Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)

Q: What is your favourite performance by an actor in a film?

Doesn't necessarily mean the most Oscar worthy, just the one you most enjoy watching for whatever reason

Mine: Daniel Day-Lewis in Gangs of New York - lovely stuff - closely followed by Malcolm McDowell in A Clockwork Orange. <3 both those intelligent, charismatic sociopaths. And a third place podium finish for - and unless you've see the movie, this is going to sound embarrassing - Val Kilmer as Doc Holliday in Tombstone. Everything else he's done is stunningly poor, but he's schmick in that.



  • Edward Norton or Benicio Del Toro in most things.

    • Oh yeah

      Ed Norton in American History is superb

      • erm,

        *X

        • and then he had to go and do

          Keeping the Faith.

          • Keeping the Faith is awesome

            Stfu.

            • just when i was getting past

              your homophobia...

      • just a shame that the film itself is total dogshit

        • American History X is awesome

          Stfu.

  • Toshiro Mifune in Seven Samurai

  • Val Kilmer in tombstone:

    Fucking amazing.
    Tombstone - Fucking amazing!

  • Brad Pitt in Fight Club

    OR
    Daniel Day Lewis in There Will BE bLOOD.

  • Can't choose

    between Pesci, Liotta and De Niro in Goodfellas.

  • A few:

    Ed Norton - Primal Fear
    Nicholson - One flew over the cuckoos nest (obvious but brilliant)
    Johnny Depp - Ed Wood
    George Clooney - O Brother where art thou
    David Stratairn - Good night, and good luck
    Vincent Cassel - La Haine

    in fact there are loads and I cannot pick one.

  • Christian Bale in American Psycho

    Terrifying, intelligent, hilarious. He looks great too.

  • Bill Paxton in Aliens/Predator 2.

    Joe Pesci and Marisa Tomei in My Cousin Vinny.

  • De Niro in Taxi Driver

    • De Niro in anything pre 1980

      Deerhunter is his performance

      • *best performance

        I'm so shite today

  • I've got a few

    Al Pacino in Godfather II
    Liam Neeson & Ben Kingsley in Schindler's List
    Robert de Niro in Raging Bull or Taxi Driver
    Even Johnny Depp in Pirates of the Carribean.

    oh

    and Gene Wilder as Willy Wonka.

    • Will second Neeson here ^

      • Surely Ralph Fiennes

        blows everyone else out of the water in that film?

        • He is fucking terrifying in that film

          • He is

            but I would argue it is harder to play Schindler well in that film. I think it is slightly easier to play (and get the plaudits for) a violent psychopath.

          • True

            very true. I will include him as well.

    • Gene Wilder in Willy Wonka is brilliant!!

  • Marlon Brando in streetcar named desire

    just cos he's sexy

    mike myers in austin powers because he has hilarious facial features

    and samuel L jackson in pulp fiction because every line he delivers in the most cool way you could potentially deliver that line. It's a joy.

  • Al Pacino in The Devils Advocate

    Brad Pitt in 12 Monkeys
    Kevin Spacey in Usual Suspects
    Charlize Theron in Monster

    • Good call on Monster

      She's terrifyingly good in that.

  • Travolta/Cage in Face Off

    Superb stuff

  • Bruno Ganz as Hitler in Downfall

    To bring such a charicatured historical figure to life with such realism without once straying into cartoony archetypes is incredible - for most of that film, honest to God you think you are actually watching Hitler. It's jaw dropping

    • ^^^^Good shout LordLucius

      Fucking immense performance, I found myself feeling sorry for him at parts which is total credit to Ganzs performance.

      • ^^ can only

        echo what's been said in both posts. An epic performance.

  • Okays

    Mark Wahlberg - The Departed
    Christian Bale - The Prestige
    Vinícius de Oliveira - Central Station (aww!)
    Salvatore Cascio - Cinema Paradiso (aww!)

    • And

      Cary Grant / Gary Cooper / Gregory Peck in anything.

    • Mark Wahlberg is great in The Departed

      "I'm the guy doing his job. You must be the other guy."

      I'd go for Audrey Tatou in Amelie. Or Vince Vaughn in Swingers. Or Jimmy Stewart in Rear Window.

    • Wahlberg - fucking worst actor ever!

      • But he really isn't

        in fact he is becoming a fairly capable actor.

      • You clearly haven't seen The Happening.

        Comic genius, he could give Judd Apatow a run for his money.

