Is Buddy Holly worth listening to?
I'm not get into a debate about his massive influence or anything but any of the songs of his I have heard sound very dated and lightweight. And they have very little to distinguish between. Having said that I don't really know his stuff well enough to pass much judgement.
Someone help me out.
From the archive
-
Guy Garvey's track-by-track guide to Asleep in the Back (Deluxe Edition)
-
DiS meets Sian Alice Group
-
DiScover: Land of Talk
Thread not appearing correctly? Click here to rebuild | Report this


'Everyday'
is one of the greatest pop songs ever recorded.
Fact.
i'm going to listen to it immediately then
oh crap, it's probably amazing
but Two and A Half Men lifted the melody wholesale for one of the jingles Charlie writes for a kids tv show. So now all I hear is 'Oh Oh oh oh Oh Shikuru!'.
Ruined for me :(
His little voice hiccups kind of irritate me to be honest as well.
it also appears (almost exactly) to be Don't Let Him Waste Your Time by Jarvis Cocker
See, I think this is my problem. He wrote all these brilliant, deceptively melodies before everyone else but in the last 50 years his back catalogue has been ransacked wholesale, so much so that you can't listen to him with fresh ears anymore.
*deceptively simple
If only Heartbeat
had'nt used his song for their theme tune then maybe I'd like that song too...
shame.
He's an interesting character who sadly left way too early
so he and we never had the benefit of G R O W T H. Most of his recordings are a little sparse cause he was in his infancy. Rock and roll was in it's infancy as well.
Holly was such a dork though. It's hard to imagine him being anything else with the benefit of more time. I think he would have become a huge songwriter like Burt Bacharach or Neil Diamond and kept morre in the background. Can't really see him with a big stack of Marshalls and a kick ass band.
Check out the simplicity of Crickets' set up- they sound the same here as they did playing down at the bowling alley in Lubbock.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WQiIMuOKIzY
i like him, his melodies have a haunted, strange quality about them
but it is ridiculously simple.
those drums in that video are fantastic though.
Having said that he must have been younger than me in that clip
and I still don't have a 'Peggy Sue' to show for my existence so maybe I should just shut up.
no doubt bought at Sears and Roebuck in downtown Lubbock
i've just stuck on some stuff like Oh Boy!
God has his work been kidnapped by advertising men since his death. Every one of his songs remind me of some tv ad for chips, or cleaning products or whatever.
Oh Boy! is the 'Nutgrove Shopping Centre' jingle over here. As I listen to the Crickets my brain keeps reminding me of opening hours and that there's 'room to park'.
yes
These were the songs of my childhood. They were dug out last christmas for singalongs with sister and we still know the words. Good fun.
utterly essential.
True love ways will still be a heartbreaker in 50 years time.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5x9PPtPmoy4
oh, this is another one of my favourites..
this is simple, brilliant pop.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ciCESPAUvo
this is a great article on his "last days"
http://www.rollingstone.com/artists/buddyholly/articles/story/25584431/the_last_days_of_buddy_holly
This too from Don McClean. He wrote this song about when he found out about Holly's death. He was 12 yrs. old, had a paper route (paper boy) in New York and when he cut the string on the bundle of newspapers he saw the article about the plane crash on the front page- pretty cool song.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uAsV5-Hv-7U
American Pie
Fantastic song. Coupled with Buddy Holly by Weezer and I think I prefer the songs Holly inspired to his own actual music. True Love Ways is gorgeous though.
I like to think that story about him walking in on little richard
banging his (little richard's) girlfriend, then without saying a word, dropping his trousers and joining in is true.
That is all.
did Buddy give him his 'Little' nickname afterwards?
Well, apparently,
despite the nerdy look and stammering vocals, Buddy Holly was known for having one of the biggest little fellas in the rock'n'roll gang.
I'd be surprised if the Little Richard story were true
If only because I'm pretty sure Little Richard didn't swing that way. 'Tutti Frutti''s original lyrics were, 'Tutti frutti/good booty', and I believe a bunch of his early songs originally had lyrics that, er, wouldn't be out of place on a Hidden Cameras album. I recall reading somewhere that in the 1950s he was playing straight and gay venues, and then toned down the camp side as he got closer to pop stardom.
But then again you never know...
not really.
Once you've heard 'Oh Boy' you've heard them all.
Rock n Roll is great dance music but it's very similar. The best of them all is Chuck Berry, though. I find it funny that Elvis is given any sort of superlative descriptions regarding his 50s output. That said, post-revival stuff is about 100 times worse.
most definitely
Whilst his songs aren't massively varied (he pretty much just uses 3 chords in different orders), they do what they do brilliantly well. Just awesome melodies over perfectly arranged simple songs.
If you're looking at this sort of thing it's also worth checking out Roy Orbison. He might not be as cool or as good lucking as Elvis et al, but his voice is amazing and his songs are all just that little bit slower than all the other rock and roll stuff and are really beautiful/tragic as a result.
yeah, I worship Orbison
Oh Boy is probably my fave...
although they're all pretty vital listening, if only a few times over (as said up there, there's not a great deal of variety there). Lots of nostlagia vaue for me, being 'eduacted' by my dad on the way to our hols about how great buddy holly was. Great times. Well Alright, Wishing, and Peggy Sue got married are other faves...
Learning The Game
is a simple, but sweet song.
Definitely deserves props for being one of the first 'rock bands' as we know it today, and for being one of the first artists to write, produce, and play his own stuff.
Remember that he only really started recording in early 56, and died in Feb 59. 3 albums in 2 years, but enough extra stuff for new albums for the next ten years. Eat your heart out Biggie & 2-Pac.
yeah, it's definitely weezer's best song