Sign In:

Outside the Scala is teeming. The touts are having a field day with the assembled scenesters queuing around the block, or shouting and doing deals in the scrum for tickets. I can see Independent critic Simon Price's trademark vertical cybergoth hair spiking up amidst the throng, and I bump into a pair of Plan B journalists in the lobby - the music press are here in force. In fact, every other person seem to be a tall model type, a critic, or a Euro-chic fashionista - it's one of those events that turns into a crucible of assorted London glitterati. Getting the opportunity to go to one-off events like this instead of half-full Midlands gigs is one the reason I moved to London in the first place.

In the hall, pre-show bass rumbles up through the ground, and the anticipation is palpable. A transparent sheet of material is stretched across the front of the stage, and lights flash from behind it. After what seems like forever, twin silhouettes slip out onto the stage, and the room roars as beats start to snare-click and handclap from the speakers. Light plays across the balaclava masked faces of The Knife - a green glow from their keyboards illuminates their moving mouths as they start to sing, and a pink aura hangs from above, casting deep pits of shadow into their eye sockets, accentuated by skull-like overlays that extend the cheekbones and brow. The bass is heavy and slow, and the vocal sounds at once distant and like it is being whispered into my ear, layered but live, treated with effects, but real and immediate. The songs are claustrophobic, but expansive, becoming more vibrant and convincing through live performance. There are backing tracks, but also live marimba and live triggered synth drums, and while it's for the most part not particularly danceable, it's hypnotic nonetheless. When Heartbeats arrives, it's a different version - bass heavy, distorted, bent out of shape, but not at all disappointing. The Knife hold the audience's attention not with traditional quiet/loud verse/chorus song structures, but with a tense tightrope act of serious pop and dark electronica.

Throughout the performance, patterns flicker across the screen between The Knife and the audience. Shapes form and dissipate, sometimes like a matrix of lines gradually appearing, sometimes like light tears running down in front of the band like rain on a window; at one point stage curtains are projected onto the screen, and it's like we are glimpsing some kind of gothic Victorian/futurist ensemble; later we see still portraits with shining eyes, staring upwards. Dotted around the stage are sculptural projected faces that sing along to the songs, reminding me of the work of artist Tony Oursler - the faces later melt away into skulls, and the stage is swathed in midnight blue. This is an entire audio-visual spectacle rather than a straight music recital. It feels like a gig that couldn't have happened in any other period; it feels like a gig made out of right now.

There's always an issue in how to present electronica in the live arena, especially the kind that exists outside the club scene where people will dance under the flashing lights whatever happens. The Knife tonight set the bar higher than it has ever been before in terms of imagination, imagery and technical innovation - their dark music has found a hugely effective visual counterpart that moves The Knife onto another level altogether.

  • The Knife 10 / 10

Yaye

for the Knife!

It sounds...

fascinating. But ultimately I think I would have been disappointed musically.

The show sounds great but for me, you're there to hear the music. And from John's descrption it sounds like a dull, bass heavy thud-a-long effort and although the visuals would have kept you entertained, it could be argued it could get tiresome and boring. I wasn't there though, so maybe I'm wrong.

I would have wanted to go to dance my ass off to those wonderful tracks on Deep Cuts. Not watch a visual art show.

As you say

You weren't there.

Did you want to go there...

...to dance? Or to see a visual art show?

Honestly, did what you want meet with what you got?

It was their first UK gig, so

I went to see The Knife with no expectations of what they might be like. Dancing is not a pre-requisite of fun with me, so if it's not dancable, I don't care as long as it's good. I try not to review bands based on what I want them to be, but rather on what they are. And it is very hard to fault what The Knife did on that basis.

I think it was the best thing ive seens so far this year.

"Forest Families" sounded totally unbeleivable in the scala soundsystem. It was giving me shudders.

also, i've got a recording of that version of heartbeats

I far prefer it to the original, I think it's much more pretty at atmospheric.

Email it to me and I will give you a prize.

(Nature of prize to be announced at a later date).

it wasnt their first

was it? they did a one off somewhere else a while back, no?

yeah

i swear they played the ica a while back... was that cancelled?

.

they played the ICA last February

I wrote a review of it here

http://www.itsatrap.com/index.php?article=66

Tack!

d

PS. now that they wanna do the live thing, they have compromised everything that they ever stood for. They is fucked.....

I struggle to give a fuck whether it was their first or not to be honest

That's what I was told. I get really sick of these tedious fact picking wrangles at the bottom of my reviews sometimes. I can see why Plan B turned them off...

,

hey, i just thought some people would be interested in reading that. Anyway, to be honest with you we're all a bunch of nerdy anally retentive music fans. None of us are ashamed of that, surely?!

.

oh.. and the fact that Knife have always refused to play live up until recently makes their first show a big big deal. So yeah, I don't think anyone was nitpicking mate.

it was a big deal

a very big deal, not only did they have the most amazing visuals that you didn't know where to look as so much was going on, they took time out to deliver differenr versions of old classics, and weren't afraid to change the pace from blistering techno to sweet sad chamber music, this was one of the best shows iii have been to in going to see gigs in 20 years, also they get extra points because the fashionista stood next to us at one point actually rang a friend and told him "it's like being at a real art instillation" what a twat! They should headline this years supersonic festival thay are so the perfect band for capsules event.

Yeah.

I agree about it being one of the best gigs I've been to.

i was there

and it was pretty good, it wasnt dull at all, whoever said that. due to its rare nature though, there were a lot of people there just to be seen there and paid no interest in the music at all. plus it wasn't exactly a long set..

Do you think so?

I was there and most folks seemed to have come for the music to me. Reveiw was spot on in my opinion.

maybe it was

just the people standing around me. maybe i attract morons. i think it was because a lot of them were there with the photographers and i was right by the rail.

to their credit they shut up when i asked them to. thats not happened before.

I've just discovered

that it IS Karin from the knife singing on royksopp's 'what else is there'. And I feel really, really DUMB :-\. I love that woman's voice. Album cover of the understanding really should've given it away...!

wicked

wicked

google search for

'tony oursler primal scream' and i end up here. on a related note, the cover of their new album (beautiful future) looks like it's a tony oursler piece. still don't know if it is though.

Add your comment

Reply


 or Abandon