Drowned in Sound

Search



songs by artists that will only be remmbered for cover verisons

29 votes
?
by moonwolf

ok songs that where writen and performed by some but will only be rembered for someone`s cover them for example

hurt- johnney cash
knocking on heavens door- guns and roses
etc
what song do you think

moonwolf | 24 Mar '08, 12:20 | Send note | Report this | Reply

May I be teh first to say

Definite troll.


re: no.2

Bollocks.


I agree with neither of those

But I can see where you're coming from

my suggestion would be Klaxons version of Not Over Yet. Who the fuck is gonna remember Grace?


The Futureheads

will always be the novelty Kate Bush band. Poor sods.


anyone

with a set of ears, a brain and a long-wave receiver?


FACT: the only Dylan cover that's better than the original is

'I'll keep it with mine' as performed by Fairport Convention.


Hallelujah

will always be remembered for the Jeff Buckley cover and not the Leonard Cohen original.


1234 by Feist

Originally by Sally Seltmann


.

Wasn't 1234 co-written with Sally Seltmann? I don't think Sally Seltmann has performed it.


ish

"I had been listening to Feist's album Let It Die. I thought my little song about lost love, and the hope to recapture what you once had, sounded too much like a Feist song for me to use for New Buffalo, so I shelved it. Then, in late 2005 I did a tour across Canada supporting Feist, and Broken Social Scene. After meeting Feist, I started to wonder whether she might like to do a cover of "1234," but I was too shy to tell her about it. At the last Broken Social Scene show, I plucked up the courage to tell her that I had written a song which I thought she might like to use. We went onto the tour bus, and I recorded a simple version of the song into her laptop, with guitar and vocals. To my surprise, she loved the song, and started playing it live."

cute story and I think she made a good choice as Feist etc helped turn it into the best song of last year.


Happy Mondays' "Step on" of course.

and indeed Toploader's version of "Dancing in the Moonlight".


Heart Shaped Box

by the Vichy Government?

History will prove me right...


do you mean....

Gloria Jones - Tainted Love?


Errrr....yes and no!

I thought the point was to name the artist who would be most remembered for the song rather than the original?


gary jules

mad world (tears for fears)

the enemy - we'll live and die in these towns (the jam)


You are kidding about The Enemy right?

everyone will soon forget about them, they will be a small blip.


read that again


aaah, thanks.

I'm not at all clued up on The Enemy, maybe if Dis ran more news stories on them I would have understood first time round :-)


well

the vichy govt certainly have more talent and charisma than nirvanna. so. i can see that.

but. isnt kate bush's hounds of love already quite popular and famous. same with mad world if you hang around in the right circles.

as for bob dylan. i think that most of his songs are better when covered. see the byrds.

i think, led zeppelin have immortalised the most here probably. A lot of their songs are just old blues classics reworked. as many bands did. But whenever anyone thinks of the hunter, its Led Zeppelins version that springs out, not say. Free, who also did a nice version. And Led Zep have that with a fair few songs i reckon


The Byrds' versions of Dylan songs are limp and without character

apart from 'You ain't going nowhere'.

The 'hounds of love' point was that the Futureheads will only be remembered for doing that song, not that theirs will be its definitive version.

Led Zep smell


Tiffany

I think we're alone now.


Dare I suggest.....

..... "Such great heights" - Iron & Wine


as the postal service

album is sub pops biggest selling album ever (as in over nirvana's bleach), you'd be wrong.


You're joking, right?

I'd certainly never heard of the original.


Depends what social

solar systems you orbit, i imagine.


I misunderstood the question....

I thought it was asking what songs will artists be known by, that aren't their own songs.


probably "Heartbeats" by Jose Gonzalez

seeing as the Knife album it's on is so average (esp. compared to Silent Shout) that no-one listens to it any more


i listen to it, its ace

nobody listens to jose gonzalez do they?


yeah

heartbeats is deffo the kinfe in my head. i have only heard the jose version twice


I thought it was thde Knife

covering Jose Gonzalez for ages.


Bridge Over Troubled Water

because who's going to remember Simon & Garfunkel over Hear'Say?


clearly badfinger's

without you, as immortalised by mariah carey. who can honestly hear "i can't live, if living is without you" by anyone other than mariah carey. even though welsh rockers badfinger wrote it and others (including nilsson and bonnie prince billy) have covered it.


^ nicely written

tabloidese FTW!


oh and apparently

the zuton's valerie as done by amy(last of the summer)winehouse and mark ronson. not my wordds but that of others like the radio and free london papers etc


I think the original version is lovely.

Whereas Wino's is strong contender for most irritating song of last year.


the zuton's song was i thought

a massive hit but apparently it is easily forgotten. thats the radio crowd for you.


hmm

American Idol - Float On


^dyslexic duck?

Nirvana covering Meat Puppets' Lake of Fire.


'Louie Louie' by Richard Berry & the Pharoahs

made more famouser by the Kingsmen


I dunno why

but I always thought no one knew where Louie Louie came from, huh? Ok, now I know.


there's a lot of myths about the song

there's an album called 'Love That Louie' on Ace Records which has about 25 versions of the song, its antcedents and followers, including the first cd issue of the original. It has liner notes covering the song's development, FBI investigation etc. it's brilliant.


sinead

oconnors nothing compares 2 u will be remembered more than the prince orignial


^ misread the question

Thought you said bands that will only be remembered for their cover versions!


URGE OVERKILL

Girl You'll Be A Woman Soon

orignally be Neil (who?) Diamond

which is a reet shame as UO have some very classy tunes of their own. I blame Uma Thurman.


teardrop

i dislike the way many have had a 'dig' at covering massive attack's classic. elbow, jose gonzales, even newton faulkner, im sure there are others. perhaps its only so irritating because i view the original with such high regard.


when the huntsmen comes a-marchin'

the chris tt original is the worst version of this that i've heard and i wouldn't be surprised if more people have heard frank turner cover it than have heard the original.


that song that was covered

by that donnie darko man at christmas the other year


nirvana-the man who sold the world

by a generation anyway.





© DrownedinSound.com | From the Archive - Some Questions: The Hedrons