Sign In: or Sign Up! (forgotten password?)
Drowned in Sound

It's inevitable really.
Which albums will be looked back upon in the '10s and '20s as classics of the decade?

I think those Arctic Monkeys ones probably will by most.
Funeral by Arcade Fire is a definate. It is loved by so many, has affected a lot of people and also influenced a lot of bands.

Cult album of the decade?

DiScuss, I guess...

BoyNamedTim | 22 Jan '08, 20:33 | Send note | Report this | Reply



...

You just blew my mind. With retardidity.

haha

yeah.

'worst thread everr.'
/comic book store guy.

corrected myself below

yeah, safe

good word

battles mirrored

.

Lift To Experience: The Texas Jerusalem Crossroads

yes!!

but 99?

*What is the

cult album of the decade?

(Not saying Arcade Fire was.)

*is.)

it's just not my day today

Ys

In Rainbows
Funeral

And in terms of "indie classics" that people on the DiS of the future will out-nerd each other over deatils of...

Probably For hero: for fool and grizzly bear and the national and stuff like that.

Fullerov's already prepared

his out-nerding answer. It's good to rehearse these things.

What, The Texas-Jerusalem Cross Roads?

It was all over TV and radio in 2001. I'm surprised you can't remember.

'In Rainbows' is a poor album

where Radiohead seem to generally abandon anything that has ever marked them as special. It's a limp handshake of a record, and I don't believe it'll ever stand up as a classic. They've made at least three of those, though, so hardly fair to complain.

For Hero: For Fool on the other hand is amazing!

*wieners

sorry

The Wieners?

Sounds like a NOFX support band.

Boy in da Corner

...but wait, it's already a classic.

It'll probably be a forgotten masterpiece come 20 years time.

^ this

brilliant album

-

Kid A
Lift Yr Skinny Fists
Is This It
Funeral

Lift Yr Skinny Fists...

a classic

YES

That album will go down in time, man.

hopefully

The Last Broadcast

but i think i'm the only person going for this :S

100% agree!!

This album always sounds totally outstanding every time I hear it...

Yeah

I hope so too.

Me too

Shame Some Cities was such a disappointment.

There are several that

while perhaps not regarded as strongly by the DiSees of the future, should be looked upon favourably:

Turn On The Bright Lights
Funeral
Boy In Da Corner
Kala
They Threw Us All In A Trench And Stuck A Monument On Top
Fever To Tell
Parachutes
Kid A
Ys
Whatever People Say...
Speakerboxxx/The Love Below
Elephant
Franz Ferdinand
Mirrored
Soulja Boy Tell Em

SBXXX/TLB

is a flawless album but where is Stankonia on that list? I think that may be the best rap album ever recorded.

but YES! I agree with everything on your list! except the obvious.

especially titillated by: Liars, Arctic Monkeys, M.I.A. and Battles picks

Tom Waits 'Orphans'

Surely.....its a work of genius.

no.

it's marred by the fact that he's made much.better.records.

probably

This? Well maybe the top 10.
http://www.drownedinsound.com/articles/1254995

We forgot like The Streets 'Original Pirate Material' and obviously a lot has been released since like Panda Bear and also The Field (which had it been reviewed last year would have been in our albums of the year but wasn't included in a technicality)

bLOLc party

don't think so

no classics in the 00s so far

...

funeral

kid a
relationship of command
lift yr skinny fists

yeah

.

De-Loused In The Comatorium
Elephant
Funeral
Is This It
Kid A
Melody A.M
The Moon And Antartica
Neon Bible
Relationship Of Command
Turn On The Bright Lights

Any Other City (lwb)

erm, Is This It.
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not.
Up The Bracket?

I'm shocked

at no mention of Yankee Hotel Foxtrot yet.

And Neon Bible...please, please no.

YHF

seconded.

And also

Figure 8 by Elliott Smith.

I think

basement on a hill is better.
Also Funeral, Antics, Alligator, maybe Boxer, Decline of BSP and I think Make Up the breakdown is better than is this it? and return to cookie mountain

Yankee would probably be my favourite album of the decade

but there's a subtle difference between my favourite and what I think the best records are.

About YHF...

Sometimes I cannot help but think that the album's myth and the story behind it inflates the quality of the album's content. It's not Wilco's best record (that title belongs to Summerteeth), but still rather essential in understanding the decade.

Elephant,

Original Pirate Material

come on feel the illinois

still sounds fantastic 2 or 3 years later. Also, no-ones mentioned Silent Alarm I don't think, although not sure that's quite a classic.

