammatics
In Photos: Arctic Monkeys @ Wembley Arena, London
In Photos: The Flaming Lips @ The Academy, Manchester
In Photos: Moby @ The Palace Theatre, London
In Photos: Tegan & Sara @ Shepherds Bush Empire, London
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article