      • lets not start

        this again

  • .

    The one that really jumps out at me is Ben Kingsley in Sexy Beast. Awesome.

    As well as the obvious ones....

    • ^^^Kingsley is fucking brilliant in sexy beast.

      Terrifying performance.

    • he's just a sweary ghandi

      • and that's a bad thing?

    • Good call.

  • Roberto Benigni - Life is beautiful!

    • The film is a fairy story

      but his performance is utterly breathless. And breathtaking.

      • I agree ht27, a tad corny in parts...

        but anyone who doesn't have a huge grin on their faces because of Benigni performance must be a cold son of a bitch.

        • Absolutely

          he's brilliant.

  • Klaus Kinski in Aguirre:wrath of God

    or anything really.

    • Philip Seymour Hoffman

      in most things he's appeared in, to be honest: Capote, Happiness, The Savages, Before The Devil Knows You're Dead

      • he is the hero of all that is good in the world

        he just makes films good

        • totally agree....

          watched Charlie wilsons war for the first time last night and every scene he is in he steals.
          That films big letdown is that Hoffman is not in every scene.

      • Oh and I loved Philip Seymore Hoffman in Almost Famous

        which also adds Kate Hudson to my list - I loved her as Penny Lane

    • ^ what I was going to say

      (Kinski in Aguirre, in case this post gets lost somewhere)

      I would actually have said Daniel Day-Lewis in Gangs of New York if somebody had asked me my least favourite performance in a film ever.

  • ^5 to the Malcolm McDowell choice

    Paddy Considine in 'Dead Mans Shoes'' is nearly impeccable and Dennis Hopper in 'Blue Velvet'' eminates a most pungent evil. Completely engrossing.

  • tom waits

    in short cuts.

  • Jim Carrey in Eternal Sunshine Of The Spotless Mind

    • nick cage

      in leaving las vegas and raising arizona and adaptation.

      • i really hated nic cage

        before adaptation.

        still hanging out to see the wicker man!

        • You've got to see Wicker Man,

          it's truly jaw dropping.

          • i'm heading to the lovefilm list now...

        • How'd it get BURNT?!

          .

      • The thing about

        Cage in Leaving las vegas is:

        Once you've seen him be that good it's just annoying how lazy and half arsed he is in everything else.

    • ^ Yes

  • Val Kilmer

    is very underrated

  • daniel day lewis in gangs of new york yes!!!

    hes amazing.christian bale in american psycho.heath ledger as the joker (i know its not out yet but come on it looks ridiculously good)

  • John Cameron Mitchell in Hedwig and the Angry Inch

  • jason schwartzman in rushmore.

    • THE HIGHEST FIVE IN THE WORLD TO YOU

      • ^5

        i love that performance so much, that i think i love him.

        • I want to be Max Fischer so much

          I've started to look a bit like him

          • same.

            glasses: check
            moles: check
            side parting of hair: check

            • i just need to work on my eyebrows,

              but they're so light and the hairs are so fine. it's not gonna work :(

              • Oh I got the whole look down

                I just need to find the perfect blue blazer and that's me.

                • I FOUND ONE!

                  i actually bought one in a charity shop, because when i tried it on i felt like mac fischer. i really need some 'attendance' and 'punctuality' badges though

            • :D

              Also handy is that I do look 15!

              I like to quote him too. Like:

              Someone: "I did blah, blah, blah"
              Me: "That's great. I wrote a hit play and directed it, so I'm not sweating it either."

              • SO DO I!

                also, i think i'm spending too much time writing and stuff, i should probably be trying harder to score guys, cause that's all anyone cares about. also, I SAVED LATIN.

                • I actually prefer

                  Bill Murray's performance in Rushmore. Jason Schwartzman is a legend though. I really liked him in I <3 Huckabees.

                  • i really liked his performance,

                    but just not as much.

                    i really liked i <3 huckabees too, i know it's dismissed a lot as 'pretentious', but i thought it had an interesting concept, great casting, and it was funny as well.

        • i saw him in real life

          at a film awards thing in sydney, and he is totally worth falling in love with. unfortunately he would be too short for me.

          so freaking jealous that a guy i know got to interview him for total film:

          http://www.totalfilm.com/features/jason_schwartzman_steps_off_the_darjeeling_limited

          /end gush

    • yus!

      "I like your nurses uniform"

      "these are OR scrubs"

      "O, R they?"