And agree with Relationship of Command, Kid A, Ys, Funeral, Is This It

....

either arcade fire album
a coldplay album
in rainbows
a bloc party album

that would be quite depressing

in a number of ways

bloc party?

really? nah.

......

there not my choices,there what i think will be,whether its a bloc party album thats been made yet or not i dunno???

but i do like bloc party alot

neon bibble had three good songs on it

so, no.

i do not

agree.

...

Obvious ones;
Funeral
Kid A
Boy in Da Corner
Original Pirate Material
I dunno, maybe Rounds or Pause?

Deserving ones;
Ys
Yank Crime
The Power Out
Thunder, Lightning, Strike
Leviathan
The Civil War (Matmos)
Body Riddle
maaaaybe Ultravisitor

I Phantom by Mr Lif

deserves more attention, at least

^^yeah

that is a great album,i lost it when my old computer fucked up then forgot bout it

Yeah

But also Labor Days by Aesop Rock should be included

...

Ultravisitor is too good to be regarded as a classic by the lumpen mass of soulless, dead eyed consumerplebs.

They can have Ys, though.

^

Ys really isn't that great

...

What's not to love about 75 minutes of harp music accompanied by a woman with the voice of a wasp on a window?

Yank Crime

came out in 1994.

For me;

Lift Yr Skinny Fists
Kid A
Confield
Drum's Not Dead
No Kill No Beep Beep
()
Hold Your Horse Is
Rossz Csillag Allat Született
Untrue
and something by Animal Collective... Feels

i hear

no kill no beep beep

^ oops, you're right about yank crime

I lose masses of points on that one.

In my defense I was just going off my itunes 'year' entries, and since I have the reissue, from 2002, it got in there.

FOOL

JESUS CHRIST

FINALLY

That's the first Leviathan I've seen so far

it's making me feel very un-indie

that i haven't even heard of at least a third of the albums mentioned so far :/

Boys And Girls In America

by The Hold Steady.

Anyone mentioned that yet?

Nope

It's not exactly of it's time...

Of course

we can't really say yet. Most will probably be established but unremarkable bands that are yet to go on to unexpectedly great success and artists who'll die unexpectedly young.

If i may suggest a couple in other categories..

Aphex Twin - Drukqs
Soulwax - Nite versions

Glassjaw - Everything you ever wanted to know about silence
Deftones - White Pony

(i agree with many already mentiones too.

In an ideal world, people would remember...

...And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead: Worlds Apart.
Holly Valance: State of Mind.
Rammstein: Mutter.
Rival Schools: United by Fate.
Sonic Youth: Sonic Nurse.
Silversun Pickups: Carnavas.
t.A.T.u.: 200 KM/H in the Wrong Lane.
Vanilla Ninja: Vanilla Ninja.

Not exactly going to happen, though.

WAIT A SECOND

Sonic Nurse isn't that bad!
Don't be dissin'

Who said I was?

It's in some elite company there, after all.

Yeah

all I saw was Worlds Apart and I assumed the worse. Sorry bout that.

also...

Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Things We Lost In the Fire
Agaetis Byrjun (technically the 90s perhaps)
Fever to Tell

hmm

whilst its good, its not their best = not going to be remembered...

Kid A / In Rainbows
Funeral
Ys
Turn On The Bright Lights
Fever To Tell
Up The Bracket
Sound Of Silver (believe it)
ALLIGATOR
Is This It
Asleep In The Back

I think:

Funeral
Mirrored
Ys
( )
Lift Your Skinny Fists...
Turn on the Bright Lights
Apologies to the Queen Mary
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning
The Arctic Monkeys ones
Silent Alarm probably will too
meh

Also,

Demon Days by Gorillaz.
I truly think it is an amazing record.

...as well as all the other obvious ones everyone has already said that i missed out.

oh and

how could i forget?:

Now Here is Nowhere by Secret Machines.

Alligator

Chutes Too Narrow
Back To Bedlam

scissor sisters

kaiser chiefs
razorlight
lily allen

you can work out the names, i dont know em

*

Leviathan - Mastodon
Apologies To Queen Mary - Wolf Parade
The Decline Of... - British Sea Power
Is This It - The Strokes
Bows And Arrows - The Walkmen

this is it.

These New Puritans = Beat Pyramid.

The following

Michael Mayer - Immer
Luomo - Vocalcity
Jens Lekman - When I Said I Wanted To Be Your Dog

LOVE EM.

I have no idea.

I'm out of touch.

