- Artists:
- Belle And Sebastian »
An incredibly tense Stuart Murdoch shuffles onto the stage with his accompanying Belle and Sebastian family and greets the audience like his first school assembly. "Hello... We're gonna play some stuff first... then the album... then we'll see what happens." His nervously meek demeanor, even before the night has begun, is an indication of how important tonight is - not just for the band - but for the hard-core, no, soft-core indie mafia seated in the audience.
The coy figure of Murdoch takes to the piano and plays the opening chord to 'Slow Graffiti'. Then promptly forgets the first line. It's a fitting start to the evening, with the trademark B&S live mistakes making their shows ever-more endearing. Yet more apologies from Murdoch who giggles to himself, then moves on. Stevie Jackson's mod-boy get-up and accompanying ridiculous dancing get the indie kids shaking through an unexpected, but overwhelmingly appreciated synth-laden rendition of Tigermilk's 'Electronic Renaissance'. The modest start to the evening suddenly seems forgotten as the true focus for the night begins.
The release of If You're Feeling Sinister in 1996 introduced to those not caught up in the Britpop battle of the time to something far more special. 'The Stars of Track and Field' builds with more confidence and power than ever and you can't help but feel that Belle and Sebastian have grown up, matured and evolved. The addition of a complete string section adds a richness and new life to the album, staying true to the original, but glorifying what is often an overlooked album in the grand scheme of the Belle and Sebastian story.
The lyrics to 'Seeing Other People' seem to ring through louder than ever tonight, "You take a lover for a dirty weekend, that's ok"; words now proudly shouted, rather than shyly suggested on the album. But B&S fans don't have sex, I thought they just held hands and cuddled? The Laurel and Hardy-esque banter between Murdoch and Jackson highlights how far they've progressed and Murdoch seems a little overwhelmed by it all, reminiscing of times past, and even his ex-girlfriend and band mate Isabelle, gets a nod tonight. "I do miss her," proclaims Murdoch, before launching into 'Get Away From Here, I’m Dying'. There's a clear sense of unity between the band tonight and by the close of the album, Stuart invites the kids that were dancing at the back to join them on stage, before confessing "I'm glad that's over" at the end of 'Judy and the Dream of Horses'.
The standing ovation that follows, stays upright throughout the five-song encore. 'Dog on Wheels' initiates the side-stepping, followed by screams of elation for the opening keyboard glory of 'The Boy With The Arab Strap'. By the monologue at the end, even the uber-chic no-sweat fashion students are dancing in the aisles. 'If You Find Yourself Caught In Love' closes the evening, leaving all and sundry with that warm feeling of a lovely afternoon tea with an amazing slice of carrot cake. All that is left to be said is that this needs to happen again.
Set list:
_'Slow Graffiti'
'Another Sunny Day'
'Woman's Realm'
'The Loneliness Of The Middle Distance Runner'
'Electronic Renaissance'
'The Stars Of Track And Field'
'Seeing Other People'
'Me And The Major'
'Like Dylan In The Movies'
'The Fox In The Snow'
'Get Me Away From Here, I'm Dying'
'If You're Feeling Sinister'
'Mayfly'
'The Boy Done Wrong Again'
'Judy And The Dream Of Horses'
Encore:
'Dog On Wheels'
'The Boy With The Arab Strap'
'The Wrong Girl'
'I'm A Cuckoo'
'If You Find Yourself Caught In Love'_
- God Help The Girl - Extended Review & Analysis
- Stuart Murdoch: Likes Murray, but won't meet Morrissey in probably "not that nice" shocker
- ATP film to get UK premiere at Edinburgh Festival
- News Drowned-Up: Animal Collective, Stevie Nicks, Billy Corgan, Courtney Love, Sigur Ros + more!
- Belle And Sebastian - The BBC Sessions
- Beggars are choosers; snaps up Rough Trade records
- Summercase 2007: the DiS review
- VOTE! For DiS's album of the year! WIN! A massive pile of CDs from Our 66!
From the archive
-
ReDiScover: Inspiral Carpets
-
In Photos: In The City 2008 (Saturday/Sunday)
-
SXSW: When A&R people go on holiday?
Belle And Sebastian
Re: Belle And Sebastian
for the above person, its been advertised for about three months i'm sure, maybe even longer.
i'd considered a plane-y trip to london for the event, but funds let me down
Re: Belle And Sebastian
Re: Belle And Sebastian
Belle And Sebastian
Belle And Sebastian
Re: Belle And Sebastian
And given these tickets were very much in-demand and it was an exclusive show, I'd have thought a B & S-loving reviewed such as T. Judge would have asked to have them, or maybe even bought them himself. I for one would have been well-pissed off if DiS gave tickets for something exclusive like this to someone who wouldn't appreciate it.
Plus surely a one-off show like this is really intended for fans. If you were a big B & S fan (which I imagine you're not) and saw an exclusive one-off show where they played one of their best albums in full, a selection of other songs and something from their new album, it probably would rank as one of your favourite gigs.
On top of which B & S are a surprisingly strong live band, particularly in recent years so I can see it being that good.
In a sense I think I'm agreeing with you, in so far as it is pointless to do balanced reviews because all reviews are opinions.
But surely you're basically saying that nothing should ever get a 5-star review because anyone who gives it one is not representing the opinions of people wouldn't give it 5 stars. I might well have given a B & S 5 stars myself if I was a reviewer.
Does that make my opinion invalid?
Re: Belle And Sebastian
i mean, it lacked the vision and radicalism of a truly great opinion, but was well expressed and quite similar to my own tastes of opinon on this particular subject.
Belle And Sebastian
it's bizarre but beautiful.
Re: Belle And Sebastian
I was worried it was only a 3 and a half star opinion, which have been ok but a touch on the mediocre side.
I'm deeply proud to have a 4 star opinion.
I think I'd also give you 4 stars for your opinion of my opinion.
Re: Belle And Sebastian
to be honest, it was more of a comment on people whinging about negative reviews than anything else. i ended up ranting on this review because, as you correctly surmise, i fucking hate belle and sebastien and find it very difficult to believe that anyone could ever rate them that highly.
but your opinion's not invalid - just WRONG
Something & Nothing
Good point somwehere in there. I saw B&S live in 2000 and they were mediocre at best. I avoided them for a few years whilst they released a few pretty weak LPs.
However, I was bought Catastrophe Waitress and I thought, hold on, this is on the money, this. So this year, I went to see them again and they were magic. The great thing is that they can play almost anything from their back catalogue on demand.
I was lucky that they played "Your Cover's Blown", which I would recommend to any B&S haters out there.
I'm very conscious that this is off the point and gratuitously dull. Indeed, I'd rank this post as a weak 1.5 stars. Well, it'll save you facetious feckers the bother, innit.

Belle And Sebastian
In Photos: Mew @ The Academy, Manchester
In Photos: Kap Bambino @ The Old Blue Last, London
In Photos: DiS presents BLK JKS @ The Harley, Sheffield
In Photos: Royksopp @ Shepherds Bush Empire, London
Comments
- Post a new comment on this article