Drowned in Sound

Search



Camus vs Sartre

16 votes
?
by Bundoz

The Outsider or Nausea?
I vote The Outsider.

Bundoz | 06 Jul '08, 12:15 | Send note | Report this | Reply

not read nausea.

is it good?


Well,

i read many many years ago, when i was an angry young man. Now that im an angry old man, im not quite sure what i'd make of it now. I remember it being hard work, but very worthwhile.


CAMUS

always.

always camus

but philosophers who write fiction can fuck off. allegories are for the most part shit.


This is wrong

and Zarathustra single-handedly proves it


2-0 Outsider

or The Stranger as my version is.


Scooby Doo can do do

but Jimmy Carter is smarter


I've only half read the outsider in french

Couldn't understand it that much as my french is terrible. Though in september i'm starting my degree in french+philosophy so I'm sure I will encounter them at some point. It's all very exciting.
I'll get back to you in a few years.


I did French and Philosophy!

The outsider is great.


i'm kind of reading nausea now

however i've got distracted by paul hegarty's masterful 'noise/music: a history.' which is amazing to say the least.


^

XD


Sarcasm:

The lowest form of wit?


Outsider over Nausea

but Age of Reason over Outsider. But The Fall over Age of Reason. So Camus wins.


I've only read Nausea

The Rebel = Nausea

I dunno, I mean Camus is hotter but Sartre has a hotter name. I'm trying to read Being and Nothingness and failing. Existentialism and Humanism is quite a snazzy speech though int it.

I dunno, I like them both.

I think my minor language will be French at UCL, even if it means having to spend my third year in Belgium.


I've never read any Satre

but I like the Camus I've read.


The Plague beats all Satre

as does L' Etranger. Actually Myth of Sisyphus beats Satre too. So Basically Camus FTW.

I have a Philosophy / Literature joint degree and thus on this topic MY WORD IS LAW.


i've only read

existentialism and humanism and the age of reason by sartre. i prefer camus.


Camus

for sure. He's more hopeful, varied, less wallowing and pretentious.


camus

because he was a goalkeeper. we're a special breed that must stick together.


Nausea is gash

The main character's essentially a pretty vile wasteman who is used by Sartre as a conduit to justify his own bourgeois lifestyle. The Autodidact for me is the hero, and then Sartre outs him as a paedophile at the end. Great.

The Outsider meanwhile is a masterpiece.


I felt a similar

affection for the Autodidact, Im quite glad that someone has said that.

Id go for the Outsider, but there are certain images in Nausea that will stay with me, despite it not being that amazing. However, its certainly better than The Plague.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Singles Round-up (16/06/08)