However I would hope that these in someway scratch the surface of musical history

Relationship of Command
The Argument
De-Loused In The Comatorium
Nurse
Mono
Desperate Youth, Bloodthirsty Babes
Fantastic Damage
Pink

oh and something by DEP

Probably Miss Machine.

Nah

it'll be Calculating Infinity.

Also Jane Doe, Full Collapse and Yellow House.

No one mentioned The Sophtware Slump?

Or is that already regarded as a classic?

skinnyman

council estate of mind maybe

i doubt it

one good track doesnt make an album

yeah

prob not a classic -just felt thread was bit indi-centric.

hmmm... rap classics in the noughties

the listening - little brother
unplugged - jay-z
supreme clientele - ghostface
the college dropout - kanye
the cold vein - cannibal ox
the unseen - quasimoto
operation doomsday - mf doom

and i guess probably some dilla, madlib and weezy will all be considered classics in years to come

you forgot

el-p's fantastic damage, fool. And Saul Williams self titled. And I do believe Liquid Swords was released in 2001, no?

true el-p should be on there

but "ill sleep when your dead" surely?

no liquid swords was mid 90s

Kid A

In rainbows
Come On Feel The Ilinoise
I am a bird now
funeral
The Trials of Van Occupanther
Yankee hotel foxtrot

"Come On Feel The Ilinoise"

no album of this name exists.

People really like

In Rainbows, then...

Scouting for Girls.

Elliot Minor.

Seriously though,

Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Thunder Lightning Strike

.....

Kid A
Deloused in the Comatorium
Chutes too Narrow
The Sunset Tree
Lateralus

..

Is This It
Silent Alarm
Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots
Funeral

i truly believe

in ten years The Great Destroyer will be viewed as one of the best albums of the 00s.

Not forgetting

No Cities Left by The Dears.

mm

3-4 tracks were classics, but too much filler.
Set Yourself On Fire, possibly.
Leviathan too, and Boy In Da Corner

oh wait

when was "In The Aeroplane.." released?

Vertigo of Bliss

Effloresce
Sleep and Release

/obligatory Biff' 'Size 'Gramme trifecta.

these:

Funeral
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning
Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
Transatlanticism
Picaresque
Sound Of Silver
Good News For People Who Love Bad News
Absolution
Give Up
Chutes Too Narrow
Final Straw
Fourteen Autumns And Fifteen Winters

Ideally

Drukqs
A grand don't come for free
Funeral
Relationship of Command
Brian Wilson: Smile
White Pony
The Exploding Hearts: Guitar Romantic
Blueberry Boat
The Argument
Blood Mountain
Hissing Fauna...
Songs for the Deaf
Picaresque
Chutes too narrow
Come on feel the illinoise

Realistically: In Rainbows, Lily Allen, Is This It, Up the bracket.

Where's the justice!

Drum's Not Dead

I can see Liars going on for years, and in future decades, Drum's Not Dead will be seen as their 'EVOL' or 'Sister'... i.e utterly brilliant kinda defining piece of work that, in itself, influences future artists.

Yeah, well, you know...

FOR SURE

Also:

stars of the lid and their refinement of the decline
frances the mute by the mars volta (my favorite record)
anything mastodon came up with
and that damned hissing fauna album! (I've seen that a few times already)

Potentially the following:

Up the Bracket
Silent Alarm
Is This It (meh)
Funeral
Origin Of Symmetry (why has no-one mentioned it?)
Absolution
Blood Mountain
Songs For The Deaf
Kid A
The Arctic Monkeys Albums (meh)

And some pop rubbish that I can't be bothered to write about, like Blunt, Winehouse etc.

Some people seem to be mentioning bands that I'm not even that familiar with, strange that they could be classics.

...And Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots.

Great album, I'm ashamed I left it out.

my guesses

well i guess that i would say
Is this it
Kala
boy in the corner or showtime with dizze
the warning
elephant
and just because i´am swedish i got to say
oh, you´re so silent jens or the new school.

Madvilliany

Ys

Deloused and/or Frances The Mute

Kid A

Relationship of Command

Boy In Da Corner

Original Pirate Material SHOULD be, but i fear people would regard A Grand Don't Come For Free (they'd be wrong)

Lift Yr Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven

Hard.

