Sign In:

Soweto Kinch

Edit this event

Don’t be surprised if you’ve not heard of Soweto Kinch; prior to April 12, I too had only a few songs from a MySpace page and the information I robbed from Mike – “c'mon - he raps and plays sax!” – to advise me of what lay in wait under a railway arch round Old Street.

As it turns out, Kinch has been right under the noses of the music-buying public for a while now, counting a MOBO amongst the prizes in his trophy cabinet, as well as a Mercury nomination for his 2003 debut album Conversations with the Unseen. Even the list of accolades don’t quite do his musical talents justice, both as a show-stealing saxophonist and narrative hip-hop MC, his second album A Life In The Day of B19: Tales of the Tower Block being a collection of stories centring around its three main characters.

Translating well to the live stage, Kinch weaves these well-rendered tales with a laid-back natural hip-hop vocal flow over the heavily-grooved jazz soundtrack provided by his four-piece backing band, regularly swapping between microphone and saxophone mid-song without breaking stride. The ease onstage matches his rapport with the crowd, as between each song our narrator outlines a fresh set of circumstances with a glint in the eye.

When they find a good balance of hip-hop and jazz, the Soweto Kinch Quintet demand your full attention, though tonight these instances aren’t as frequent as some might like. Perhaps it’s an obvious criticism of a show of this nature, but there are just so many jazz solos it can be a bit much for anyone with no love for jazz as a stand-alone genre, with the sax, bass, guitar and drum solos sometimes running consecutively and lasting in excess of four minutes each time.

Even ‘Ridez’ – on record perfectly-balanced, complete with a sax hook easily the equal of any current commercial hip-hop single found on daytime radio as well as a voiceover from Moira Stuart – has an extra couple of minutes crow-barred into the centre, though it does little to interrupt the excellence in this instance. With jazz you'd expect this kind of approach, but there’s just so much of it here that after a while it all feels a little self-indulgent for anyone not familiar with its methods. Kinch’s first saxophone solo tonight is jaw-dropping, the second sounds a lot like the first, and the third sounds largely the same as the other two.

The aficionados lap it up, but some are just left a bit alienated, though it’s still far more pleasant to take in than the bastardized pop-jazz of Jamie Cullum. Too much jazz, not enough rap perhaps, though that’s subject to personal taste. What is abundantly clear is that in Soweto Kinch, Britain has a charismatic performer and an undeniable talent, though the live show might have to change if he’s going to become anything other than a well-kept secret outside of certain circles.

  • Soweto Kinch 7 / 10

....

I saw him in 2005 at the Colston Hall in Bristol - he was ace - surprised you hadn't heard of him really....

yeah, as you recognise, your criticisms about there being too much jazz is rather odd - he is first and foremost a jazz musician and has never really claimed to be otherwise...

i think its because

on record, its under control and well-balanced with the rap elements, then when you go and see him live its much more jazz-based..

.. and

not just normally jazz-based, excessively so.

jazz based

what exactly does "normally jazz-based" mean? I don't think I'm being excessively pedantic in asking this.

no, i dont think you are either

it means being based upon jazz, just playing together as a band without going overboard with a handful of solos per song until they all just blend into one.

to be fair, i'd have been just as bored if i went to a rock/indie show and every song had some kind of solo.

This is gonna be a long one

Since I first saw him at a jam session years ago, it's been really obvious that he's the type to make waves. Such a good player.

As for the 'excessively jazz based' comments: a fusion like this is always going to draw criticism as it's bringing together people who have fairly polarised listening experiences.

As someone said, on the record it's possible to balance these things out, but jazz music is an essentially 'live' experience, in the sense that the musicians are constantly improvising, not just in the solo sections, but throughout the music and in response to the melodies. This means that solo sections are likely to 'stetch out' as they have an indefinite length and tend to run their course according to the mood, situation and basically level of creative development the soloist is capable of.

To an audience with hip hop in mind, this is obviously a slightly alien approach. In saying this, I'm not discounting the freestlye traditions which are innate to hip hop, but more highlighting the decades of harmonic development in jazz improvisation which have led the the lenghtly interpretations possible of a spontaneous solo. It's hard to go into without getting massively technical, but it's well worth watching/reading any interviews with Soweto on the subject of the push and pull between traditions. Also, check out his tune 'Intermission: Split Decision' from his first record.

Basically, Jazz can be an artform that isn't neccessarily instantly gratifying and can take a little getting used to: The first time I heard John Coltrane (someone who's since gone on to totally shape the way I enjoy music) it just sounded like a bunch of noise and it took a long while for my ears to come around to it.

I don't see any harm in investing a little time in learning about a tradition if it helps you understand and in the long run, enjoy the sounds you're hearing...

Thing is, right...

I know sort of what you mean, but the trouble with it is that improvisation in the form of 'a handful of solos per song' is a virtually intrinsic element of jazz as a music.

I think a lot of the issues arise from this being 'hip hop elements in a jazz setting' as opposed to the reverse: what a lot of people percieve to be 'jazzy' (complex chords, unusually phrased lines, small elements of improvisation) often comes from interludes or features of music from other traditions which have adopted characteristics from the jazz tradition. Soweto is closer the reverse of this in a live setting.

See also: massive introverted stream of conciousness nonsense I wrote below... ;)

wow, that WAS a long one

and yeah, i agree with both posts.. i can only report on how i found the gig though, and if the live show is different to the record - which it is - then i'm going to write about what i thought of the difference.

that i'm not a fan of jazz as a stand-alone genre is just unfortunate, because it means i couldnt really enjoy it as much as most others there did, but it's easier to be honest and say what i actually thought.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon