Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)

If your Gf/Bf asked you to stop smoking

whether it be Cigarettes or Weed etc, would you?

My friend has apparently just had this happen, and she doesn't know what to say.



  • Depends how much she likes them

    /how much she likes smoking.

  • no

    I would instead start going out with someone who appreciated my smoking.

    • Are there people

      who appreciate smoking? Or do 99 percent of people just put up with it?

      • i appreciate it a lot

        but i am a smoker, so i dont know if it counts

  • i probably would

    but i'd see it as a benefit these days. i dunno what i'd do if i didnt want to.

  • My ex asked me to stop,

    so I just lied and said that I had, it made smoking more fun anyway, with the whole covert operation surrounding it. She said it made her puke to think about it. Her current boyfriend smokes about 20 a day by my reckoning.

  • a tricky one for sure.

    but y'know, if you don't actually want to stop smoking yourself then you probably won't manage it.

  • Yes

    I would start and then I would stop, just to prove my love for her.

  • no, only if I wanted to

    but I would not do it around them, if they didn't like it.

  • i don't think i would ever go out with

    someone like that in the first place. maybe if we were married and my husband had a weak heart or something.

  • I don't smoke but my partner does

    It doesn't bother me that much, though he's considerate and smokes outside or away from me in general. I don't like it but I also don't want to force him to stop, that's his choice.

  • I think it would depend on the context really

  • No.

    But then I wouldn't get into a proper relationship with someone who clearly has a problem with it either.

    I was seeing a guy for seven months who decided to give up smoking himself near the end of the relationship, he turned into a right proper twat about it. Reformed smokers are the worst.

  • I can't believe some of the replies to this thread

    Someone's attitude towards smoking would affect whether you get into a relationship with them or not? That's quite sad.

    • well surely it's their attitude towards your own personal choices?

      • Not necessarily

        In fact probably not. I think that's just a smoker's way of construing the situation to make them feel better.

        • why is it not?

          • Because

            eww, mouths that taste of cigarettes.

            • depends on their personal hygiene then doesn't it?

              • I don't think anyone who smokes

                can manage to be completely devoid of the evidence *all* the time. Personally, I don't like it very much when someone smells or tastes of cigarettes, but if I knew someone was a smoker, I wouldn't automatically discount them as relationship material, and if it later turned out to be a problem, I'd take it up with them.

                • not all the time, no.

                  but from experience, a lot of people don't smell of it or taste of it. but then again a lot do. so... it's all relative really.

                  • Yes

                    In the "You smoke so you're going to die young" sense, I don't think I'd really care. Is that more what people are talking about? If you break up with someone because they smoke and you're concerned about their health, that's kind of self-defeating. But then, I probably wouldn't to be tied to someone with a hole in their throat. But then, I probably wouldn't worry about that just because someone smoked.

                • I do agree with you Zapsta.

                  Smoking IS gross and it does taste foul, so if I'm seeing someone who doesn't smoke I don't go near them without teeth brushing/washing hands/have windows wide open in my flat etc - I don't like the smell of it either, it mings.

                  However, consider this. You meet someone who is 5ft 5 and 12 stone in weight. You really like her. Six months in you decide to ask her if she can lose weight for you. But that's the way she's always been. You should accept and love people exactly for what they ARE, not what they COULD be. And if you like them for what they could be, that's just plain dumb. People only change if they want to change for themselves. If they try to change because someone's bullying them too, they'll only end up unhappy about the whole situation.

                  Does that make sense?

                  • I see your point

                    but smoking is more serious than being average? weight. Its detrimental to their health and as someone who cares for them wouldnt you want them to be healthy?

                    • Okay, perhaps that was a bad example.

                      I just don't believe in trying to change people in any way, shape or form, and most certainly not in the early stages of a relationship. It's no good loving someone for everything about them except for x y and z which you wish you could change but can't, because if you're already aware of things you'd like to change, you shouldn't really be in a relationship with them in the first place.

                      Faults and all, or nothing at all.

                      I agree with you regarding the health aspect though. But then you could say the same for a boyfriend who eats a fry up three times a week and you're worried about him having a heart attack.

