Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)

Favourite Why? song

Fall Saddles

the melody where he is sining "I listened to your taped epistle to Rachel" makes my spine go all tingly

I wish I could write songs like that.



  • waterfalls.

    • Yep, Waterfalls sounded great last night

      or Gemini

      • Gemini also

        but i think i've listened to it too much :S

  • Rubber Traits

    "cut my DNA with rubber traits
    Pull apart the double helix like wishbone"

    • Always be working on a suiciiiiiide note

      • Its the

        Animal Collective-y "ooh-ee-ooohs" in the background that make that song for me.

        Its so hard to pick just one but my top few at the moment would be These Few Presidents, Simeon's Dilemma and Gemini.

        Thanks to last night I have a newfound appreciation for A Sky For Shoeing Horses Under. Amazing playingggg

        • definitely :D

          the bit where he sings 'but i want, but i want, but OOOOH!' is so great :D

    • after we saw them at ATP

      me and my friend kept singing that line all weekend, love it.

    • Sounds

      a bit gay to me.

      • come to think of it we did often

        have our dicks in each others asses when it happened.

  • It seems to change

    all the time for me

    But at the moment my favourites are 'Fatalist Palmistry' and 'Sanddollars'

  • I've just remembered

    'Song of the sad assassin' and 'a sky for shoeing horses under'

    fuck i don't know. i love why?

  • At the moment it's

    Song of the Sad Assassin. It made tears come out of my eyes when they played it at Primavera, specifically the line

    "her face turned red, and she said to me. I'll suck the marrow out and break your hollow bones Yoni"

  • Afterschool America

  • Fatalist palmistry

    • ^ this

      Greatest opening lines ever.

      A catchy mother lover. No doubt.

  • no

    love for 'Good Friday'?

    for shame!

  • Dirty Glass

    probably

  • At the moment

    Crushed Bones - because the build up and strange beatdown style is awesome.

    The Hollows - Mainly for the "all my homies warned me OH NO! those gypsies probably got knives!" part.

    500 Fingernails - Just because its mint.

    Afterschool America - Because its the first song I heard and started my slight obsession.

    • ^

      these are probably my other favourites thinking about it. But still...

      GODDAMN IT YONI YOU NEVER DO ANYTHING RIGHT <3

  • good friday

    sending sexy sms's to my ex's new man, cause i can.

  • gemini

    ..and they played it both london gigs, too!

    or rubber traits, or 'we few presidents, or.. etc

    i love the 'do you still pray about me' bit in fall saddles, and it was the first why? song i heard.

  • the fall of mr fifths

  • Simeon's dilema

    It never seems to get mentioned yet the ratio of redundant pithy little lines to actual genuinly good lyricism and narrative is really low.

    "stalker's my whole style" is brilliant. As is the whole verse of
    "are you a female, young messiah?
    for stowaways and dugouts and
    are you what church folk mean by the good news pulling plastic bags off heads
    or are you giving me a dirty look in the rear-view
    flicking the button on your u-haul pen
    dont pretend you didnt see me coming round the bend
    on my fixy with a chopped horns turned in
    trailing behind you biodeisel bins"

    That's all gold. "I know a psychic who reads her own palms and the findings are personal" is NOT gold.

    • yes yes yes yes yes

      yes_. I mentioned it up tharr ^. The way the drums and music builds up on 'don't pretend you didn't see me coming round the bend' does things to my soul...

  • did 'Why?' do that song where he goes

    'even though I haven't seen you in years / yours is a funeral I'd fly to from anywhere'?

    I get that stuck in my head a lot even though I've probably only hear Alopecia once in my life.

    It is 'why?' isn't it? Which song is it, so I can get more aquainted.

    • Yuss

      'These Few Presidents' off Alopecia

    • it is, yes.

      All The Presidents Men.

      • ALLLLLLLL THHEEEEEEE

        PPPPPREEEEEEESSSSSSSSIDNETNS MENNNNENNNN

    • one of my favourite lines

      is it dark or romantic? i can't decide

    • I hate that line

      it's rubbish

      • Yeah I don't get the love for it either

        Especially amongst some of the other lines.

        • Yeah

          "Cheery A, Cheery E, Cheery I, Cheery O, Cheery U" makes me cringe too. I still love Why? though.
          He makes up for it with lines like "If you grew up with white boys who only read black and puertorican porno because they want something that their dad don't got, then you know where you're at". Brilliant.

  • i love why? so so much.

    probably gemini, with fall saddles a close second. and then these few presidents. and crushed bones. and simeon's dilemma. oh man, i dunno, i can't pick.

  • 500 FINGERNAILS RIGHT NOW

    but it was Waterfalls yesterday and will probably be Miss Ohio's Nameless by tonight. cheers.

  • Light Leaves

    or Yo Yo Bye Bye.

    'there's no mound of clouds to lounge on'

    <3

    • The Hollows

      The Hollows and Gemini for me.

  • WHISPERS INTO THE OTHER