Boards
John Peel and Thom Yorke.
So Merlin has them both, in his castle, in the sky. They're both alive, Peel has been revived.
BUT: he says 'Only one can live. The other must be fed to a pack of hungry beasts.
Who do you choose?
Also, if you say 'neither', not only do they both get set on fire, they chase after you and kill you, slowly, with their fingers!