Drowned in Sound

Search



sebadoh - III

7 votes
?
by walkingwithwolves

i'm listening to this for the first time right now. i'm really annoyed i didn't get it sooner.

so... thoughts?

(YEAH i put this on the wrong forum, GO ME)

walkingwithwolves | 06 Jul '08, 21:18 | Send note | Report this | Reply

Yes, Bakesale is better

or at least a lot more consistent. III is still a fantastic album, I even like quite a few of the Gafney tracks including that one guntrip thought was a joke track.


I keep meaning to get this.....

is it better than 'Bakesale'?


"better than bakesale" is a misnomer

because both albums are great in completely different ways.

I think III is personally my favourite of the two albums, just because clearly less effort has gone into it, and that is ultimately more impressive. Bakesale's tunes are great, but there is nothing as jaw droppingly amazing as Spoiled or Total Peace on Bakesale.


Yeah, Total Peace = best Sebadoh song?

Still Bakesale for me though, Lou on top form, no pointless Eric noiseouts and Jason coming into his own as a songwriter.


Sell all your Sebadoh records

buy some pot and make scratch brownies and have a real

BAKESALE!


yes!

bakesale, bubble and scrape, III and harmacy are all amazing





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Fuzzy Logic: Times New Viking turned up to eleven