Relationship of Command
Sophtware Slump
In Rainbows
Rated R
Funeral

And if there's any justice:

Zero for Conduct
Vertigo of Bliss
No Kill No Beep Beep
You're a Woman, I'm a Machine

Some definate. Some ideal

100 Broken Windows
Happy Songs For Happy People
The Fall of Math
Mirrored
Funeral
Kid A
In Rainbows
Relationship of Command
Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots
What Are Friends For (...I'm sure of this)
Person Pitch
Elephant
Silent Alarm
Whatever People Say etc etc etc

Some more:

Badly Drawn Boy - Hour Of Bewilderbeast
Frog Eyes - The Golden River
Band Of Horses - Everything All The Time
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago

I second: Ys, Yoshimi, Sophtware Slump, Leviathan, Is This It?, Bows and Arrows

Gulag Orkestar

I ctrl+f'ed this and was shocked. SHOCKED!

Whay doesnt anyone agree?

It's a classic!
CLASSIC, i tell you!

i'm gonna say

up the bracket has influenced lots of music good and shit, and the mindset of too many teenagers from where i'm from

but is this it also helped that

funeral is also incredible, but cult album ? big cult if they can play 2nd on the bill at reading...

elephant

boy in the corner was to hip hop what up the bracket was to rock

artic monkeys

then for the emo kids funeral for a friends first album (casually dressed and deep cuts into my veins)

for the general public: lily allen and james Blcunt

there's a few that come straight into my mind, if i was older i might be able to give a better opinion, having seen the music scene at the start of the decade from a more mature perspective

Is This It

is the album of the decade.

It set a precedent which has gradually got worse and worse, but its the strongest set of songs on an album since Definitely Maybe.

Everyone's getting their White Stripes

albums mixed up. White Blood Cells for sure, not Elephant though. Its got about 5 different versions of 'Dead Leaves' on it, which, although being brilliant, aren't 'classic' material.

Also no to Funeral. It doesn't sound different enough. That might sound silly since I've cited the Strokes earlier, but it sounds really similar to stuff gone before. It didn't say anything. It was nice and pretty, but it didn't have much of an impact, did it?

what the

who are similar to arcade fire ? that came before them obv

they do a version of the libertines but with a massively expanded set of instruments ?

The Arcade Fire's

album doesn't have the potential to really open my eyes and make me think 'Christ, that's good'.

Libs and Strokes debuts did.

that probably has something to do with this thing called taste

i'm not a huge arcade fire fan myself, but i can recognise that they're pretty important in that they've probably influenced a lot of stuff i do like, and i definitely wouldn't accuse them of 'not sounding different enough'.

pretty much my thoughts...

I'm rather indifferent to Funeral myself, by I know why people like it (it has passion, pathos, universal themes) and I won't argue about it.

Neon Bible though....I'll gladly argue about that one.

i

only have elephant

:)

yes i do realise i should have white blood cells...

hmm

i'd say the strokes were the ramones if the libertines were the sex pistols (if you wanna say that the latter two did messey version of the previous thing)

that sounds absolutely totally stupid to someone who is used to analysing music really deeply (as a music student)

when were s club 7 around?

i hope beast moans becomes a classic

well

s club 7 are next to slayer on my media player

but funnily enough, i don't think they deserve a mention in this thread...

^

if you listed the 100 greatest albums of all time, only one of them would be from this decade.

Only if you possess the overtly romanticised view of the 60's, 70's and 80's that magazines tend to

An unbiased opinion of actual 'good music' would find just as many from each decade.

hmm

What would generally be regarded as classics in Q magazine polls and the like in a few years...

The Strokes - This is It
The Libertines - Up The Bracket
a Muse album...i'd imagine either Origin of Symmetry or Absolution.
Boy In the Corner - Dizzie Rascal

Perhaps you can add Kid A to that list as well. I fucking hate the strokes and the libertines but i know full well that they will be in polls and all sorts years from now. I would bet money on it, actually...

Ones that to me are regarded as classics already...but perhaps won't be regarded the same way by the majority of people/press

Aphex Twin - Drukqs
TV on the Radio - Return to Cookie Mountain
Liars - Drum's Not Dead
The Knife - Silent Shout
Outkast - Speakerboxxx/The Love Below
The Cooper Temple Clause - Both albums!

Just my opinion yo.

I'm surprised by faintly pleased by the love for Drukqs in this thread.

I don't reckon it's good enough myself, but i'm very pleased to see Aphex get a mention anyway. Here's hoping he makes a more worthwhile contribution soon. There's still time James!

*but faintly pleased

grrrrr

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot

pwns most albums on here, most certainly both Arcade Fire albums and the Shins ones. I'm surprised it hasn't been mentioned yet.

My little list

Arcade Fire - Funeral
Saul Williams - s/t
Broken Social Scene - You Forgot It in People
Dizze Rascal - Boy In Da Corner