Drowned in Sound

Search


Home > Reviews > Live


Animal Collective Geologist
Date: 01/11/2007
4 votes
?
by Samuel Strang

And so, the circus rolls back into town.

Animal Collective performances have always been frustrating, often beguilingly so, but of late it’s veered towards notoriously awkward. Though the act have always distanced the analogies that are constantly drawn between them and childhood, the Brooklyn collective’s most recent London performance – at the Coronet in July – saw them making like children, as they rushed like petulant jackanapes to hold up a painting to mother while the paint slid off the page, as tendencies to hastily showcase their latest material reared up as the anticipated airing of Strawberry Jam was swept aside.

For all the arms aloft in disarray as Strawberry Jam saw the act turn their backs on the minimalist noise-folk that marked out their initial recordings, it remains under different guises. Dainty opener ‘Dancer’, with Avery Tare lulling nonsensically, for all its chiming electronics shares many parallels with the act’s early incarnation, only shifted onto a different plateau. Rapturously received perhaps, but earlier material, including ever-manic renditions of ‘Who Could Win A Rabbit’ and ‘Banshee Beat’, seem increasingly eclipsed by pastures new.

Again with Deakin absent, the act pick at Sung Tongs and Feels in equal measures, as well as the newly realised tracks, including the deranged hullabaloo of ‘Walk Around With You’. But it is …Jam material that receives the utmost attention. As heads shake with loose-necked vigour to a hectic rendition of ‘Chores’, ‘Derek’ parps with uneasy delirium and ‘Peacebone’ befittingly calls out that “a blow out does not mean I’ll have a good night” as the elbows jar to find space in the downsized venue. But it is ‘Fireworks’ that splinters off most vividly. As stuttering tape loops lap compulsively, the track opens and is held, teetering to and fro, mutating into ‘Essplode’ and back before exploding into life. Elsewhere, Panda Bear’s ‘Song For Ariel’ is fittingly incorporated as it sifts into new track ‘Bear Hug’ and underlines the way this act work: comfortable around each others’ separate ventures, free of pretension.

With such a focus on retaining a momentum throughout, with such subtleties in the transition between tracks carrying the set and drawing away from the erroneous notions of any improvisation, an encore seems unnecessary. Moments later this is not the case as the plaintive ‘No More Running’ and demented jabbering of ‘Leaf House’ leaping around compulsively as gurning jaws are left agape.

The circus is never quite as good as you expect it to be, returning home clutching a bag containing a comatose goldfish and a novelty key ring. This feeling of disappointment has often been left when Animal Collective came to town, but, this evening, the circus came good.

Post a new comment on this review

it...

really was an amazing gig.


they did not play anything off feels

and they didn't play banshee beat.

other than that, this is fairly accurate and good review.

it was a special night


CORRECT.

...'pologie'...


supports?

seeing them tomorrow (Leeds) and cant seem to find it anywhere.


animal collective support

Support at Manchester was Islaja from Finland. Imagine it will be the same in Leeds.


avey tare flu

i went to see them last night and they only played one 3 songs off their albums. avey tare then left the stage without saying anything and geologist had to make excuses for him animal collective set finished early but panda bear played from person pitch "good girl" from his album then something else i hadnt heard of.deacon wasnt there either.but having said that it was a good gig, but didnt get to hear any songs i was familar with, i would be a big fan and i have their last 3 albums i was slightly disapointed but i am sure i will see their full set in a festival sometime


2 out of 3 ain't bad

Avey Tare was still ill last night in Leeds. Panda Bear and Geologist did a set of Panda Bear tracks, of which I knew none, and Animal Collective songs of which I knew one. Having never seen them before, I didn't really know what to expect, but I've just checked Youtube and seen the three of them at a French festival, so I know that what we got in Leeds wasn't bad, but I do so wish they were all fit and well..!





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Our ATP: DiS does Weekend Two, finds that not all men with a cape can fly...