This is clearly nonsense. Best named Cribs album, sure, but not the best album. They've rated every Cribs album an 8 except for ITBOTBB, which it gave a 9. Probably because its definitely better than Ignore The Ignorant, which was well overrated, presumably because Johnny Marr.
For the record, the order is as follows:
Men's Needs, Women's Needs, Whatever > The New Fellas > The Cribs > ITBOTBB > Ignore The Ignorant. Cheers. Also, what about them releasing a best of? Bit weird yeah?