                  • Is this where I say

                    that I once told a girl I'd go out with her if she lost some weight? No... No, it's definitely not where I say that.

                    • you said that to a girl?!

                      • Maybe... :$

                        If I did though, it was definitely a joke. She kept going on about how fat she was, when, even though she's a little bit on the plump side, she's definitely not fat, and then the topic of going out with her came up and I said "I'd go out with you if you lost some weight" and she laughed. SO THERE.

  • THAT'S STUPID

    sorrycaps.
    but it is, i hate seeign people trying to change thier boyfrined or girlfriend in silly trivial ways.
    i have to put up with girls making their boyfrieneds buy stupid clothes
    'dahling, youd look hott i nthis'

    yuck

  • i dont smoke

    but i wouldnt ask them to stop, id just dissaprove and make it clear i didnt like it much, but its their choice really, and if i really liked them whether they smoke or not wouldnt be a deal breaker.

    • ^ pretty much this

      except i would be a bit more overt in making it clear i didn't like it, and i would ask them why they smoke etc but would try not to make a big deal out of it.

  • On the converse,

    I wouldn't try and make a girlfriend start smoking and wouldn't expect her to try and stop me.

    That said, if it bugged her I'd take it as an extra incentive.

    • would you say things like

      'its really inconsiderate of you not to smoke, who am i suppose to steal smokes off when i dont have any'

      • I might make her carry some tabs for me incase I was robbed or something.

        • carry them so she;s tempted into smoking subconscious like?

          i like your style

          • Exactly, otherwise she'd have to admit to having such a loser

            for a boyfirend who made her carry his tabs when she doesn't smoke just incase he gets robbed.

            Fullerov, your friend's problem could not be more solved.

  • Back when I did smoke

    I reckon I would have perceived it as an attack on my lifestyle in a more general sense, and probably would have run a mile. I would have thought that this person would also have a problem with my drinking, might be upset by my relationship history. Basically, if this person can't cope with me having the odd ciggie, they're a bit clean cut to cope with me in general.

    I don't think I was really ready for a serious relationship then anyway.

    • does not smoking make you clean cut?

      im not sure if i agree

      • Of course not

        But telling a partner they had to stop is more than that - especially as in my case I was never that heavy of a smoker and would've been happy to avoid doing it when they were around.

  • Try using some lube

  • I hardly ever smoke, so I'd tell them to get lost

    If I was going out with someone I'd prefer that they didn't smoke, but I probably wouldn't ask them to stop unless it was someone I'd think about spending the rest of my life with. I don't really want to see someone I love die in a horrible way.

  • I don't smoke but I don't think your partner has the right to ask you not to do anything*

    If someone didn't want you to do something around then that's fair enough and I think I'd respect that but I don't feel they'd have any right to tell me what to do when they weren't around.

    *bar sleep with other people, obviously

  • I don't know

    If I really liked someone who doesn't smoke then obviously I can see how it would bother them. And frankly, I probably need to cut down anyway, so maybe I'll look for a non smoker just for an excuse to save my poor throat/lungs.

    This is a new low, even for me.

  • No.

  • every one of my exes has asked me to stop smoking

    and my current beau, but i think i probably should as i keep getting a cough that sounds suspiciously like i'm dying. oops.

  • yes

    assuming I was really keen on her, which I'd like to think I would be if I was in a relationship. I don't smoke fags and only smoke weed out of boredom or with friends, and I could quite easily knock it on the head if I had the incentive.

  • i did it to try and make someone my boyfriend

    if that counts...

    ...which is kind of pathetic, but hey, i've quit for almost 6 weeks!

    {and he's still not my boyfriend}

    i have had boyfriends in the past who have wanted me to quit who i certainly cared about wayyyy more than i do this guy, but i guess i wasn't ready to quit then. i kind of wanted to anyway this time.

  • I probably wouldn't if I'm honest,

    I mean surely it's a bit much to expect someone to quit just because their bf/gf has asked them too. I know I couldn't quit unless I actually wanted too and was committed to quitting; you've got to believe in what you're doing to do it.

    Also there's a bit of an issue of personal liberty here; it's somewhat nannying (for want of a better word) to try and get someone to quit if they don't want to. People should be free to do as they please, within reason.