Sign In:

The White Stripes

Edit this event

Anyone who can slap the living bejesus out of indie’s prettiest singer (Jason Von Bondie) and still have enough marbles to come play to the venomous vacuums of Ally Pally with his chubby-armed sister is a better Bluesman than you. Still, there’s something fervently dark about Jack White’s exaggerated and cartoonish expressions that punctuate their ‘not-exactly-laugh-a-minute’ set and make it just a little more worthwhile than every other ten-a-penny garage band.

Let’s cut the crap though and be honest here. Musically, it’s shite. The drumming is terrible – Meg White cannot keep time for fuck and makes Tony McCarol look like Jimmy Chamberlain. Jack White is brilliant at what he does, but needs a better medium for his potential. The rawness of having just one barely-tuned guitar is a novelty and nothing more. A bass would heartily improve the music (as the multi de-tuned layers of the recorded 'Seven Nation Army' showed), and though stripped down rawness is cool, without the confines that their basement club origins offered or the benefit of multi-tracking, the sound often as vacuous as the venue. Sadly, the biggest anthem of last year comes out as a gutless shadow of itself.

Still, a tune is a tune as they say, and 'Hotel Yorba' leads the charge for beer-baiting Oasis-fan singalongs, whilst 'Dead Leaves And The Dirty Ground' is as thrilling as ever. Jack’s moog action works well, and with the host of covers including 'Shine On Harvest Moon' they certainly don't stick to the radio hits. But for every 'We’re Going To Be Friends' they play, there’s a good portion of fretwanking guitar buggery that would make even metal kids cringe.

It’s honourable that the Stripes haven’t sold-out their sound for the huge stage, but I doubt Jack White would argue that this just don’t work without the sweat dripping off the walls and the floor sticking to your feet.

  • The White Stripes 5 / 10

The White Stripes

Lay off Meg you twot. I play drums and would rather listen to her than some click-track following fuck. I suppose Moe Tucker should never have been let near a drum kit either, eh? Sexist, dull and deaf, fuck off and listen to Rush.

The White Stripes

This review is spot on. A quick count of the setlist reveals that there were 9 songs played not on any of the 4 White Stripes albums. While I'm not averse to new tunes or old ones played well, I found myself and the majority of the people around me standing thinking 'what the fuck is this?' too many times as Jack wanked his fretboard for eternity.
This gig had a lot of ocassional or first time gig-goers in the crowd and I wouldn't be surprised if their next gig is some time away following that performance.

The White Stripes

Sexist? Get off yo' high horse. Meg's not crap because she's a woman just in the same way Stuart Cable isn't crap because he's a man.

The White Stripes

Unlike most modern rock bands, where the drummer is required to be the pulse and anchor holding the band together (or at least a GOOD drummer does those things), in musical terms Meg is there to emphasize what Jack does, and it's directly related to Moe Tucker, who did almost exactly the same for the Velvets. Think about it... if the drumming in the White Stripes existed as a musical entity in itself, then it would detract from the solo guitar blues. However... when I heard The Flaming Lips do 'Seven Nation Army' with same energy, but with a bass player, it did make The White Stripes look very one-dimensional. The Blues is good, visceral and heart wrenching, and it comes across great on record...but it's meant for small stages, not stadia, where the intimacy is lost and that missing bottom end is impossible to blag. The band has been a victory for authenticity over polish, and paves the way for a Pixies revival (because he doesn't half sound like Black Francis)!!!

The White Stripes

'Chubby armed sister'... ooooh, hark at him. Handbags at sixteen paces at dawn methinks with that jibe. But the sound, ah yes, the beautiful sounds that we hear through our ears when we are near... of course it's got a fucking great hole in it. Most basic guitar bands sound shite in a big ol' place when they have a bassist and perhaps two guitars in the mix. It's fucking stupid to play in such a big venue from a quality of view. The alternative of playing small gigs would mean a better/more appropriate sound.

Meg's drumming was alright when they played these here Toronto parts. She ain't flashy just like Tony McCaroll but who gives a toss? It fits, it's fine.

Re: The White Stripes

The remark was in no way intended as sexist.

The fact that she is female is not the point. She is not a good drummer. Nor is the girl from Electrelane. But I'm not saying all female drummers are rubbish. There's plenty of shocking male ones.

Anyone interested in seeing a raw garage/blues band with a top drummer should check out THE MODEY LEMON tomorrow (Tuesday) at the London Barfly.

Happy Australia Day!

The White Stripes

Would you call Stuart Cable chubby armed? And if you did what point would you be trying to make? I was trying to say that she is an unconventional drummer and that she works within the context of The White Stripes. Just as Moe did in the Velvets. Yes, there are load of shit male drummers - listen to Razorlight - but Meg does her own thing and does it well, a bit of variety in a dull musical mainstream.

Re: The White Stripes

That's fair enough and well put, it's just that I prefer drummers to be able to hold time. But you're entitled to your own opinion, of course.

The White Stripes

I don't think it matters one bit that Meg's a below average drummer. She and Jack play brilliantly together. You can tell they've been playing together for a long time cos they're kinda intuitive. I thought it was a brilliant gig - better than The Strokes there in December and as good as Radiohead at Earl's Court.

As for 'fretwanking', give us a break. Jack White is the most exciting guitarist I've ever seen.

Re: The White Stripes

How many guitarists have you seen?

Re: The White Stripes

He's certainly better than the guitarist in Keane, but he's not exactly Jimmy Page.

The White Stripes

I do like this site generally, but you all want your bloody heads banging together about The White Stripes. The gig was nothing short of magnificent, and you know it - you just daren't admit it on here. A bit like DIS's equally shite (and appropriately trendy, one assumes) reviews of Seven Nation Army and Elephant.

Pah. I'll stop visiting, at this rate

The White Stripes


Oh c'mon Futes, you rip on Jack for guitar onanism and then complain that he's no Jimmy Page, a man who's certainly had his fair share of self-induced pentatonic ejaculations on record and on stage. Wankery is great as long as it's tasteful, yes?

Re: The White Stripes

1,719, approximately

Re: The White Stripes

Point taken; replace w Jimmy with Bernard then.

The White Stripes

Im completely off the white stripes. firstly for the abysmal 'button to button' song. balls.
and secondly for jack's beating of and disfigurement of scott stollseimer (?). it defies me how anyone can so viciuosly attack another human being and cause them so much damage in any sense. but then to claim that it was self defence. what a pompous twat. i hope he rots in jail.
and dont get me started on that moustache!

Re: The White Stripes


Hmm.. Sumner or Butler? :)

Re: The White Stripes

Manning!

Re: The White Stripes

Damn, I'd go for Bernard Bresslaw meself. Any man who appeared as a Carry On staple as well as one of the great Doctor Who aliens (an Ice Warrior) can't be all bad.

The White Stripes

white stripes are abit shite + i think now is the time where the fad wears off - they are one big fad. listen to their other two-piece counterparts like the Black Keys - now that is pure talent, innovation + captivation i saw them live last week in London + i swear Dan Auerbach has the most Hendrix-esque voice + guitar skills = NOT wankery.

The White Stripes

just because jack decided to twat jason stollstiemer a bit, shouldn't change your view on the whites stripes music. i went to see them at ally pally and they were great, but yeah the venue was to big, but so what? they played like 6 venues in january so i felt pretty lucky to be at one of them, especially as i was at the front looking directly at jack and meg white. to say that megs "chubby armed" is shallow and also that she can't play the drums, because quite clearly she can, how on earth would the stripes come to be so respected in the music industry if meg couldn't play the drums, and jack couldn't play the guitar? eh? answer me that.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon