Your are viewing a read-only archive of the old DiS boards. Please hit the Community button above to engage with the DiS !
which I don't entirely like to say because (I don't think) she's doing all this for cynical bandwagonny-jumping reasons
couldn't watch more than 10 seconds
The trendy costumes, reverby drums, edge/KoL guitar... and its charlotte church. Just made me cringe a bit. Listening on further into the song it does get better, but I can't bring myself to listen to the indie incarnation of Charlotte church.
i can imagine the album being like bat for lashes
it is a bit jarring that it is charlotte church but her voice sounds a lot more at home doing this than doing that dance-pop stuff she had a go at once before
will never be able to not sing like that, yeah
It seems that the end result is about the combination of attitude and physical ability. So somebody with classical training should still be able to pull off a solid punk tune, if the mindset is there. In fact, how much would you love a band where the singer doesn't show off that power until certain moments where the lyrics need it?
However, this would be a really tough spot to land in. I agree that most folks with amazing technical vocal ability would have trouble keeping a lid on it.
she probably doesn't know how not to sing like it
that vibrato and everything she does
but it's the songwriting that would determine how well her voice could fit into any genre besides, well, opera. And I'm not sold on the songwriting in that piece.
I'm thinking of Adele when I say that culturally we still have a taste for sweeping, powerful female voices, but she's found a comfortable genre to play around in and Charlotte Church doesn't seem to have landed there. I guess we'll see what happens.
I actually like this "new direction", best of luck to her.
The indie rock Mariah Carey. Stop warbling and sing the bloody song!
just listen to BSS or whatever, idk.
fucking love Jeff's hystrionics.
I do hear a rubbish bit of music with awful lyrics and a lot of faux-pseudo-quasi-etc ''indie'' bs going on though.
i.e. the contents of a shoebox under any DiSser's bed
So, Bat For Lashes
I quite like this FWIW.
Much as I love his early solo records, there are times when his voice is a bit too schmoooove for the material - stuff like The Plague or The Seventh Seal for example.
the old maaaan's back agaai-aaaa-eeeyen...
dwee dubuhduh un dwee dubuduh
Hearing him sing 'her sailors stained her cobblestones/with wine and piss and death desire' in that sumptuous voice. Gets me every time.
she'll never be able to "The Shaggs" it up or anything. Maybe if she drank - a LOT - for awhile, she could be like some weathered jazz singer or something. Or maybe a boozer-styled classical singer. THAT could be cool.
she sounds a bit like the lady from The Cranberries.
Apparently it's *glitter in my wounds* not *womb*, but *womb* is much better!
by someone who doesn't really believe in what they're doing.
and if the x files has taught me anything, that's what counts