      (bill murray chokes on ice)

  • Macaulay Culkin

    Home Alone

    • An inspired choice

  • Helena Bonham Carter as Marla

    In fight club.

    Tom Courtney in A day in the life of ivan desnovich

    Michael caine in Alfie

  • i'm gonna watch gangs of new york now.

    • good choice

      there was a thread earlier tailor made for you (and some others) (i made it)

      • link plz.

        i was probably sleeping. i'm pondering if i should take tomorrow off too.

        • FOOD IS THE SUBJECT :D

          • replied!

            i want to be home :(

            • reply again!

              awww you wil be home soon enough wont you :)

              • 6 weeks yesterday.

                i cannot wait! i have to do loads of overtime before then though, like 27 hours or something. booo. my mum is coming to take some stuff in 4 weeks, yay!
                that german footballer guy had his wedding reception just outside of munich recently. my friend said there were loads of paparazzi. how interesting.

  • Ben Wishaw in Criminal Justice

  • Marlon Brando

    in Streetcar Named Desire

    They don't make em like that anymore

  • ...

    Ulrich Thomsen - Festen. Incredibly emotive and pure performance, and its quite a demanding role considering the the movies use of flashes of humour to punctuate and give relief from the more emotionally weighty moments. The dinner party speech scene is intense. You never know which way he is going to go with it.

    John Turturro - Barton Fink. Boring, but then Id say John Turturro in **almost** anything.

  • Jack Nicholson

    in One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest

  • A lot of the obviuos ones

    have already been said:

    Andy Garcia and Christopher Lloyd in things to do in denver when you're dead.

    William H Macy in the Cooler

    Dennis Hopper and Christopher Walken (for just 1 scene) in true romance.

  • Adrien Brody in The Pianist

    Tom Hanks in Cast Away / anything
    Robert De Niro in Awakenings

  • Harvey Keitel

    in most things he has ever done.

  • :D

    Richard E Grant - Withnail & I

  • PADDY CONSIDINE

    in dead mans shoes and room for romeo brass

    • Martin Sheen in Apocolypse Now

      or if only for his brief cameo Alec Baldwin in Gelngarry Glenn Ross which I think has best ensemble cast performance of any film ever

  • Takashi Shimura in Ikiru, maybe.

  • comedy-wise

    Jim Carrey in Ace Ventura, Dumb and Dumber, the Mask and the Cable Guy, and Mike Myers in Waynes World.

    • Wow

      great list there.

      • if that's sarcasm

        you truly suck.

        • No!

          I was being serious, i love all those films!

    • comedy wise for me

      would be :

      Bill Murray in Groundhog Day
      Steve Martin in The Jerk
      Seth Rogen in Knocked Up
      Jon Heder in Napoleon Dynamite
      Arnold Schwarzenegger in The Running Man

      • I would say for comedy

        then it would have to be The Marx Brothers in Duck Soup particularly Groucho

      • i was going to say

        bill murray in groundhog day as well, fantastic.

  • Matthieu Almaric in The Diving Bell and The Butterfly

    If you haven't seen it, I strongly suggest that you do.

  • Ed Norton in Fight Club.

    Jim Carrey in Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind.
    Everyone in Little Miss Sunshine.

    And I reckon soon I will be saying:
    Heath Ledger in The Dark Knight.
    yup yup.

    • a few come to mind

      Mark Wahlberg - The Departed
      Jason Lee - Chasing Amy
      Jeff Bridges - The Squid and The Whale
      Daniel Day-Lewis - In The Name of the Father
      Paddy Considine - Dead Mans Shoes
      Christian Bale - Empire of the Sun
      Tamer Hassan - Football Factory
      Danny Dyer - Football Factory
      Danny Dyer - The Business

      • danny dyer?

        seriously?

        like, honestly?

        • Danny Dyer

          is beyond criticism...

      • Daniel Day-Lewis'

        performance in 'In The Name of The Father' was brilliant.

  • Paul Giamatti in American Splendor

    is just perfect for the roll.

    • * role

      -bedtime-

  • no

  • I'm your huckleberry

    Kilmer slays in that film. He's not all bad. Kiss Kiss Bang Bang anyone?

  • Day Lewis in Gangs of New York was the first thing i thought of at this question

  • Gene Wilder in... well... all his good films

    Rhys Ifans in 'Not Only But Always'

    • Alan Rickman in

      'Robin Hood, Prince Of Thieves'.

      *yeahiknow*